I think we're on the same page, we were just saying it differently. It's probably my bad for not being the best "explainer".
1)When all four tires are getting equal traction, both driveshafts are turning, and both axles are getting close to equal power.
2)When all four tires are getting unequal traction, the power is diverted to the axle, and then to the wheel, that has the least traction. This is the same as an open diff in the rear end of a vehicle.
With a VC, the effect of Point 2 is lessened since it acts as a LSD. Without the VC, you're effectively screwed (until you lock the center diff) if you're going slow and lift one tire in Hi. That tire will receive all the power and since you have no momentum, you'll just spin that tire and not make it over the obstacle.
So to revise my previous statement, when you're off-road with no VC and the CD unlocked, you're more or less in 2HI. Not technically, but as soon as you lift a wheel or one tire loses all traction and starts spinning, your truck will perform just like a truck that is equipped with 2HI. If you have the switch and you lock the CD, you're then in 4HI, and if you drop the T/C to low, you're then in 4LO. With the Pin7, it gives you 2LO since you can drop the T/C in low and unlock the center diff.
Not having a VC probably makes the biggest difference for those that use slippery boat ramps, don't have the CDL switch, and don't know to go to 4LO to make the front wheels pull.
BUT, if you have the CDL switch, understand that for off road with no V/C you might as well lock the CD, and realize that on ice and slippery conditions you're driving an open center diff vehicle, you should be fine.
I for one like the VC, anything that gives me more traction is a plus but the reported $900-$1000 to replace one could be spent on far better mods.
If I do take mine out, I'm going to cut it open on a lathe and see what's what. Maybe it can be repaired?