cracked block!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 4, 2004
Threads
13
Messages
73
Location
Richmond, va
Well I had a thread about my leaking core/freeze plug, and thought I was in the clear as far as a cracked block goes. I was trying to take pics with my camera phone (didn't work) BUT the bright always on flash my phone has showed me that I do indeed have a cracked block. It is in the same place as the other 2 that I know of, here's one... https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.p...ht=freeze+plug

It is just under the middle freeze plug that is under the intake. I think I also have a leaky freeze plug so Im going to replace that and see if its still leaking. Not quite sure what action (if any) I will take on the crack right now. My Dad has a friend with a machine shop who is a very competant welder, I may let him have a look at it. Any suggestions?
 
To be honest I'd just look for a used motor. 1FZEs are not in huge demand as the last so well so there is getting to be a sort of surplus of them around from folks who buy rolled rigs and part them out. I know cruiserman has one for sale and I think lagwagon has a couple of more. Unfortunately, Idaho and California are a long ways from VA.
 
okay, so lets say I go that route, if I can stop the leak (hopefully its the freeze plug) how long can I drive it before that crack gets so bad that its leaking antifreeze faster than I can put it in? IF my plan is to put a new/rebuilt/used engine in it, it certainly can't hurt anything to keep driving it like it is, right? I can be the guinea pig to see how long a cracked 1fze will run.. I mean "if" it doesn't get much worse, there is no reason it can't and won't run "forever" like it is?? Is catastrophic failure a possiblity?
 
Sorry ... and I feel your pain...had similar bad things happen in the past. On the other hand if it is just a small weep and you are loosing only a few cups a month ... you might be able to drive it into the ground long before the crack is a significant issue. Not sure you have anything to lose at this point. If it is reasonably accessible there may be some treatments worth trying while the block is in situ.
If you had to go to the trouble of pulling the block to mend it I think I would be inclined to replace the block with a reman one

..on a previous thread I related how a friends Renault was patched with a mystery material that seemed to last very well. Was like a very hard epoxy. Now that you know you have the crack it might be worthwhile installing a proper frost plug and soda blast the whole area while the block is in the vehicle and then try applying some appropriate sealer.. sealing the whole area. Sorry I never did find out what was used on the Renault ...

If you and several others are seeing this particular issue... I imagine there are still others with the problem not yet noticed.

My money's on a bad casting. But for all I know could be a very thick part of the block with a different rate of expansion that when heated causes the stress crack....the experts will eventually figure it out. What do I know? Heck I'm suspicious that the cause of blown head gaskets around no.6 cylinder may be due warped blocks...everyone checks the head ... but don't hear much about the straightedge results on the block.. and I think it would be tough to eyeball that sort of issue without a mirror unless you pull the block ??. Good luck.. If I run across that epoxy I'll drop you a PM.
 
it's not the challenges you face but how you deal with them.

I've never dealt with something like this but the first thing I'd do is get some sort of die and try and access how large or long the crack is.

Then formulate your best attack at a repair and have at it, you can't do much more damage to it anyway.
 
J B WELD :doh:
 
okay, so lets say I go that route, if I can stop the leak (hopefully its the freeze plug) how long can I drive it before that crack gets so bad that its leaking antifreeze faster than I can put it in? IF my plan is to put a new/rebuilt/used engine in it, it certainly can't hurt anything to keep driving it like it is, right? I can be the guinea pig to see how long a cracked 1fze will run.. I mean "if" it doesn't get much worse, there is no reason it can't and won't run "forever" like it is?? Is catastrophic failure a possiblity?

Check this out there metal stitch can repair a crack better than the original casting. You can also repair cracked heads.

http://www.locknstitch.com/

http://www.locknstitch.com/Repair pdf files/Cummins 5.9 crack repair instructions.pdf
 
I think my plan at this point is to clean the area up even better, maybe get some dye and make sure the crack isn't a mile long. I am going to try some of the Bars stop leak in it, and see if the leak goes away. Then I will put some JB weld on it..
I also got to thinking that I just noticed the leak after flushing it this weekend. It wouldn't be outside of the realm of possibility that the leak was there when I bought it a year ago, and that it was hidden with some stop leak then. That stuff washes out with a good flush from what I understand. I don't think I am going to try any major surgery to fix it, at this point, depending on the crack. whos to say that it is even a full thickness crack?
One other thing, it has a new radiator in it, so it could have had overheating issues in the past, is there anyway to tell if the headgasket has been done?

My thinking is that before I pay big money or even pulled the engine to fix that crack I would just use a reman engine anyway, so I might as well use this one for as long as possible without spending a TON of time or $$ on it. BUT I will certainly start saving $$ for when the headgasket and/or oil pan gasket need to be replaced, because I think it would be a good time to pull the whole engine and replace it with what ever I was going to replace it with..
 
if it were me I'd do my best to find the end of the crack and if possible drill and plug just beyond that to stop the crack from travelling any further. Then if after several attempts to stop the leak completely and failing you could at least confidently predict the need to add coolant and not worry about a looming total failure of the cooling system.
 
My thinking is that before I pay big money or even pulled the engine to fix that crack I would just use a reman engine anyway, so I might as well use this one for as long as possible without spending a TON of time or $$ on it
Bang on!!!

I think Rick's suggestion about looking into a way of preventing the crack from spreading is wise. Not sure if the cure is worse than the disease though so you would want any drilling and plugging done by a well qualified expert with good credentials.

I am not a big fan of additives as they can also clog the rad and the heater core... but if you end up with a new block down the road ... a new rad then may be in scope.

I also think that you are wise in questioning just how deep/long the crack is ... who knows .. maybe it is actually quite small and could stay that way for several hundred thousand miles of normal driving... sometimes we get too obsessive about issues and don't enjoy the vehicle as we should.

Personally I'd top up the coolant; make sure I had a 60/40 mix of Toyota red (I think that is the max concentration and it may help to reduce your coolant loss through a small crack) put a new OEM rad cap on and drive the vehicle to operating temp. Shut it down ... let the heat collect in the block and have a look at the crack for 30-40 minutes. the amount of flow or weeping will tell you if you can ignore it or not...

edited to add... I just had a look at the "Lock and Stitch" - it is a clever approach. There is a site where guys are trying it on a Cummins diesel block crack (apparently common on one of the models) and they are not having great success. I gather that their conclusion is that the section of block they are dealing with is too thin to hold up after the lock and stitch treatment and cracks return ... fwiw.
 
Last edited:
I don't know if I will get to it this weekend, BUT I will post up some pictures of the area once I get it cleaned up...
thanks again for all the suggestions/support
Steven
 
Block

If this makes you feel any better had the freeze plug leaking in the same manor, took it to toyota to get it fixed. It was back leaking again in about 6mo and they did a warranty about a year later it was leaking again and they told me it had a hairline crack and would not fix it under warranty. I put some block sealer in it and has not been a problem since. It has gone apx 60,000 miles and still holding I had always thought they were trying to get out of poor workmanship but I have heard of this a few times. I am lucky enough to have a spare motor I bought used a few years ago but have not needed to use it.
Good luck
 
I also put some bars leak in it and have not seen it grow any since, actually haven't thought about it since I saw that the leak had stopped. I may put some JB weld over the top of it at some point. The only thing I worry about it is the freezing temps in winter, I may run a 70/30 mix of anti freeze just to be sure that any liquid in the crack doesn't freeze and expand the crack.
 
Back
Top Bottom