Chasing intermittent starting issue

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 7, 2014
Threads
61
Messages
422
Location
Falkner, MS
Here's the rundown.

1991 FJ80 199k has been sitting for years when I purchased it a year ago. It had an "aftermarket" alarm system and had the starter rigged on a push button. Fast forward to what I've done to the truck since DOP...

-Removed aftermarket alarm and repaired splices with solder/heat shrink
-Removed push button and all wiring
-Unlocked Factory Radio
-Replaced Starter
-Replaced Alternator
-Replaced battery
-Replaced starter solenoid/starter activation pigtail

*I've replaced way more items but these are the only electrical items that would have anything to do with my issue I believe*


When everything was removed the truck started fine with the ignition switch. A few months later I attempted to start the truck and nothing. A small peck with a hammer on the starter solenoid and it would fire up. This lead me to believe the starter was bad. I replaced the unit with a New Bosch unit and it started normally for about a week. Then came the same issue. A small peck from a metallic object and it'll start. I inspected the wiring to the starter (large wire) and all is well. I did notice the starter pigtail was slightly deformed so I replaced it with a quality terminal.

I measure the voltage with a volt meter and with key in "start" position its getting 11.8v. The battery has 12.xx volts. The starter will not "click" or make any sound unless "pecked" with something.

I made a 4 foot jumper wire with a terminal on one end and bare on the other. I attached one end to the starter solenoid and then touched the other to the positive terminal on the battery and bam....it starts every time.

I'm thinking the wire from the key switch to the starter could be the issue causing a voltage/amperage drop when attached to the starter and loaded.

Does anyone have any experience with this issue? Relevant wiring diagrams? Thoughts/Opinions are welcome as I'm almost to the end of my rope...
 
I replaced the battery end already. I have not inspected the larger gauge wire to starter as I can make it start consistently with a jumper wire to the solenoid from the hot post.

I'll make sure to remove and inspect that cable just to be sure.

I don't see a relay in the system for the starter. If that's the case could the ignition switch the toast? Any way to test it?
 
There is no starter relay on these trucks.
You're having an issue with the starter logic circuit, which explains why the PO added the push button. He bypassed the OEM logic path rather than fixing the issue.

The starter logic path is as follows:
Battery +, fusible link AM1, fuse AM1, ignition switch, neutral start switch, starter.

Since you are getting voltage (albeit low) at the starter logic terminal, the path is complete, but there is a resistive connection somewhere in the chain. My first guess would be the NSS as the internals will corrode if there has been any water in there. Sometimes rocking the transmission shifter will help it make better contact or shifting into neutral may help as well.
 
Thanks for the reply.

I have not given any thought to the PNP sensor. I do have a spare transmission...

Are these located on the side of the transmission like the later year trucks? I guess the PNP sensor could cause a voltage drop if its corroded.

*note* I can hear the fuel pump, pumping when I hold the key in the 'Start' position.
 
Thanks for the reply.

I have not given any thought to the PNP sensor. I do have a spare transmission...

Are these located on the side of the transmission like the later year trucks? I guess the PNP sensor could cause a voltage drop if its corroded.

*note* I can hear the fuel pump, pumping when I hold the key in the 'Start' position.
It is called the Neutral Start Switch (NSS) and it is located on the left side of the transmission and is a pie shaped housing that the transmission shift rod passes through. There is a large nut on the outside housing that fastens the shift rod to the NSS. There is a wire harness that exits the top of the NSS and terminates by the starter in 2 connectors. The large rectangular one runs the dashboard tally lamps and the smaller circular connector is the NSS that the starter logic passes through.
For diagnostic purposes, you can short the harness side of the circular connector and see if this makes a difference in voltage drop. Keep in mind that the starter will now be able to crank in all positions.
 
When you turn the key to start, several devices are triggered. The cold start injector time switch which triggers the cold start injector, the first coil of the circuit opening relay which fires the fuel pump, and the starter.
Since the fuel pump is running when you try to start, I would guess that you have a poor connection to the starter and it's not getting enough current to throw the solenoid.
 
Here's what worked on my son's 94: Not only was it delayed but about twice a week we had to tap on the solenoid/starter with a broom stick to make it crank.
94 delayed cranking. Starter, ignition switch, or other?

This brings a full power from the battery to the solenoid. I believe wiring or the ignition switch was dropping voltage to the solenoid which caused the problem. Change the wire to and from the ignition switch, change the switch, or install a Ford Solenoid?
 
I'm going to try running a wire directly from the key switch to the starter solenoid and see if that works. This will rule out a broken down solenoid activation wire.

Based on the information you guys have given I believe this is the most plausible explanation.

I will measure the voltage in and out of the ignition switch and replace if needed.

If neither of these work I'll move on and bypass the NSS



It will be Thursday or Friday before I'll have the opportunity to work on it...will check back and post my findings.

Thanks again!
 
UPDATE/FINAL RESOLUTION :

I pulled the ignition switch and found the wire that controlled the 12V feed to the solenoid. At the Ignition switch the voltage was 12.8v but at the other end of the wire (end that connects to starter solenoid) it was 11.8v. This measurement was with the wire disconnected from the starter solenoid.

When I plugged the wire back to the starter solenoid the voltage remained close to the same at the igniton switch but dropped to about 8v at the starter.

Since the wire is encased in the factory harness I just cut the original solenoid activation wire and ran a new 12GA wire along the harness to the starter.

Works flawlessly now!

Thanks for the help guys!

I believe this wire degrade after years of use due to not having a relay incorporated in the system. Hope this helps someone in the future...just cause you can tap the starter does NOT mean the starter is the issue.
 
UPDATE/FINAL RESOLUTION :

I pulled the ignition switch and found the wire that controlled the 12V feed to the solenoid. At the Ignition switch the voltage was 12.8v but at the other end of the wire (end that connects to starter solenoid) it was 11.8v. This measurement was with the wire disconnected from the starter solenoid.

When I plugged the wire back to the starter solenoid the voltage remained close to the same at the igniton switch but dropped to about 8v at the starter.

Since the wire is encased in the factory harness I just cut the original solenoid activation wire and ran a new 12GA wire along the harness to the starter.

Works flawlessly now!

Thanks for the help guys!

I believe this wire degrade after years of use due to not having a relay incorporated in the system. Hope this helps someone in the future...just cause you can tap the starter does NOT mean the starter is the issue.
So you bypassed the NSS?
 
So you bypassed the NSS?

No, sir.

The wire from the ignition switch to the starter solenoid was evidently bad/broken.

Just replaced it from the ignition switch down to the starter. NSS is still in loop.
 
Sorry.

Yep, I read the post incorrectly. The NSS is bypassed currently in this configuration.

I have a TLCA event this weekend but will continue chasing this issue when I return.
 
Hey gents, I was wondering if tacoma's above issue was the same as mine. My 1997 80 series won't start on hot days after I have run it for a bit. Just the click of everything coming on, gauges, radio, etc... no cranking. After it sits for a while, usually 10-20 minutes it cranks right up. I'm assuming the heat is causing something to not work correctly and once it cools it works fine.. I haven't had this issue in the winter, just the summer. It happened again the other day. I've had the starter replaced but the issue remains (a year or so ago). Let me know what you think. Thanks!
 
Back
Top Bottom