Electrical Short Regulator/Alternator- help

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jul 12, 2006
Threads
70
Messages
2,462
Location
Fort Collins, CO
I need a bit more guidance on my short problem.

Problem: Turn Signal/Regulator fuse is shorted. I eliminated the fuse box and the turn signals as the culprit. (tested separately) Line to the regulator was shorted... or the regulator itself was shorted.

When I tested the fuse, it shorted whether the alternator was plugged in or not.

Just replaced the regulator. Now, it shorts with the alternator plugged in, but not when I unplug it. I think that means that I did have a problem at the regulator, and fixed that, but now have another short somewhere downline of the alternator.

Looking at the wiring diagram, there is a dotted line "E" from the regulator to the alternator. I don't know what that does or whether that could be causing the problem.

The other line out of the alternator goes back to the fuse box with a cut off going to the Ammeter and the ignition switch. I don't have an Ammeter hooked up. Came that way.

Don't know if this helps, but this short occured while driving. It's not something that has happened intermittently...

Any ideas?

Thanks,
 
I

Just replaced the regulator. Now, it shorts with the alternator plugged in, but not when I unplug it. I think that means that I did have a problem at the regulator, and fixed that, but now have another short somewhere downline of the alternator.

Sounds like the alternator field windings are shorted.

I

Looking at the wiring diagram, there is a dotted line "E" from the regulator to the alternator. I don't know what that does or whether that could be causing the problem.

This is an extra ground wire (white with black stripe) that some cruisers have. It is redundant with the case grounded to the engine and chassis, but since these grounds can fail, the extra wire helps to make sure that the voltage regulator sees the same ground as the alternator. It isn't the problem unless the hot wire is physically shorted to this wire.

I

The other line out of the alternator goes back to the fuse box with a cut off going to the Ammeter and the ignition switch. I don't have an Ammeter hooked up. Came that way.

,

The wiring sounds normal, except your description that the ammeter is not hooked up. If the ammeter is not hooked up, there will be no power to and from the battery, unless you have bypassed the amp meter.
 
"Sounds like the alternator field windings are shorted."

Thanks,

For now I'll focus here. What exactly does this mean and what's the fix?

I didn't do the ammeter wiring so i'll have to look at it when I get home to see what was done. Probably just bypassed. I haven't run into any crazy wiring so far.
 
There are two sets of windings in an alternator: The rotating field windings that the regulator runs current through to produce a magnetic field and the stator windings that generate high current to provide power to the battery B+ post on the alternator. If you only remove the plug and the fuse stops blowing (and not the white wire with blue stripe that is bolted tothe B+ lug) then the field windings are shorted. Most likely cause is the brushes are worn to the point that the metal holder is contacting the case.

The fix is replace the brushes or find the short or get a rebuilt alternator.
 
Will double check everything tonight take the next step. Thanks for the help!
 
Getting closer... but stumped

The fix is replace the brushes or find the short or get a rebuilt alternator.[/quote]

I put in a rebuilt alternator today and had put in a new regulator. Short is still there.

I dug deeper and here's what I found. In the plug, the "F" wire that runs between the alternator and the regulator is the culprit. I pulled that wire from the plug and the short is dependent on that wire being attached.

I tried pulling the "E" wire as well both with and without the "F" wire. Shorts any time the "F" wire is hooked up regardless of "E".

I ran a test "F" wire from the plug to the regulator. Still shorts?

I am not sure where to go next.

If you can stand giving this one more shot, I would appreciate any help!

Thanks,
 
I'm not sure I understand your description of what you did and what happened, but if you unplug the wire at the alternator and the fuse still blows, then the short is somewhere before the alternator.

If you unplug it at the regulator, then the short is somewhere upstreqam of the regulator. Keep unplugging it or disconnecting wires in the circuit all the way back to the fuse block to find the short.

If you get tired of replacing fuses, you can use your test light probe instead.
 
I'm not sure I understand your description of what you did and what happened, but if you unplug the wire at the alternator and the fuse still blows, then the short is somewhere before the alternator.

If you unplug it at the regulator, then the short is somewhere upstreqam of the regulator. Keep unplugging it or disconnecting wires in the circuit all the way back to the fuse block to find the short.

If you get tired of replacing fuses, you can use your test light probe instead.

Let me try again. I am using the light... no fuses.

I have plugged and unplugged all wires out of the alternator. Found the one that is causing the short.

If I unplug just the "F" wire out of the alternator (the one that goes directly back to the regulator) plug the short stops. I bypassed that "F" wire in the plug, and ran a test wire from the alternator back to the regulator and the short is still there.

That is why I'm stuck. I know where the short is, but rewiring that line isn't helping?

Does that better explain what's happening?

Thanks,
 
I bypassed that "F" wire in the plug, and ran a test wire from the alternator back to the regulator and the short is still there.

Thanks,

OK. I get it.

If you run a new wire from the regulator to the alternator, the test light should light up with the key on, because it is supposed to power the field windings. However, this should not be enough current to overload the fuse.

At this point you need to be quantitative about how much power is flowing. Put the fuse in it with the new wire and see if it is too much or use an amp meter in place of the test light to see if the current exceeds the fuse rating.
 
Now I think we are getting somewhere. I'll check that tonight. May have been fixed last night but I never plugged in a fuse... just checked with the light. I'll pull out the amp meter and give it a go.

As always, thanks!
 
Just be aware that the amount of current in this circuit (15A) can exceed the limit of many inexpensive meters. The fuse is always an alternative.

PS. My recollection is that the maximum field current is about 5 - 7 amps.
 
Last edited:
I am fixed!

Pinhead, thanks for the help... saved a lot of time and learned a bunch.
 
I am fixed!

Pinhead, thanks for the help... saved a lot of time and learned a bunch.

What was the verdict after your last tests??

All this is going by memory but I'm tracking down a similar issue as we speak...

The "F" terminal on the alternator will have continuity with your ground system when the ignition is off. However, with the ignition on, it sends power though the white/red wire to the VR, which in turn sends it to the white/bluw wire to the alternators field terminal... if the alternator is working correctly it should not short here. Sound right?
 
Back
Top Bottom