engine rebuild question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 21, 2005
Threads
30
Messages
228
Location
ATL, GA
Website
www.mybj40.blogspot.com
I have ready may threads tonight and I am trying to understand why someone would say that it would be better to buy a used engine vs rebuilding the one you had. My engine was / is running , it was making some top end noise , had started to lose and not hold oil pressure. The engine was working great.. except for the oil pressure and valve noise. Does this sound right ? I would understand this if he engine threw a rod and was gone, but mine is still running. I am going to get a second opinion.. thanks
 
I think the cost of a rebuild kit from toyota is more expensive than buying a used engine, but I don't really know.

But yes, it does sound like your engine needs a rebuild.
 
The engine has 128,000 miles on it. It has had some ticking or noise on the top end for about a year with no problem. I sent in for a black stone report about a year ago and it came back alright. I started to have low oil pressure on my drive in to work, the gauge had bottom out, but not quite at the very bottom. The engine then stopped. I pulled over and restarted, everything seemed fine, except the oil pressure would start out normal but as soon as I started going it would drop down to the bottom. Other than that the engine was running fine. I was able to drive it over to a shop here in town. The truck did not over heat as far as I could tell. OK what do we think.
 
I just had my engine rebuilt last month. I would take a good look at how cheap Dan can get you a short block and compare that around with how much it would cost you for parts and machine labor to rebuild yours. You may not be too far off the rebuild cost to just pick up the short block. They are much cheaper than they were a couple years ago.

My thoughts on rebuilding vs buying a used engine. I just thought spending all the time and $ taking down and replacing the engine, I didn't want to do it twice. A well rebuilt engine should last me a long long time verses putting in an engine that I don't really know how it was treated and how long it would last.

Still, not cheap either way. Sorry in that position now.

my .02

troy
 
That engine is a baby at 128K.
I am no pro but I doubt your engine even need rebuilding.
It sounds like you need the valves adjusted and figure out whats happening with the oil pressure. Is it leaking oil up front underneath? I think landtanks question about the oil pump needs to addressed first. Very interesting. There are alot of guys around the ATL area perhaps some of them will be willing to help you out.
 
yea there a a few drips of oil but nothing major. Yea I am going to have someone get a second look at it.
 
If it does end up being trashed there is a 1hz setting in a friends garage about 1 mile from where I am typing this in NC. Always good to have options:)
 
It could be a bad oil pump or some thing stoping up the pick up screen.A Toyota rebuilt will cost you over $6000 my guess.My wife tore mine up and now she dosen't it any more and cost me 4300 and thats not Toyota rebuilt.I would check it out real good or have it check befor i rebuilt.No need to do something it dosen't need.
 
A loose crank pully can cause the oil pressure loss.

This would also produce a steering effort problem as well.


This low oil pressure, is it during initial warm up or just after you have driven it a while.

The reason is, you might have an oil return issue. When that happens the oil accumulates in the head because it's not draining back into the pan fast enough. This will eventually drop the oil level in the pan to a point where the pump starves for oil. I've seen this on other engines not ours.

A couple of things:

1. when the oil pressure is low check the oil level while the truck is running and in that low state.

2. get a mechanical gauge on there to confirm it's not the factory gauge being at fault.

3. I had low oil pressure when my truck was running hot. If you haven't modded your temp gauge to eliminate the dead spot then get that done immediately. RavenTai wrote a nice procedure for this.
 
The oil pressure starts out fine but then with in 10mins of driving the pressure is lost. Once it starts going down is it pretty rapid. I have noticed at start up sometimes a high pressure reading then it levels out to normal. I dont know if that means anything or not. I do not have the temp mod but I do think it will be on my list of to-dos. I am going to try and solve the oil issue first and then see where that takes me. Then address the other noise under the hood. I think maybe drive it until it fails then rebuild or used engine.
 
Have you noticed a reduction in power steering assist when the oil pressure drops?
 
Check out the need first..

Like the others, I seriously doubt you need an engine or a rebuild. Like kidpen said, that engine's a baby. No way it should have serious internal issues. If it was run VERY low on oil, or got very hot...maybe. The best evidence againt the need for major repair is your own report of how good it runs otherwise.

The PCV valve will suck a lot of oil out of the crank case if it's bad. It actually sucks it out of the cylinder head / valve cover area, which gets a big supply of oil for those big camshafts.

Once all these other symptoms are dealt with, and you still think, or are being told by two or three reliable sources that you need major internal work, than consider the cost either way.

I went through all this due to an idiot machine shop guy ruining my idler bushing by vatting the block without removing it. I found one mudder that had a complete new engine in a rolled 80 for $2000, and Dan had a new block for $2700. In the end I got a new bushing made.

If you need an engine or a rebuild, I would recommend a rebuild if you are a :banana: :banana: to a :banana: :banana: :banana: guy. If not, then have soemone else do it, and go with a short block.
 
The oil pressure starts out fine but then with in 10mins of driving the pressure is lost. Once it starts going down is it pretty rapid. I have noticed at start up sometimes a high pressure reading then it levels out to normal. I dont know if that means anything or not. I do not have the temp mod but I do think it will be on my list of to-dos. I am going to try and solve the oil issue first and then see where that takes me. Then address the other noise under the hood. I think maybe drive it until it fails then rebuild or used engine.


I know that there is a relationship between engine temps and oil pressure. The stock gauge will allow the engine to get pretty hot before showing any movement. It's a half hour and two resistors to do.

Check the oil level when the pressure is low. What you are describing is exactly how a clogged return would act.
 
I think you have a pretty simple diagnostic here. Get the engine warm with a mechanic's manual oil pressure guage hooked up and see what the pressure REALLY is (vs your gauge). THEN, if you have an oil pressure issue, start working to resolve that.

The title of this thread should have been "oil pressure issue - do I have one?" versus jumping all the way to a rebuild discussion. Don't overanalyze it - get the oil pressure checked.

DougM
 
thanks all points well taken. I cant image a better source for input and information then here. I am going to solve the oil problem first then move into the other stuff.
 
Hello all,

I bought FUELGEDDES' LX-450.

Tonight, I connected a mechanical oil pressure gage and here are my findings:

At startup, the pressure is about 60-65 psi
After one minute, it drops to around 40 psi
After about five minutes (engine is starting to warm), the pressure is 20 psi.
After a few more minutes (engine is fully warm), the pressure drops to zero.

Once the pressure drops, I have noticed that the oil pressure doesn't change much as you increase the throttle.

I checked the oil level with the dipstick after the pressure dropped to zero. The oil level was normal.

The power steering assist seems OK. Any recommendations on where to go from here?
 
Back
Top Bottom