Do I need "E" rated tires?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jun 1, 2006
Threads
104
Messages
573
Location
North Jersey
I need to replace my spare to match my other four tires which are BFG AT 285/75R16 with a load rating of E I got the E's for two reasons one being they are 33'' vs. the D's which are 32.7'' and I figured with all the armor (weight) and abuse they would be well suited or did I just waste my money. Is my hard ride mostly from my heavy weight EMU springs and are these tires making it worst if so I'll buy an D spare and switch to D's when the other four wear out.

Thanks
George
 
A combination of things are leading to your harsh ride. A D rated tire will offer more compliance and be less harsh than an E rated tire. Also, what inflation pressure are your running? You should be running 40-42psi cold.
 
IMO, D rated tires are too stout for the 80 unless the conditions under which you'll use it warrant the load carrying capacity. Since even fully laden, an 80 is still at the low end of their capability, it's still overkill.

You'll get better traction, ride, and possibly even wear from tires whose load rating is matched to the 80. If you need durability for trail conditions, then tires designed for trail use and your load rating would be more suitable. Cary's tire pressure question is a good one - what pressure are you at? Likely you'll be able to lower pressure to improve ride, but unfortunately then the tire is not providing optimal pressure across its contact patch.

DougM
 
I have run dozens of sets of BFG A/Ts on these trucks for trail and street, never anything more than "D's." With OME I have found optimal pressure for a good ride at 36 psi unladen. But mpg tends to suck below 40. If I am loaded up with people and cargo, typically 40 psi. And sometimes 42 psi with the loaded rack. I wouldn't call it harsh at all, but that's just me.
 
Last edited:
I have run dozens of sets of BFG A/Ts on these trucks for trail and street, never anything more than "D's." With OME I have found optimal pressure for a good ride at 36 psi unladen. But mpg tends to suck below 40. If I am loaded up with people and cargo, typically 40 psi. And sometimes 42 psi with the loaded rack. I wouldn't call it harsh at all, but that's just me.

36psi is under-inflated. I has posted the information before from the various tire manufactures, when converting from a P metric tire (like the OEM tire) to a LT tire (what you are running) you need to increase inflation pressures by approximately 8-10 psi. A LT tire will not ride as nicely as P metric because it has a heavier sidewall for increased load capacity.
 
36psi is under-inflated. I has posted the information before from the various tire manufactures, when converting from a P metric tire (like the OEM tire) to a LT tire (what you are running) you need to increase inflation pressures by approximately 8-10 psi. A LT tire will not ride as nicely as P metric because it has a heavier sidewall for increased load capacity.

Try and drive my 80 on 35" load range E trxus at 40 PSI. It's awful. At 31 PSI they are perfect. Nice and soft around town (way softer than the ride of Load D BFG AT's) with good handling.

When did tires becomes one size fits all for PSI? When each tire can handle 3,400 lbs at max pressure what is the need for all that extra pressure :confused:? Seems to me you can afford to run a higher load range tire at slightly less pressure, not the other way around.
 
Try and drive my 80 on 35" load range E trxus at 40 PSI. It's awful. At 31 PSI they are perfect. Nice and soft around town (way softer than the ride of Load D BFG AT's) with good handling.

When did tires becomes one size fits all for PSI? When each tire can handle 3,400 lbs at max pressure what is the need for all that extra pressure :confused:? Seems to me you can afford to run a higher load range tire at slightly less pressure, not the other way around.


It doesn't quiet work that way because the load capacity curves are the same for all LT Tires. i.e. it doesn't matter if the tire is a D or E rated tire, at X psi, the tire will still be rated for the same load. E rated tires allow you to inflate to higher pressures which in turn support their load rating. I went through this pretty extensively here and have the links to the supporting documentation:

https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=111671
 
It doesn't quiet work that way because the load capacity curves are the same for all LT Tires. i.e. it doesn't matter if the tire is a D or E rated tire, at X psi, the tire will still be rated for the same load. E rated tires allow you to inflate to higher pressures which in turn support their load rating. I went through this pretty extensively here and have the links to the supporting documentation:

https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=111671


Ok, here's a monkey wrench, courtesy of Inteco, which is to be expected.

My Trxus MT's are 35x12.5x16. The sidewall states:

Load Range E
Max Capacity 3,640
Max Inflation 65 PSI

So this tire is not delivering additional load capacity due to enabling pressures above 65 PSI. How can this be?

Check out Interco's link below. The 35x12.5x15 has a max inflation of 35 PSI and 2,555 max load capacity. My 10 ply 35x12.5x16 weight 10 lbs more each than their 6 ply counterparts.

Their 285/75 has a max inflation of 80 PSI.

http://www.intercotire.com/site35.php

Interco is a special nut, but these ratings clearly disrupt the idea of all things being equal on the PSI/load curve for LT tires.

To a greater issue, what I cannot tell is how to correlate these figures back to the load capacity @ 31 PSI.

I can tell you that the tire rides and handles the best at the lower PSI, but is it "too low"? And what would "too low" mean? Excessive heat generation on long summer highway trips? What does that 10 ply sidewall mean in relation to a 3 ton SUV that doesn't need 3,640 load capacity? From the pic below, I have very little sidewall bulge at 31 PSI, and I know the tires perform horribly at higher PSI. How does it all fit?
DSC04910.webp
 
Interco is a special nut, but these ratings clearly disrupt the idea of all things being equal on the PSI/load curve for LT tires.

To a greater issue, what I cannot tell is how to correlate these figures back to the load capacity @ 31 PSI.

I can tell you that the tire rides and handles the best at the lower PSI, but is it "too low"? And what would "too low" mean? Excessive heat generation on long summer highway trips? What does that 10 ply sidewall mean in relation to a 3 ton SUV that doesn't need 3,640 load capacity? From the pic below, I have very little sidewall bulge at 31 PSI, and I know the tires perform horribly at higher PSI. How does it all fit?

Load curves are actually determined by the load rating of the tire (on the sidewall it will have a number like 114, 118, etc), see this:

http://www.discounttire.com/dtcs/infoLoadIndex.dos


For each load index, there is an inflation tire that sets forth the load capacity of the tire at a set PSI. Ideally what you do, is take the load index for the factory p-metric tire, find it's rated load at the factory 32psi, and then take the new tire, look at what inflation pressure it has the same load carrying capability, and then if necessary, adjust up a couple psi as needed for body armor and other increased in vehicle weight.

The problem is that I cannot find these load charts anywhere on the internet, some tire stores have them, but generally only the management will know about them.

This leaves us with the converting P-metric to LT need to increase pressure, but little else. We know that when converting you need to add 8-10psi, but then without having the load charts, cannot adjust further.
 
The problem is that I cannot find these load charts anywhere on the internet, some tire stores have them, but generally only the management will know about them.

Cary is this what you are looking for?
scan.webp
 
Cary is this what you are looking for?

I wish, there are actually tables for each load range so basically it will list the load ranges down the left, then across the top it will list inflation pressures in 5 psi increments, then each cell will list the weight capacity in pounds.
 
Load curves are actually determined by the load rating of the tire (on the sidewall it will have a number like 114, 118, etc), see this:

http://www.discounttire.com/dtcs/infoLoadIndex.dos


For each load index, there is an inflation tire that sets forth the load capacity of the tire at a set PSI. Ideally what you do, is take the load index for the factory p-metric tire, find it's rated load at the factory 32psi, and then take the new tire, look at what inflation pressure it has the same load carrying capability, and then if necessary, adjust up a couple psi as needed for body armor and other increased in vehicle weight.

The problem is that I cannot find these load charts anywhere on the internet, some tire stores have them, but generally only the management will know about them.

This leaves us with the converting P-metric to LT need to increase pressure, but little else. We know that when converting you need to add 8-10psi, but then without having the load charts, cannot adjust further.

Right, that's the issue. My tires don't have the number because they aren't a metric tire and you don't get the load rating/speed rating designation. But by the charts I'd have a 125 load rating since max capacity is 3,640.

If load capacity to PSI were linear you'd have a problem at 30 PSI, but what I've found is Discount Tire sets my PSI to around 43 no matter what. With 34" trxus on Jeep Cherokee I got 43, with 33" on my 80 I got 43, and with 35's on my 80 I got 43 PSI. Pretty much the 8-10 PSI above factory rule with no other considerations.

And after wondering what the hell is wrong with my new tires I check the PSI, immediately take it back down to the low 30's, get an enormous improvement in ride quality and handling, and then get the balance properly adjusted to the lower PSI at some point. I've just started to tell Discount to balance at 31 PSI or we just end up having to do it twice.

I think this is the reality for oversized tires - I'm not running them on a Super Duty pickup towing a 10 ton horse trailer and so 40+ PSI is completely out of the equation or I literally bounce all over the road.
 
I've been running my TRXus MTs between 30-35 psi. They ride well, and handle washboards too. I air down for worse conditions. What does the tire pressure guru, Cary, say about this? Are my tires going to fall off or explode in protest? No offense, I'm just being a smart-a kid. You really know your stuff.:D
 
36psi is under-inflated.

That is merely your opinion or a position you are taking based on something you have read. I have 50k miles on the current set of BFG 285/75 16s and they are not even to the halfway point yet. I have been running 285 and 315 BFGs on 6 FJ-80s for a decade and that psi unloaded has worked exceptionally well for me on 285s. Excellent ride, EXCELLENT wear, excellent stability. Not optimal for fuel economy, but I haven't run ONE million miles in 80 Series because they are fuel efficient.

My statements on this board are based on my experience and I always note that. Your blanket opinion and your chart are wrong in my case, and in my case 36 psi is not under-inflated.
 
Last edited:
That is merely your opinion or a position you are taking based on something you have read. I have 50k miles on the current set of BFG 285/75 16s and they are not even to the halfway point yet. I have been running 285 and 315 BFGs on 6 FJ-80s for a decade and that psi unloaded has worked exceptionally well for me on 285s. Excellent ride, EXCELLENT wear, excellent stability. Not optimal for fuel economy, but I haven't run ONE million miles in 80 Series because they are fuel efficient.

My statements on this board are based on my experience and I always note that. Your blanket opinion and your chart are wrong in my case, and in my case 36 psi is not under-inflated.


Sorry that the facts don't agree with your opinion. If you run close to the load capacity of the vehicle you are putting yourself and others at risks as the tire will be overloaded. I have no doubt your truck rides fines and the tires wear well (you are close to the pressure you should be running).
 
Sorry that the facts don't agree with your opinion. If you run close to the load capacity of the vehicle you are putting yourself and others at risks as the tire will be overloaded. I have no doubt your truck rides fines and the tires wear well (you are close to the pressure you should be running).

On the contrary, you are asserting your opinion as fact. Show me where it is documented that BFG LT285/75/16D's on a 1997 80 Series weighing 5200 lbs are "under-inflated," "close to the load capacity of the vehicle," or anywhere near "overloaded. "

BFG publishes maximum cold inflation pressure at 65 psi. Show me where minimum inflation pressure is noted.
 
For each load index, there is an inflation tire that sets forth the load capacity of the tire at a set PSI.

Per the US Tire & Rim Association YearBook, tire load limits at various pressures for an LT285/75R16D, with a Load Index of 122 are as follows:

PSI - Load Limit (per tire in lbs)
35 - 2130
40 - 2340
45 - 2540
50 - 2755(C)
55 - 2925
60 - 3110
65 - 3305(D)

Therefore, at 36 psi cold, each of my tires have a load limit of at least 2130 lbs vertical. Using your link above, my maximum load-carrying capacity at that psi is 4 x 2130 = 8520 lbs. I weigh 5200 lbs unladen. I am a LONG way from under-inflated at 36 psi.
 
On the contrary, you are asserting your opinion as fact. Show me where it is documented that BFG LT285/75/16D's on a 1997 80 Series weighing 5200 lbs are "under-inflated," "close to the load capacity of the vehicle," or anywhere near "overloaded. "

BFG publishes maximum cold inflation pressure at 65 psi. Show me where minimum inflation pressure is noted.


You missed a few steps. You now need to go find the load capacity at 32psi (factory recommendation) of the OEM P-metric tire (114 load capacity). You then take this weight and multiply by .91 because it is a P-metric tire (see the tire manufacture links I provide explaining why you do this) to get it's load capacity. If you do this with the OEM tire at 35psi (I can't find the load capacity at 32psi), you come up with a load capacity of 2402 pounds.

Now I bet your going to say, well that gives a total load heavier than the truck. Yes, it does, that is because you don't carry a static load, the weight of the vehicle constantly moves as you accelerate, slow down, turn, and go over bumps. The engineers at Toyota have decided for a STOCK truck, the minimum load capacity of a tire should be approximately 2402 pounds (it is probably 2300 pounds at 32psi but as I said, I don't have the chart).

So now we look at your chart, and we find that for a 122 load range LT tire, we need to set the pressure at, 40PSI to equal the factory minimum load of 3300 pounds per tire. But wait, we aren't done yet. You have a bunch of crap on your truck that adds probably 800 pounds, which means you should increase your pressure up to about 45psi.

Those are the facts, that is how ALL the tire manufactures specify you need to set pressures when going from a p-metric tire to another tire, as well as when changing load capacity from any OEM tire. I'm sorry they don't agree with what you find to be a comfortable ride, but LT tires weren't designed for comfort, one of the reasons that a P-metric tire is specified from the factory.
 
You missed a few steps. You now need to go find the load capacity at 32psi (factory recommendation) of the OEM P-metric tire (114 load capacity). You then take this weight and multiply by .91 because it is a P-metric tire (see the tire manufacture links I provide explaining why you do this) to get it's load capacity. If you do this with the OEM tire at 35psi (I can't find the load capacity at 32psi), you come up with a load capacity of 2402 pounds.

For stock Michelin 275/70R16, the table says the factory load is 2480 at 32 psi. So 2480 x .91 = 2257, which falls between 35 and 40 on the chart above.

I do appreciate you attempting to school me on all this, but after looking at this data you are wasting your time on me trying to prove that my tires are under-inflated at 36psi cold versus 40 psi. Frankly, you are splitting hairs. Feel free to crank out some more data if you'd like, but I am going to go wheel my truck......with under-inflated tires at 20 psi.
 
Back
Top Bottom