Dual Battery Question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 31, 2003
Threads
952
Messages
10,248
Location
"the whale's vagina", CA
Hi, I am working on putting together a dual battery system on my 96 fzj80. In my 40, I used a simple boat switch, hooked to 2 optimas. I manage the batteries manually, yellow optimas deep cycles, I usually will run batt 1 for awhile and then switch over to batt 2 when I drive it next. This has worked for years for me with no issues whatsoever.

I have been reading some of the threads on the hellroaring, power gate, etc, etc. I would rather not spend the extra money on any of these units. My main question is will they work for what I want to do? From my research the short answer seems to be no.

What I want to do is have a dual battery system where I can choose which batt the car is pulling enerygy from. By this, I mean I want to be sure that all the accessories, radio, interior lights, etc, are all being pulled from a specific battery. My main goal is to camp with the vehicle and be able to run all the lights, radio, etc, etc. without having to worry about draining the main battery. I want to ensure that I can camp for a few days and run everything, drain the aux battery and simply start up with the main battery the morning we leave.

From what I can gather most of the systems above tell you to attach all your accessories to the 2nd aux battery? therefore you won't drain your main battery, BUT if I don't do some serious rewiring (which I won't do) than the factory stereo and interior lights will drain that main battery anyhow, correct? Again, do any of the systems allow you to choose when parked what battery you are pulling from for ALL accessories? In the end, for my needs I would like to have something that monitors both batteries when running and keeps them topped off but when parked allows you to choose what battery you are pulling from for all of the energy used in the vehicle.

Thanks for the help.

Noah
 
What I did was run a Wrangler NW 200 continuous amp solenoid between the two batteries. One battery sits in the stock location and powers only the stock accessories. It's hooked directly to the alternator. Then a large wire runs to a solenoid which then connects to the aux battery. All non-stock accessories run off of the aux battery. Everything, including driving lights, all interior accessories, fridge, the works. They way when camping, I can run anything I want off of the aux battery with no worries of discharging the main battery.

When the solenoid is turned on, both batteries are hooked together. If the engine is running, everything runs off of both batteries and both batteries are charged by the alternator. When the solenoid is turned off, the aux battery is isolated from the main battery and alternator and aux accessories cannot drain the main battery, only the aux battery.

To control the solenoid I have a 3 position switch. In position 1, the solenoid is powered by the stock ignition, so whenever the ignition is on, both batteries are connected...ignition off, both batteries disconnected. This is the "auto" position and where I normally just leave it. Position 2, is manual off, so I can disconnect the two batteries at any time. Position 3 is manual override. This allows me to connect both batteries at anytime. It's powered by the aux battery. So, if the main battery is dead, I just flip the switch to position 3, assuming the aux battery has juice and fire up the truck. If the aux battery is dead, I would flip to position 1 and the solenoid is powered by the ignition switch/main battery and will start charging as soon as the engine starts up.

That's basically my system and it's worked really well. No need to even open the hood and mess with either battery at any time. Some companies sell kits that basically do what I describe, but all you really need is the solenoid, some basic wiring skills (you'll want heavy wire and be very careful about routing, etc) and a 3 position switch (on-off-on). I added a volt meter for the aux battery too so I can monitor it's charge seperately. And I also went a step further, adding a cut off switch for all my interior accessories. I have radios, fridge, ham, and ton of chargers (computer, phone, radios) and other stuff that sometimes stay plugged in and on, so when I dont' drive the rig for a while I can just flip a switch and cut power to everything and not drain the battery in case I leave something plugged in or turned on.
 
Last edited:
National Luna monitors your batteries, automatically charges both when needed, and you hook up your accessories to whichever battery you want. When starting, you can either start off your main battery or off both batteries together.
 
If you are going for the simple marine switch and solenoid scheme then you can wire things how ever you want to combine/draw/charge. I went with added accessories wired to the aux battery, all extra cig lighter outlets, compressor etc wired to the aux and left the stock accessories alone. Convert your domes/doors to LEDs and you won't need to worry about draining the main battery down, even after a week camped.

To run the solenoid, rather than using the ignition to energize the solenoid, there is a signal in the engine fuse/relay box that I call alternator_good that is perfect (see my website). It keeps the batteries isolated until the engine has started and the alternator is putting out charge. This way if you have a dead battery you aren't jumping it right at the time you are trying to also pull a heap of current to start the engine.

If you need to jump start the main (due to battery failure), then you can use the marine switch to manually combine the batteries, wait a few minutes for the main to recover a bit and then start the engine. I've had to do this when an old main battery has finally bitten the dust.

The simple parallel combining with an old school solenoid has worked well for me. I've been running it over 8 years, no issues at all. Batteries have not had problems with charging, I don't have overcharging/boiling issues and the batteries are not "matched". I've read folk saying the batteries need to be the same age, same type etc etc - why... The alternator puts out nominal 14.4V (max) while running, if one battery is charged it will basically draw no current from the 14.4V, the other battery will. It's not like one will overcharge - we're dealing with essentially a constant voltage charging system for lead acid batteries.

Anyhow, I like the simple nature of a solenoid and marine switch. No electronics to worry about, no question whether the system is working and I get to choose exactly how/when the batteries are combined and charged.

I draw current from the winch from either battery (or both) and can disable the winch power completely. I've jump started myself a couple of times, once when the original main battery died at 5yrs and again when the replaced optima red died after 6yrs. The aux is at least 6yrs old (costco marine battery) and is still going strong doing its job.

cheers,
george.
 
What I did was run a Wrangler NW 200 continuous amp solenoid between the two batteries. One battery sits in the stock location and powers only the stock accessories. It's hooked directly to the alternator. Then a large wire runs to a solenoid which then connects to the aux battery. All non-stock accessories run off of the aux battery. Everything, including driving lights, all interior accessories, fridge, the works. They way when camping, I can run anything I want off of the aux battery with no worries of discharging the main battery.

.

thanks for your input, but if I am reading this correctly, in your setup, the stock radio and interior lights, etc, would thus be pulling energy from the starting battery, correct? I want a setup that will isolate that pull to one and only one battery when parked and camping.
 
If you are going for the simple marine switch and solenoid scheme then you can wire things how ever you want to combine/draw/charge. I went with added accessories wired to the aux battery, all extra cig lighter outlets, compressor etc wired to the aux and left the stock accessories alone. Convert your domes/doors to LEDs and you won't need to worry about draining the main battery down, even after a week camped.

To run the solenoid, rather than using the ignition to energize the solenoid, there is a signal in the engine fuse/relay box that I call alternator_good that is perfect (see my website). It keeps the batteries isolated until the engine has started and the alternator is putting out charge. This way if you have a dead battery you aren't jumping it right at the time you are trying to also pull a heap of current to start the engine.

If you need to jump start the main (due to battery failure), then you can use the marine switch to manually combine the batteries, wait a few minutes for the main to recover a bit and then start the engine. I've had to do this when an old main battery has finally bitten the dust.

The simple parallel combining with an old school solenoid has worked well for me. I've been running it over 8 years, no issues at all. Batteries have not had problems with charging, I don't have overcharging/boiling issues and the batteries are not "matched". I've read folk saying the batteries need to be the same age, same type etc etc - why... The alternator puts out nominal 14.4V (max) while running, if one battery is charged it will basically draw no current from the 14.4V, the other battery will. It's not like one will overcharge - we're dealing with essentially a constant voltage charging system for lead acid batteries.

Anyhow, I like the simple nature of a solenoid and marine switch. No electronics to worry about, no question whether the system is working and I get to choose exactly how/when the batteries are combined and charged.

I draw current from the winch from either battery (or both) and can disable the winch power completely. I've jump started myself a couple of times, once when the original main battery died at 5yrs and again when the replaced optima red died after 6yrs. The aux is at least 6yrs old (costco marine battery) and is still going strong doing its job.

cheers,
george.

hi george, I have converted all the interiors, except the map light to led's, but I want something that I know all the energy is being pulled from only one battery for sure.

thanks for your comments, my question here is how is a solenoid used in a dual batt setup with a simple marine switch? Not sure if you mean solenoid the same as an isolator? I planned to run everything using the boat switch and charge as needed, but I am thinking If I could find and isolate the charging wire from the alternator and route it through an isolator so that it charges both batteries when running that might work. Then when parked the isolator would effectively be shut off and both batt's would be disconnected, correct? Then at that point I could choose which batt energy is being pulled from when parked/camping. Upon startup, I could choose which batt the car is pulling from but once the alternator starts charging, it would be feeding both batt's due to the isolator being installed.
 
thanks for your input, but if I am reading this correctly, in your setup, the stock radio and interior lights, etc, would thus be pulling energy from the starting battery, correct? I want a setup that will isolate that pull to one and only one battery when parked and camping.

I don't worry about the stock accessories, but if you use the stock radio and interior lights and worry about them draining the battery then you're two choices are to either rewire those components to run off of the aux battery instead of the main battery or have everything, including stock and aux accessories run off of your main battery and have nothing run off of your aux battery and when camping, the main battery will be used, but the aux battery will remain untouched and available to start the truck.
 
What I did was run a Wrangler NW 200 continuous amp solenoid between the two batteries. One battery sits in the stock location and powers only the stock accessories. It's hooked directly to the alternator. Then a large wire runs to a solenoid which then connects to the aux battery. All non-stock accessories run off of the aux battery. Everything, including driving lights, all interior accessories, fridge, the works. They way when camping, I can run anything I want off of the aux battery with no worries of discharging the main battery.

When the solenoid is turned on, both batteries are hooked together. If the engine is running, everything runs off of both batteries and both batteries are charged by the alternator. When the solenoid is turned off, the aux battery is isolated from the main battery and alternator and aux accessories cannot drain the main battery, only the aux battery.

To control the solenoid I have a 3 position switch. In position 1, the solenoid is powered by the stock ignition, so whenever the ignition is on, both batteries are connected...ignition off, both batteries disconnected. This is the "auto" position and where I normally just leave it. Position 2, is manual off, so I can disconnect the two batteries at any time. Position 3 is manual override. This allows me to connect both batteries at anytime. It's powered by the aux battery. So, if the main battery is dead, I just flip the switch to position 3, assuming the aux battery has juice and fire up the truck. If the aux battery is dead, I would flip to position 1 and the solenoid is powered by the ignition switch/main battery and will start charging as soon as the engine starts up.

That's basically my system and it's worked really well. No need to even open the hood and mess with either battery at any time. Some companies sell kits that basically do what I describe, but all you really need is the solenoid, some basic wiring skills (you'll want heavy wire and be very careful about routing, etc) and a 3 position switch (on-off-on). I added a volt meter for the aux battery too so I can monitor it's charge seperately. And I also went a step further, adding a cut off switch for all my interior accessories. I have radios, fridge, ham, and ton of chargers (computer, phone, radios) and other stuff that sometimes stay plugged in and on, so when I dont' drive the rig for a while I can just flip a switch and cut power to everything and not drain the battery in case I leave something plugged in or turned on.

This is exactly what I want. Not including the batteries, how much did all the materials run you Brian?
 
hi george, I have converted all the interiors, except the map light to led's, but I want something that I know all the energy is being pulled from only one battery for sure.

thanks for your comments, my question here is how is a solenoid used in a dual batt setup with a simple marine switch? Not sure if you mean solenoid the same as an isolator?.

See the aux bat write up on my website, link in my sig... It shows what I did and where to get the alternator_good signal from. Basically I have something like a 150 or 200A solenoid to provide the charging connection, and the marine switch when I want to draw serious current like for winching. When the marine switch is in use a small circuit of relays disables the solenoid so big nasty winch currents don't try to flow through it.

cheers,
george.
 
This is exactly what I want. Not including the batteries, how much did all the materials run you Brian?

If you're starting from scratch, you would need, or at least should get, the parts from Slee to relocate the window washer bottle....

Slee - Battery Related Products

Then get the early FJ80 battery tray that fits on the passenger side from Cdan (can't remember the cost) Then you'd have a VERY nice clean and stock looking place to mount that second battery.

Then I used the Wrangler NW solenoid (they call it an isolator relay)

Wrangler NW - Isolation Relay

You'll need some heavy battery cable. I would get pretty much the largest you can find, to connect the two batteries through the isolator. I also purchased super heavy duty slow burn fuses just to be extra safe and run these on both batteries. The fuses are rated at about 200 amps each. I've winched with these fuses in place no problem. The idea being that in an accident or some unforeseen situation, if the cable between the battery grounds, it will eventually burn the fuse. It will probably spark for a few seconds and there's still a risk of fire, but at least there's some fusable connection. I also run my connector wire inside some heater hose for extra protection. I'm kind of paranoid and don't like to take chances.

The rest is just basic wire a switch from your local autoparts store.

Hope that helps.
 
I reread this again and understand better the solution using the solenoid better. This seems like a good solution if you don't ever want to manually deal with the batteries and just want something relatively automatic. After thinking about it though, I think I will stick to my first plan and just route everything through the boat switch and manually manage the batteries.

That brings up a question though. When you have the batteries connected through the solenoid, do you ever worry about the large current draw between them when one is completely dead (ie: camping and completely drained) and the other is full? I will be using dual yellow top optimas. It would seem under your setup that there would be some major exchange of energy between the batteries when one is drained completely and then the next morning the ignition is turned on and the two batteries level each other out. I have heard that this can be dangerous or greatly shorten the life of batteries? any truth to this? or can they handle it just fine? I am thinking that if they can handle it just fine, then great, because I can simply pop the marine switch to BOTH in the morning and let the batt's equalize and then leave the switch on BOTH so that they both charge from the alternator. I would probably also always leave the switch to BOTH when driving it regualarly, that way I know both batteries are being used/charged regularly. I know the oly real NO NO is to turn the marine switch while the engine is running, which I never do.

anyhow, thanks for the help and opinions.

Noah
 
Just to be clear, the solenoid does have a manual option as well. Instead of a big manual switch, the switch is just electrically operated. As I mentioned, mine is wired so that if either battery is dead, the solenoid can still operate normally.

The biggest risk when connecting a dead battery to a live battery is overheating the cables that connect the two, that's why you want to make sure you have a good size battery cable. Otherwise, whether it hurts the Optimas or any other battery after repeatedly do that, I don't know for sure.

I did find that in the past, on my old truck, the Optimas did not like staying connected over long periods of time when the charging system (engine) was turned off. In other words, leaving the two batteries connected and then turning off the engine for a day or longer. If the batteries are not exactly the same age, condition, use, one will be slightly less charged than the other and eventually they will discharge each other. I've actually ruined a number of Optima batteries over the years as my rigs are not daily drivers, so the batteries would sit and get discharged and I think the type of discharge with the two batteries connected, damaged their cells.

My current set up as described above has worked absolutely perfectly for several years. However, I rarely fully discharge the aux battery. Usually the aux battery only gets down to about 11 volts or so before I reconnect the two and start the engine.

A couple of ways to address this concern, which I haven't done, is to get a cut out switch for the aux battery that cuts out accessories at a certain voltage to prevent complete discharge of the battery. Another way is to design the system with an isolator so that the two batteries always stay indepedent of each other, but both are seperately hooked up to the alternator.

As I recall, the manual battery switch has the option of hooking up the alternator to the switch and allowing you to charge one, the other, or both batteries. If you want absolute full manual control and the option to charge only one of the two batteries, then that may be the way to go. Plus you have the added protection of not having to worry about the solenoid failing...which can happen.
 
Last edited:
thanks for your input, but if I am reading this correctly, in your setup, the stock radio and interior lights, etc, would thus be pulling energy from the starting battery, correct? I want a setup that will isolate that pull to one and only one battery when parked and camping.

This thread covers a pretty wide variety of options.
https://forum.ih8mud.com/80-series-tech/104630-faq-addition-dual-battery-set-ups.html

Like you, I wanted a brute force dual battery solution. Mine is set up to run two loads, house and winch. House includes everything on the truck but the winch. Both are manually switched between battery 1 or battery 2 or both using big radioactive glow in the dark marine switches.

My install starts in post 25 of the above thread. Mine is a lot like Boston Mangler's with the exception that I have two isolated outputs.

If you're going dual battery, be sure to read the whole thread. I didn't get smart and put in fuses until post 47.
IH8MUD.com - View Single Post - FAQ addition: Dual Battery Set-Ups

Oh, almost forgot. I run mine in parallel 99% of the time. I can do this because I purchased (and paid extra for) factory matched Optima D31A batteries. This goes beyond just getting them off the store shelf at the same time. They're matched in capacity and discharge from the factory and sold as a pair. This cuts down on the cross-charge draining issue.

Is this the kind of solution you are looking for?

IMHO YMMV.
 
Last edited:
Oh, almost forgot. I run mine in parallel 99% of the time. I can do this because I purchased (and paid extra for) factory matched Optima D31A batteries. This goes beyond just getting them off the store shelf at the same time. They're matched in capacity and discharge from the factory and sold as a pair. This cuts down on the cross-charge draining issue.

Are the cross charge/draining issues really that bad? I've seen plenty of people with setups (granted, mostly for boats, RV's, etc) that use different sized batteries without issue, though I think they're usually charging them via VSV rather than directly from the alternator (which you should also be able to do with an 80, I'd imagine).
 
I am running both the marine switch and the hellroaring isolater. The marine switch is normally stationed on 1. I can combine or switch to 2 if I want. Whichever battery is selected gets charged but the isolater normally charges 2. It's as simple as that. I can start off or deplete either battery and don't have to remember to keep the aux charged.
 
Unless you move loads that are tied to the main over to an aux. battery, what you're trying to achieve is not possible. In a perfect world, you could hand-pick which loads would be attached to which battery, but with the way our trucks are delivered, when adding a second battery, there are compromises to be made. Solenoids are simple, cheap, and can be set up to function automatically....but they get hot and degrade in performance over time. Ironically, we just shipped the first batch of solid-state relays to the Department of Transportation, New Jersey to replace solenoids for powering accessories on trucks, 300 amp devices. Too many solenoid failures including vehicle fires pushed them to a solid-state solution. Marine style mechanical switches are another option, but like you mentioned, switching under load will greatly diminish its lifespan. But all this makes little difference until you acknowledge that as long as you have loads attached to the main battery, you have exposure. The idea is to minimize exposure and choose the best setup that serves your goals. If the idea is to camp for a weekend, run all devices you can PRACTICALLY transfer to an accessory battery, and isolate that battery, then you have some choices to evaluate. If you want to strip the radio and interior lights out of the OEM harness and move them over to the aux, more power to you.....may not be practical to do so, but knock yourself out. That said, figure out how to best isolate that dedicated accessory battery. Mechanical, solid state, automatic, manual.....need to factor price, reliability, ease of implementation, longevity, warranty, performance, etc.... and run with it.
 
I think I am going to stick with my initial plan and route everything through a simple manual switch. Not sure why you say what I am trying to do is impossible? I don't think it will require rewiring anything at all. On the stock battery, there are wires from the fuse box there and I plan to route those wires to the "source" post on the dual battery as well as the rest of the aux accessories to the same post. That way they are all pointed to the source terminal and then I can dictate what battery the whole car pulls energy through via the switch.

I have had it this way for years on my 40 with no problems.

Really what I was more interested in learning was how badly effected deep cycle batteries are damaged when you flip to "both" on the switch and one batt is drained completely. I would think that it would be the same effect as jumping a battery, which is a somewhat normal procedure.
 
One potential issue with your plan...and this may not be a big deal...but if you wire everything to a central and source post and then swap between batteries, as you switch from one battery to another, I assume, for a second, everything will be disconnected from power, so things like memory on the radio and even the EFI will constantly be reset.
 
Most marine switches are make before break - as long as you switch them through the combined setting and not through the off setting.
 
Back
Top Bottom