FJ40 Rest or Restmod???

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 22, 2019
Threads
15
Messages
87
Location
COLLEGE STATION, TX
I have owned 3 FJ40's so far in my 55 years on this planet. My First was an all original, except motor, '78 mustard, Bought in 1984. It had a Pontiac 400 in it. Did a wheely in first 3 gears. It was a beast! would climb anything. 1st wife hated it so I sold it, BIG MISTAKE!!! 2nd was a '77 pale blue original, did a frame off resto. The only thing not original was the paint color, went back with the FJ40 beige, added PS/AC. My mistake was redoing it too good! I could not enjoy it on my ranch because of the awesome paint job, I was scared of scratches,,,, 2nd wife made me sell it, BIG MISTAKE. Current 40 is a 74 all original, except upgraded front seats and a HFS front bumper, fresh from new paint, correct white. The top is original but painted black in the rhinoliner stuff. 3rd wife calls it a sexy beast!!! Guess both will be keepers! My question or survey is: It has the F.5 motor (weber carb) with 95,000 original miles. After this summer, I feel like I will need to do mechanical refurb. Would you A.) send current motor to be rebuilt? B.) Source a rebuilt 2F? or C.) turn it in to a resto/mod? If, you put a totally different drivetrain, would you do a GM, thinking a 383 stroker, or try to retro fit a diesel? If, I change to a 2F or o, my thought is, why not switch to the new blinkers in front, new doors, etc, list can go on. I am mostly a purest,,,, and want all original period correct, and inwardly emotionally look down on mods,,, Intellectually, I like the idea of taking something good and making it great! Help get me off the fence,,,, one way or the other ,,,,, (side note, if I get my motor rebuilt where do I send it and how much can I expect to pay???)
 
I'll throw in my 2 cents.
As far as the motor goes, if it were me and what I plan on doing is getting the motor rebuilt. What I mean is changing the seals and any and everything that leaks on the motor. I'm not really talking about re-spec'ing out new everything machined parts and the likes mostly refreshing everything to get it running better. If you're looking for more power then you could go with option C, but that can open a can of worms too.
As far as making the other mods and making a good thing better, I'm also a purist and I will say like you look down on mods, is how I feel when I see things that don't match on these old FJ40s. For example the later model hard tops on earlier model FJ40s. They're better hardtops I think, but it kinda just doesn't belong. There are a couple other things like that where I go, "well that doesn't belong:cautious:", but admittedly there are some other things that I can let slide. But that could be just my too purist opinion so take it with a grain of salt.
 
I'll throw in my 2 cents.
As far as the motor goes, if it were me and what I plan on doing is getting the motor rebuilt. What I mean is changing the seals and any and everything that leaks on the motor. I'm not really talking about re-spec'ing out new everything machined parts and the likes mostly refreshing everything to get it running better. If you're looking for more power then you could go with option C, but that can open a can of worms too.
As far as making the other mods and making a good thing better, I'm also a purist and I will say like you look down on mods, is how I feel when I see things that don't match on these old FJ40s. For example the later model hard tops on earlier model FJ40s. They're better hardtops I think, but it kinda just doesn't belong. There are a couple other things like that where I go, "well that doesn't belong:cautious:", but admittedly there are some other things that I can let slide. But that could be just my too purist opinion so take it with a grain of salt.
I hear ya, like a factory roll bar in a 1971,,,,, it just jumps out at me,,, I can't not see it
 
So, at some point in time, someone cut the rear fenders, I added period correct aftermarket flares,,,,, thought being, if I repair fenders by buying an after market kit (yes they do make them) ,,,,, how is that really any different than adding the fender flares,,,,, it's funny how we reconcile ourselves with what we have, being ok. FULL DISCLOSURE,,,, I traded a boat for a very nice restomod 1981 Jeep scrambler, had a V8 (amc jeep but AMC never put them in a scrambler) with a 3speed auto tranny,,,,, I never got over the mod part,,,, ANYWAY, traded that for this baby I got now,,, funny thing was neither one of us could believe the other was willing to trade. I am still laughing
 
This is a very very difficult question for others to answer. I think the best answer is that you should do what makes YOU happy, and you should ignore what us yahoos think.

The key is in analyzing what makes you happy... what will give you the best chance of having no regrets.

Your budget (and your sensitivity to resale value), what you plan to use the truck for, and what puts a smile on your face are all that matters. Nail down your criteria, and I think the answer will present itself. :)

Now, for my opinion (don't listen to me!!!). Keep it as original as possible. I love the nostalgia and I love the original looks, and it certainly helps that originality plays a big role in resale value when you or your heirs decide to sell.

PS- your post cracked me up. Third time's a charm, my friend! :)
 
This is a very very difficult question for others to answer. I think the best answer is that you should do what makes YOU happy, and you should ignore what us yahoos think.

The key is in analyzing what makes you happy... what will give you the best chance of having no regrets.

Your budget (and your sensitivity to resale value), what you plan to use the truck for, and what puts a smile on your face are all that matters. Nail down your criteria, and I think the answer will present itself. :)

Now, for my opinion (don't listen to me!!!). Keep it as original as possible. I love the nostalgia and I love the original looks, and it certainly helps that originality plays a big role in resale value when you or your heirs decide to sell.

PS- your post cracked me up. Third time's a charm, my friend! :)
Your right, I have to own 2, one all original and one that's not!
 
Back
Top Bottom