Front Diff gear wear question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 27, 2003
Threads
490
Messages
9,929
Location
North Cadillac
I have my front end apart and was cleaning up my front diff. I noticed the strange marks on the front ring gear teeth.

What's the opinion on this? Something to worry about?
IMG_6035.webp

IMG_6034.webp
 
Yes. Your bearings are worn seriously and you should consider new gears. They probably "sing" while driving and they are also have a huge amount of wear on the toe, indicating the bearings are worn and the pinion is moving.

I believe you are running a risk of failure soon. Will they run for a while? Yes, probably. Are you installing new bearings? If yes, then install new gears. Install an ARB or a Harrop at the same time. Fixes it all........
 
I have an ARB in there. The ARB was installed about 5 years ago. I have it apart because my front diff was leaking. In the process of cleaning it up i saw those marks on the teeth.

I have not heard any noise from the gears. But obviously something is not the way it should. Thank you for the reply.
 
Alex-I agree that's very odd wear. Can you run a pattern with gear paint?

But whatever is going on, it isn't good, and sending to @gearinstalls.com "ZUK" gets my vote too. He can advise you if you need a new ring and pinion. As a side benefit, he can rebuild your airlocker good as new. He recently did this for me.

I think you're buying a new set of gears at a minimum, but it's probably time for a full rebuild of the ARB and diff.
 
Can you get a shot of the pinion as well?
 
Id guess there either was something on one of the pinion teeth or one of the pinion teeth are deformed or have a burr or something. The wear mark is on every tooth because the number of teeth on the gearset are coprime and will always eventually mesh with one another.
 
OK, you guys confirmed what i was suspecting. Darn!!

Here is the crappy part... obviously you have to take the whole front end apart to get the diff out.... i'm heading to the beach to camp for a long weekend on labor day. So, i doubt i can get the gears, send to zuk, get them back, put it all together before then. So, it looks like i'll have to put everything together only to take it apart again..... DAMN!
 
OK, you guys confirmed what i was suspecting. Darn!!

Here is the crappy part... obviously you have to take the whole front end apart to get the diff out.... i'm heading to the beach to camp for a long weekend on labor day. So, i doubt i can get the gears, send to zuk, get them back, put it all together before then. So, it looks like i'll have to put everything together only to take it apart again..... DAMN!
DUUUDE, Labor day weekend is like a month away! If you do choose ZUK for the r&r, I would contact him asap...good luck CJ
 
Just dont blow it up on the beach!

Always wanted to drive a sc rig with 4.88s to compare. Just sayin' :D
 
Take your 200!
 
Take your 200!
RTT, fridge, slides, solar panels, drawers and tons of yellow lab hair not including the salt water, just don't sound appealing to me on my nice 200!!

Trust me, i thought about it. haha
 
Just dont blow it up on the beach!

Always wanted to drive a sc rig with 4.88s to compare. Just sayin' :D

I hear that, but i think highway cruising with a SC for 13 hours at a time at 80 MPH just isn't right with 4.88. I've got T-case gears for nice crawling speeds... just need to install those too.
 
@concretejungle - There's a picture of you on the North Rim holding a pinion flange in your hand. Was that the front diff, and if so, what was going on at the time?
 
@concretejungle - There's a picture of you on the North Rim holding a pinion flange in your hand. Was that the front diff, and if so, what was going on at the time?
actually that was from slick rock camp ground. My front pinion seal went out so i replaced it..... I completely forgot about that.

This was after we had departed from you guys after the hole in the rock trip. Drove back to Moab and ran poison spider. When we got back into camp that day i had a leak and it was the the seal at the stake nut. Good memory! I'm wondering now if that's the culprit.
 
@jfz80 sent me this gem and reminded me that was the rear that was leaking. So, nothing was wrong with the front diff.

Thanks Jason!

IMG_5775.webp
 
So i took the front diff back to East Coast Gear supply in Raleigh, NC. They are the ones who installed the ARB for me and when i sent them the pictures via email they said bring it in. Seem like a really good, stand-up operation. I'll be interested to see what they say, but right out of the gate they said the bearing feels bad. BUT, he wasn't not convinced the gears are toast. He said they are probably fine since the grove is not in the wear pattern area of the gear. We will see once the guy in the shop tears it down and assesses it.

I'm considering getting them to swap out the ARB for a Harrop locker. This is simply because ever since i've installed the ARB i've had oil issues. Either oil coming up into the arb compressor or constant birf soup leaks. Seems like the diff is pressurizing. That's a hunch at least. I've already replaced the o-ring in it from ARB and that hasn't changed anything. So, they are going to pressure test it and see if it's leaking at all.

Will report back.
 
Not that I know for sure, but...

Based on the several thousand drive axles I built at Dana, you need a new gearset. Yes, the wear is on the coast side, but the tooth strength calculation is based on the whole tooth thickness (albeit at the root, but in practice the whole tooth gets used) and your teeth aren't full thickness. The reason you haven't heard anything is that the wear isn't on the drive side (or you would have heard it sing). My guess is that during setup, someone royally screwed up, and put it in anyway, knowing a) you wouldn't see it and b) you wouldn't hear it, until a tooth broke under extreme load. Then, during failure analysis, someone well meaning someone would suspect, and claim, that the tooth damage was due to the breakage and dismiss it entirely. Yes, I'm very cynical; I also spent a couple of years in root cause failure analysis, trying to prove the axles I built were actually good when they left my line.

That having been said, while it's apart have a new set installed and make sure, if you're not there, you get pictures of the gear contact print that's done to confirm the backlash before they bolt everything up. That's the only way you'll ever know that the gearset was installed properly.
 
Back
Top Bottom