Front Bearing Exploded!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Sep 23, 2006
Threads
26
Messages
653
Location
Crawl-o-rado
So, I drove from work to get some lunch today, about 2 blocks. As I drove back to work, I got into the left turn lane, applied my brakes, and heard this popping, and then some grinding as my cruiser pulled hard right. I lost most of the power to my brakes as well, came to a stop, made my turn, and brakes were still weak. Drove around the block at work, after getting out and checking fluid level in brake reservoir, and condition of lines/possibility of leaks around wheels, front and rear. Everything was clean and checked out okay. No lights on dash about brakes, and no further noise from anywhere. And as I drove around the block, the power to my brakes eemed to even out again. So I drove home, about 18 mi on the highway.

Got home, and as I pulled in the driveway, heard a little bit of grinding as I turned right. Pulled the cruiser in the back, put it up on stands, felt the front hubs. Left was warm, right was too hot to keep a finger on it for more than a second. Let that cool down a little, and called ToothFairy. Started to take apart the front hub, burning my fingers, and found an interesting paste inside. Collected some of this substance, and found that it was indeed magnetic, very magnetic. So I know that axle grease, in and of itself, is not magnetic, therefore I have a problem.

Took off the hub nuts and the flat inner washer was spun on the spindle. Got that lined up again, thanks Butch, and off. Saw that I indeed had no more of anything that resembles a roller bearing. I have the outer and inner races of the outer bearing, and empty space. Pushed the hub back on as far as I could get it, rotated, and the rear bearing still seems okay. However, the inner race of the bearing seems to be welded onto the spindle shaft.

How do I get this thing off, without being myself and beating the living bujeezes out of it? I thought about using a torch, but is that really a good idea? Should I grind the races down until i can get the hub and rotor to pass the inner race? Do I need to take the entire knuckle off? I really need some help here.
 
I had the same thing happen to me but it was on a trailer. I had to grind the race that was friction welded to the spindle off. the way I did it was to grind through the race all the way accross until I got down to the spindle in two places 180 degrees apart. Then I was able to peal the race off of the spindle by beating the living **** out of it with a chisle and a hammer. very time consuming and it really sucked but it did work out well for me.
 
I think you are experiencing what I did a few months ago. Thread here:
https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=162109

When I talked to the tech who did the work he said he almost got to torching them out but decided not to because it was likely to compromise the integrity of the axle. Instead I believe he tried notching one out with a file, which worked but was slow. The other one I want to say he got out with some SST not designed for the job but which worked well. I know thats not much help, but in the end he did get them out.
 
I had the same thing happen to me but it was on a trailer. I had to grind the race that was friction welded to the spindle off. the way I did it was to grind through the race all the way accross until I got down to the spindle in two places 180 degrees apart. Then I was able to peal the race off of the spindle by beating the living **** out of it with a chisle and a hammer. very time consuming and it really sucked but it did work out well for me.

I did the same thing. Trailer wheel popped completely off (luckily not on the highway). The grinding/cold chisel worked well.
 
Well, if I owned a camera, then I probably could post pics. I don't, so I can't. Do I have to post pics to even get much of anyone to look at my posts? It is really starting to seem like it. I get 4 replies on a problem that has completely incapacitated my cruiser, and not much else. Thank you guys for your help, those that have. This is really pissing me off right now.
 
Well, if I owned a camera, then I probably could post pics. I don't, so I can't. Do I have to post pics to even get much of anyone to look at my posts? It is really starting to seem like it. I get 4 replies on a problem that has completely incapacitated my cruiser, and not much else. Thank you guys for your help, those that have. This is really pissing me off right now.

Relax man. There isn't much we can do to help you here until you tear it down as far as possible. If you take the wheel off and use a puller on the hub (or just yank on it for awhile) it will pop the seal and bearing off the back of the hub, and then you can pull the hub off.

Once you get it cleaned up, try some of the above suggestions, or borrow a camera to post a pic. We can't see things on your truck, and imagination only goes so far.

Personally, I'd use a propane torch or MAPP gas to try to heat the ring up enough to slide off.....

Good Luck,

Dan
 
:whoops:I'm grateful for the suggestions, and I know it is nearly impossible to give me really good advice without pictures. Again, I thank you guys for your suggestions, and I'm trying to figure out how to implement them. I don't own an acetylene torch, do you really think MAPP gas would get hot enough to work? I'll give it a try.

Should I just bite the bullet and order a new hub, spindle, and all the bearings and seals/gaskets? Is it pretty much a lost cause to try and salvage the hub or spindle? The only time I've dealt with a bearing race being welded to a spindle is on a semi-trailer axle. I know it makes a difference when you're dealing with a solid spindle that is ~2" thick.

I tried the gear puller, a screw-type one. I weigh about 250, and I was leaning on the thing, and nothing was happening. Am I going to need to take off the entire knuckle if the MAPP gas doesn't work?
 
I wasn't suggesting that it was a lost cause--I'm just lazy.
I'm kind of assuming the spindle might be a little screwed-up by a likely spinning race, maybe more screwed-up through the removal process(?). Factor the labor of getting the race off the spindle, and possibly fixing up the worn spindle against the cost of a new spindle that bolts on and off in less time than it takes to drink a beer. Might be a ridiculous comparison that I should be flogged for.

I didn't get the impression that there was anything wrong with the hub.
 
1. Post pics for our entertainment.
:popcorn:

2. Get a spindle
a. High budget, call CruiserDan
b. Low budget, call IRBIS

3. Get bearings, seals and grease. CruiserDan would have all of it and likely be able to rattle off the parts you'll need faster than you can look them up to order anywhere else.

4. Tear it down all the way, repack the birfs, replace the rest of the bearings and ALL grease. Otherwise I'd be worried about leaving shavings inside bearings... bad.

5. Send us lots of pictures for our entertainment.
:popcorn:

YMMV
 
Last edited:
Hammer, chisel, hacksaw, grinder. Ckeck and go...
You can always order the new stuff at todays prices and change them out in 10years if you burn up another one.

Check the other side.
 
:whoops:I'm grateful for the suggestions, and I know it is nearly impossible to give me really good advice without pictures. Again, I thank you guys for your suggestions, and I'm trying to figure out how to implement them. I don't own an acetylene torch, do you really think MAPP gas would get hot enough to work? I'll give it a try.

Should I just bite the bullet and order a new hub, spindle, and all the bearings and seals/gaskets? Is it pretty much a lost cause to try and salvage the hub or spindle? The only time I've dealt with a bearing race being welded to a spindle is on a semi-trailer axle. I know it makes a difference when you're dealing with a solid spindle that is ~2" thick.

I tried the gear puller, a screw-type one. I weigh about 250, and I was leaning on the thing, and nothing was happening. Am I going to need to take off the entire knuckle if the MAPP gas doesn't work?
If you read my thread, the tech working on my car ordered all new stuff 'just in case' not sure if he would be able to get them off. He did, and ultimately he left the decision up to me but thought it would be somewhat risky to leave the old stuff on. Considering the impeccable callback response of the dealership I was at, I didn't feel like he was lying, and after having a look-see at the leftover parts I was mighty glad I had him replace everything.

Just order the stuff as spares if you want. I suspect if you do get the race off you may still feel like you should replace. And squash is right on the money with the check the other side comment.

For whatever reason both of mine decided to go at 20k miles after being repacked. One side was completely gone and the other was about to go completely as well. Ended up replacing everything on both sides and I'm glad I did; having to worry about a front wheel coming off on at speed on a truck as unwieldy as the 80 series is not a pleasant though.
 
I would love to know what causes it...

Is it contaminated lubricant? An unnoticed manufacturing defect (I doubt this though because both of mine were failing ~ the same time). In my case they were not over their service interval and I hadn't had any signs they were going to fail, they just abruptly seized. There was no play in the bearings beforehand, and if it was a preload issue I would certainly think it would have happened well before I got 20k miles on them.

The only thing I wonder is I made the first ~600mile continuous trip since I had owned the cruiser (everything was ~140 miles to/from school) and it failed after I got back on the interstate and cruised at decent speed. Still I've not been able to resolve what would cause the failure, so those of you smarter than I, any ideas?
 
It's bad voodoo from hanging out with ToothFairy. His cruiser consumes all the good karma from your cruiser through osmosis.

End result, you get repair bills, he gets a 300,000 mile gem.

Jay
 
I meant use the puller on the hub to get the hub and rotor out of your way. The only thing keeping your hub on is the inner bearing and seal. Pull on it hard enough to pop those out, and then you can take the hub off.
 
Okay KliersLC, I think what you are telling me to do is what I've tried. I placed a large gear puller on the center of the spline shaft of the birfield. I placed the arms behind the hub where the wheel studs are pressed in, a nice flat spot exists here in six places. I have cranked on said gear puller until all slack was taken out. Then I really cranked on it, to the point where, even with this fat guy putting all of his weight on it, it would move no more. Still, the inner race will not budge. It also looks like I've managed to split the outer race during this process, so it now spins inside the hub assembly. I am about to take a die-grinder with carbide bur to the inner race and see what damage I can do. I am not saying any of the above in an angry way, or in an impatient way. I just want to know if what I've described is what you're telling me to do. Thanks for the help!
 
That was it, I may not be understanding exactly what is going on. I was under the impression that your outer wheel bearing has disintegrated, leaving the inner ring front the bearing "welded" to the spindle. If this is the case, I *think* (I used to be sure) that the entire hub will slide over the ring and give you more space to work. This isn't necessary to get the ring off, but it would allow you more space and allow different angles, as well as getting the greasy hub out of the way in case you want to use heat.

MAPP gas should be hot enough, you just need to expand the ring a little.

When you had the puller on it, was the hub hitting the stuck bearing ring? If so, this won't work, but you could use that to your advantage if you use heat. i.e. put pressure on it, heat the ring, more pressure, more heat etc.

Just be careful with the spindle.....

Good Luck,
Dan
 
Yeah, the inner race was contacting the outer race, but only because of the new welded metal paste that attached itself to the inner race. After about 30 mins heating and applying pressure via the gear puller, the hub and outer race popped off the spindle and inner race. The inner race was still welded to the spindle, and took some grinding with a die grinder, and some beating with a chisel and BFH to get it off the spindle. I'm going to see if I can borrow ToothFairy's camera tomorrow to take/post some pics of what the spindle looks like right now. You can see where the two pieces of metal rubbed against each other and started to friction-weld together. I just count my blessings that I was able to get it home safely, despite not being able to troubleshoot what the problem was. I'm trying to get a parts list together for CDan, and could use some suggestions. I think I need a few things: new bearings, new washers, new nuts, new seals for both sides. New spindle and hub for the right side, along with new dust cover gasket and spindle gasket for the right side. I found this info on page SA-13 of the FSM. If anyone thinks I need anything else (including a digital camera ;)) look at your FSM and let me know what it is. Thanks again for all the help. Sorry for whining before, but waiting sucks.:D
 
Back
Top Bottom