Cylinder head cracked - redux.....

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 8, 2003
Threads
480
Messages
9,163
So, you all recall the fun and games I had with the 97 we bought used. For those who tuned in late, Blackstone test showed coolant in the oil, changed the HG, continued to use oil, opened 'er up again and found the head was cracked. Well, it's happened again. I now think it must have been overheated and damaged by the previous owner, though everything else was clearly well maintained so I'm giving up on this head (thanks, Onur!) and will be replacing it next week. It lasted about 50,000 miles after the weld and HG replacement.

Here's what happened. Soon after a 6000 mile summer trip, the truck started using coolant a couple weeks ago. I couldn't find any external leaks with UV dye and the special light. Strangely, while filling it I found two tiny pieces of clear plastic film in the radiator neck (more on this later) and saved them. Pulled the spark plugs and they were all uniformly dirty - no steam cleaned plug. No deposits under the oil cap, nothing on the dipstick. Where's the coolant going? So, I sent a sample to Blackstone last week. Before they even got it, peanut butter deposits on the filler cap showed up as by now I was checking all fluids daily. They were kind enough to toss the check and sample in the trash as I had my answer.

The tiny plastic film. After I thought about it, I had a bad realization - they looked like the plastic layer on the head gasket. Called Cdan to have him describe the layer as I thought it had some kind of regular texture to it. Nope. Looked at the stuff under a microscope and it was untextured, too. Bummer. Called back and ordered a HG kit.

So, today I pulled the engine down to the head, removed the cams and pressurized the cooling system with a special tool to see if that welded crack was holding up. Yes, it's holding up fine, but now there's an identical crack between cylinders #4 and #5. Exactly the same - from the center round Allen head plug outboard to the head bolt. With the dye in the coolant, you simply mop up as much oil as you can from the top of the head and then pressurize the cooling system, then use the special light to see a perfect line of bright green forming.

So, at 198,800 miles (!) the old girl's getting a new (used) head. I'll be adding a few more tips to the Head Gasket DVD, and hopefully permanently close the chapter on this issue. I have an hour's work yet to pull the head (probably Sunday) and will then find out how the HG fared. Dan and I agreed there are a couple areas on the HG that normally lose the film so I may simply be the first person to happen upon it. These areas are where the HG partially blocks a couple of coolant passages to modify the flow near cylinder #6 and they're often missing the clear film when changed out. But there's a chance something else want awry, so I'm anxious to pull the head.

Hope you are all enjoying a more restful weekend than I!!!!!

DougM
 
Major bummer!

Do you have a link to the thread re: welding the head?
 
PS - thought about taking one for the team and putting in a fix from NAPA purported to fix a HG or cracked head to see if it worked. It's a can of blue fluid that's $65 and takes 2 hours of idling to work and my buddy there says they've sold 35 of them and it has worked every time, including one guy who's racked up some 80k miles. But I couldn't handle the thought of what it might do to the engine down the road...

The thread is in the head gasket FAQ.

DougM
 
So, you all recall the fun and games I had with the 97 we bought used. For those who tuned in late, Blackstone test showed coolant in the oil, changed the HG, continued to use oil, opened 'er up again and found the head was cracked. Well, it's happened again. I now think it must have been overheated and damaged by the previous owner, though everything else was clearly well maintained so I'm giving up on this head (thanks, Onur!) and will be replacing it next week. It lasted about 50,000 miles after the weld and HG replacement.

Here's what happened. Soon after a 6000 mile summer trip, the truck started using coolant a couple weeks ago. I couldn't find any external leaks with UV dye and the special light. Strangely, while filling it I found two tiny pieces of clear plastic film in the radiator neck (more on this later) and saved them. Pulled the spark plugs and they were all uniformly dirty - no steam cleaned plug. No deposits under the oil cap, nothing on the dipstick. Where's the coolant going? So, I sent a sample to Blackstone last week. Before they even got it, peanut butter deposits on the filler cap showed up as by now I was checking all fluids daily. They were kind enough to toss the check and sample in the trash as I had my answer.

The tiny plastic film. After I thought about it, I had a bad realization - they looked like the plastic layer on the head gasket. Called Cdan to have him describe the layer as I thought it had some kind of regular texture to it. Nope. Looked at the stuff under a microscope and it was untextured, too. Bummer. Called back and ordered a HG kit.

So, today I pulled the engine down to the head, removed the cams and pressurized the cooling system with a special tool to see if that welded crack was holding up. Yes, it's holding up fine, but now there's an identical crack between cylinders #4 and #5. Exactly the same - from the center round Allen head plug outboard to the head bolt. With the dye in the coolant, you simply mop up as much oil as you can from the top of the head and then pressurize the cooling system, then use the special light to see a perfect line of bright green forming.

So, at 198,800 miles (!) the old girl's getting a new (used) head. I'll be adding a few more tips to the Head Gasket DVD, and hopefully permanently close the chapter on this issue. I have an hour's work yet to pull the head (probably Sunday) and will then find out how the HG fared. Dan and I agreed there are a couple areas on the HG that normally lose the film so I may simply be the first person to happen upon it. These areas are where the HG partially blocks a couple of coolant passages to modify the flow near cylinder #6 and they're often missing the clear film when changed out. But there's a chance something else want awry, so I'm anxious to pull the head.

Hope you are all enjoying a more restful weekend than I!!!!!

DougM
:cheers: to Beno... and to getting your LC back in the game! :steer:
 
Neither - she's totally stock. I'd doubt any overheat issues after we got her because my first order of business was new Toyota rad, thermo, hoses, belts, Toyota Red and then regular flushes ahead of the Toyota schedule. It also has the blue fan clutch, always synthetic oil changed early, blah blah. Basically, a pampered pet...

DougM
 
Has hindsight roughed you up about not replacing the head last time?
 
I know I should stay out of this - or invoke the wrath of the head gasket Gods - but is there a plastic film on the replacement HG? Does it stay on or get removed before installation? If it stays on - doesn't it get a "little hot" ? (and melt?)

My other recurring question (just curiosity more than anything) but are folks checking the block deck to ensure it is flat? Cracking a head in two different places seems unusual - no? As well as the frequency of head gasket repairs that pop up on this forum - although I recognize it is a "weighted" sample
 
Last edited:
Dan,

Nope. Great shop did the work (the used head will go there, too) and I felt the head was as good as new by the time they welded it, milled it flat, replaced the valve seals and adjusted the valve clearances. Had they cautioned me or expressed a lack of confidence in the repair I'd feel a bit bummed at my decision right now. That their repair held fine is a testament.

However, now that you mention it I wonder if their repair put some tension on the head that eventually came out? Hmmm. Dunno - any metallurgists want to weigh in? The welder they use is a highly trained guy who's on call for welding their aluminum heads. He's quite the wizard and didn't even consider the location of my crack to be particularly challenging They preheat the head to 400F before welding and such.

So, I was really quite confident in the repair. I'm very curious what I'll find as to the HG itself. I borrowed a 30" flatness testing tool for the block at that time and I'm hoping to do it again to ensure the block is still flat. I'm going to be VERY careful about removing this one as I want to solve the mystery of the plastic film. To answer AJP's questions, It's on the old original gaskets as well as the new version and I believe the substance is sprayed on to assist the HG in bonding to the head and block deck. My theory until tomorrow either disproves or supports it is that I just happen to be anal enough to notice the little pieces and that they're from the blocking sections of the HG. Meaning the HG will be fully intact and correctly bonded and if I'm lucky it will be easy to tell. Bet I'll be up early tomorrow morning as all I have left is to remove the EFI system and the 12 bolts holding the lower intake runners onto the head. In fact, if we didn't have dinner plans tonight I'd be out there wrenching this evening. OK, maybe not since it would still be a time I could spend with my family. Place your bets!!!

DougM
 
Well, the plastic film looks to be 'normal' and is from the places I expected it to be. The HG was in perfect shape and it looks to be a simple cleanup and reassembly with another head that will be reconditioned with a valve job, seals, etc.

Also found a way to leave the EFI system intact and simply pull it out of the way with the lower half of the intake. There's a couple hours work saved.

DougM
 
Yeah, I'll have pics of the HG. That new design is clearly superior. Fire ring shows near zero distortion at 58,000 miles of use and IMO that was the weak area - #6 fire ring. I'll wipe it off this week and take a hi res picture to add to Cdan's gallery. A couple head bolts came off 'funny'. By that I mean they didn't unscrew smoothly so I segregated them and all will be measured by a machinist for re-use. I have 4 new ones on hand in case I need them.

Gonna then take the damaged head over into the Hunting and Fishing thread and take bets to see if I can fire my .44 mag rounds through the head completely. Kind of a hillbilly "port and polish" treatment. Then it will become a garage wall ornament....

DougM
 
If you've already got 4 new bolts, I'd use 'em. Head bolts (like any other bolts) "stretch" when you tighten them down. Sometimes, they don't like to "spring back". The more you torque them and untorque them, the less they like the whole springing back thing. Save yourself some headache, toss the old bolts in the trash you've been through enough already!!!!
 
There's a measurement for it and I'll have this done by a machinist. It's also important to clean the threads well. I'll be chasing the threads and importantly ensuring there is no oil in the bottom of the head bolt holes.

DougM
 
Hopefully you use oil when chasing the threads. When I break off taps in holes I do it in a machine shop, so it's merely embarrassing.

If the bolt threads are getting rough that's a bad sign, even if they aren't elongated. You could turn them through a die to clean them up, but it'd make me wonder what's causing it.

This would sure be a lot more fun if you still lived here!
 
But he doesn't have me there! Or the machine shop I have full run of. Yeah, I really loved my travels out west. There have been serious discussions in my family about moving to Colorado, still not out of the picture. Kind of a long commute to O'Hare though. There's not a lot I'd miss about Michigan, some things, not a lot.
 
Back
Top Bottom