Balancing Toyo's a third time!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 23, 2005
Threads
52
Messages
424
Location
Arroyo Grande, CA
Well, trying to see if anyone has any insight on anything I can say to them or ideas on what they might be doing wrong.

I got new 315 Toyo mounted/balanced and lifetime alignment at Firestone last month. First trip out on the highway and I could feel vibrations at around 55-65 (stock truck, without MPH recalibrated and has stock R&P). So I brought it back and they rebalanced and realigned, (oddly enough alignment was totally off from previous with literally like only 30 miles since previous alignment, none of which was off road?!). They hand me my keys and say "she's all ready!" I ask well is the prob. fixed? What did they find? They guy goes back and I can see him talking to the tech and comes back and gives me a generic answer like, "yeah they were just a bit off it should be good now." I leave not really caring as long as it drives ok

So I go home, (didn't take it out on the highway. DOH!), park it in the garage, and then we start a trip on the highway, (going up to Arnold), and no suprise now, I know the feeling by heart the wheels are still not balanced!

Firestone is being nice about it, I actually stopped by with my kid and no time to drop it off and told them I'm not trying to be a D!ck but it's shaking still at highway speeds and they said, "no prob, just bring it back for fine tuning,"

So the plan is to drop it off tomorrow morning. So far they have clamp on weights on the outside and sticker weights on the inside? Is this best for balancing? I don't care what they look like as long as the wife can drive it with a smile. Haven't checked the lug tightness. Are they torquing to spec, in the correct pattern? The wheels are lugcentric do they know that?

Going to try to actually talk to the tech tomorrow. Any help appreciated.
 
The alignment changed? I'd look somewhere besides your tires for the problem.

-Spike
 
Ah, thank you, I left that out.

No vibrations were present prior to the new tire instalation!

And what I meant by the alignment changing were the toe in/out numbers from the first alignment, (immediatelly after tire installation), to the second alignment. But I don't believe toe in out would cause highway vibrations.

With that said would you still look elsewhere?
 
I had the same thing. What saved my day is I went to a different tire cenetr (this case a Toyota dealer) who load balances, Night and day difference. Do a search, there has been many a listing on this subject.
 
my Toyos were so well balanced when I bought them they threw of the balance machine, the reading showed weights needed oposite each weight, so in effect they were round and balanced but the machine wouldnt read that, we put weights on when we didnt need them, then when took them off the tires road real smooth. Toyo 315, MT Open countrys,
 
my Toyos were so well balanced when I bought them they threw of the balance machine, the reading showed weights needed oposite each weight, so in effect they were round and balanced but the machine wouldnt read that, we put weights on when we didnt need them, then when took them off the tires road real smooth. Toyo 315, MT Open countrys,


X2.

This is my third set of Toyo's. The last set was and still is a set of 37's sitting on my friends Jeep with beadlocks...we never balanced them and they have been on that jeep for well over a year now of DD duty.


I would try a different shop and also realize, sometimes you get a defective tire. I knew a guy that went through 3 Goodyear MT/R's that went out of round after a year of use...Discount Tire's warranty pays for itself in that situation.


How much air did the shop put in? I've had shops OVER inflate my tires so bad, they were riding on the middle of the tread. This can and will create odd handling and vibes.

The alignment...well, maybe they didn't get it right at first. Nothing should change there with a simple tire change. Unless your out hitting curbs. :lol:
 
X2.
...How much air did the shop put in? I've had shops OVER inflate my tires so bad, they were riding on the middle of the tread. This can and will create odd handling and vibes.

The alignment...well, maybe they didn't get it right at first. Nothing should change there with a simple tire change. Unless your out hitting curbs. :lol:

haha, funny you should mention that. After the initial tire insall, I checked the PSI when I got home and they were all at like 45! I changed them back to 32. (I didn't say anything to them and checked the second time and they left the PSI at 32).

[EDIT]Alignment was taken 'after' the tires were installed and then done. I had literally only driven it home then the first highway drive it was shaking, then finished our couple hundred mile trip before I brought it back, so not much of a reason for anything to have changed. I'm bringing my 2 alignment forms with me tomorrow and ask them about that. I'll try and scan them later when I get home to post...
 
Last edited:
Well, some places are full of morons with wrenches. It's hard to find a good place anymore. :( Good luck man.
 
load balancing is the proper way to balance a very large tire, but it is not cheap. I am working on this very thing and decided to just throw more balancing beads in (I was wrong on my initial calculation anyway).
 
haha, funny you should mention that. After the initial tire insall, I checked the PSI when I got home and they were all at like 45! I changed them back to 32. (I didn't say anything to them and checked the second time and they left the PSI at 32).

[EDIT]Alignment was taken 'after' the tires were installed and then done. I had literally only driven it home then the first highway drive it was shaking, then finished our couple hundred mile trip before I brought it back, so not much of a reason for anything to have changed. I'm bringing my 2 alignment forms with me tomorrow and ask them about that. I'll try and scan them later when I get home to post...

My Toyos have been "smooth as silk"...you might wanna see another tire shop. Also, try running your tires at approx. 36 to 40 psi...seems that range provides the best on-road ride. Good Luck...
 
haha, funny you should mention that. After the initial tire insall, I checked the PSI when I got home and they were all at like 45! I changed them back to 32. (I didn't say anything to them and checked the second time and they left the PSI at 32).

I run my 285 Toyos at ~42 psi. I think Romer runs his 315s at 45 psi. If you look on the 80 FAQs there is mention of tire pressure when you go to an LT tire. Basically you run about 10 psi more in an "LT" tire than you would normally run in a "P" tire

80s Tire FAQs

My Toyos seem have balanced extremely well and even after CM07 I don't have any vibration issues :)
 
Are you guys saying that the suddenly fabled and incredibly expensive Toyo MT vibrates unless you run outrageously high PSI's? That's a lot of air pressure for a load range E tire on a vehicle that runs 31-32 stock. I've never run a tire at anywhere near those pressures that didn't suffer a major dry pavement handling loss as well as ride like a brick.

Need more details given this is supposed to be "the" tire right now.
 
I run mine at 35 PSI.

They are E-range tires and stiff to begin with, I honestly can't imagine running anymore pressure unless your really loaded down or towing some real weight.

Mine do not vibrate. Mine are all static balanced with less than 4 oz of weight on each tire/wheel.

My 37" MT/R's on the other hand took well over 15+ oz of weight and STILL had a slight hop.


That being said, I'd LOVE to get rid of these Toyo's and go back to MT/R's. ;) They aren't the greatest tire like some seem to think. IMHO.
 
Are you guys saying that the suddenly fabled and incredibly expensive Toyo MT vibrates unless you run outrageously high PSI's? That's a lot of air pressure for a load range E tire on a vehicle that runs 31-32 stock. I've never run a tire at anywhere near those pressures that didn't suffer a major dry pavement handling loss as well as ride like a brick.

Need more details given this is supposed to be "the" tire right now.

Nay,

Here is the info from the FAQs

Summary of Tire Pressure-

The Stock 80 uses a P-metric tire (designated by the use of a P in the size i.e. P275/70/16), with a recommended inflation pressure of 32psi. When converting to a light truck tire (LT) which most A/T and Max Traction tires are (LT is designated on the sidewall next to the size i.e. LT275/70/16), you should add approximately 10psi to the factory recommended pressures. Based on the load charts (and this doesn't matter whether you are running a C, D, or E rated tire) you should adjust your base pressure to be as follows when changing to an LT tire:

275/70/16, 265/75/16 - 42-45psi,
285/75/16, 305/70/16 - 40-42 psi,
295/75/16- 38-40psi,
315/75/16- 36-40 psi.

You should not go below the minimum pressures above. If you have a truck that has a lot of extra weight (i.e. sliders, bull bar, winch, bumpers, etc.) add 5-8psi to the above.
 
Are they torquing to spec, in the correct pattern?

most likely no,

They either ran 'em home with the impact, or ran them on with the impact with a "torque stick"

and then after that if you are at a high end tire shop they got out the torque wrench and clicked on each one without the nut moving, in the mind of a tire guy this is proper torque,

this will tell them if one is too loose but they have no idea if it is overtightened. I tried explaining this to one of them once he did not understand and got angry and defensive.

I wear my uniform (mechanic) to these places and usually I put the wheels on wile the tire guy does runs the tire and balance machine. if that cannot happen I loosen and re torque in the parking lot,

About 10 years ago I lived in warner robins, a neighbor worked at a used tire place, he saved up for some nice tires and rims for his monte carlo, he put them on himself, he was quite proud of them, few days later it showed up on a roll back with one of the front wheels missing and the fender destroyed.

when I asked what happened he said he had no idea why the wheel came off, he made sure they were "real tight", he put the impact on each lug for a whole minute.

:eek: :rolleyes: :doh:

I don't think that si the source of your vibration, it is the source of broken and stripped studs though so get out your torque wrench.
 
Sometimes you can spin the tire on the wheel. 90degrees, can help...

Air down, place on machine and break bead, spin 90 degrees and re-inflait, balance.

It's a last ditch effort before exchanging for another tire.

[It's also could be a bad tire from the factory.]

If all else falls, they should exchange tire.

Good luck...:beer:
 
Nay,

Here is the info from the FAQs

Summary of Tire Pressure-

The Stock 80 uses a P-metric tire (designated by the use of a P in the size i.e. P275/70/16), with a recommended inflation pressure of 32psi. When converting to a light truck tire (LT) which most A/T and Max Traction tires are (LT is designated on the sidewall next to the size i.e. LT275/70/16), you should add approximately 10psi to the factory recommended pressures. Based on the load charts (and this doesn't matter whether you are running a C, D, or E rated tire) you should adjust your base pressure to be as follows when changing to an LT tire:

275/70/16, 265/75/16 - 42-45psi,
285/75/16, 305/70/16 - 40-42 psi,
295/75/16- 38-40psi,
315/75/16- 36-40 psi.

You should not go below the minimum pressures above. If you have a truck that has a lot of extra weight (i.e. sliders, bull bar, winch, bumpers, etc.) add 5-8psi to the above.

That's fine that this in the FAQ, but why? 8 more PSI for a loaded truck? Over 50 PSI on a 3,500 lb load range tire on a 7,000 lb gross vehicle weight rig? That is crazy. I would never follow that chart.

What is it about an "LT" tire, which is supposed to have a stiffer sidewall, that requires so much more air pressure? There were BFG AT's on my 80 when I bought it (285's) and they were bricks even at 35 PSI - I can't imagine running that tire at 40+.

Discount Tire and other shops seems to think this as well given they alway mount and balance them at 42-45 PSI, and then I have to go and take 12 -15 PSI back out and have them rebalanced or the truck is just about undriveable. I always wonder what is wrong with my new tires until I realize they've gone nuts on air pressure again. Now I just tell them 31 PSI and not to mess with pressure on rotations and rebalance.

My trxus MT's are 35x12.5x16LT and are load range E. They run the best by far right at stock tire pressures. I was out in Moab in April, and it was 40 degrees warmer and 3,000 feet lower than at my house when we left, and I kept wondering why my handling was sloppy, only to remember that 5 PSI I gained by getting warmer and losing altitude. My truck would be literally undriveable at our FAQ recommendations.

This just seems a bit like gospel that doesn't have a rationale behind it beyond a tire shop mitigating legal liability based on some arbitrary manufacturer recommendation. You also can't put a 35" tire on a 7" rim according to those charts :rolleyes:
 
So just dropped the 80 off this AM. They stated they don't have load balancing, (all three balances have been done for free by the way since this is still a prob since day 1), but I did tell them that all the wheels have only one weight except for one that has four, (in the pic below), so at some point I would imagine the tire would need to be spun on the wheel. The dude behind the couter just said "uh-huh."

Anyway we'll see how she drives and I'll need to retighten all lug nuts as well. I also mentioned they're lug centric, not hub. But hopefully the tech would know that as he is taking the lug nuts off!!!
wheel.weights.webp
 
I would be pretty bent about that much weight for a tire, not to mention that the weights will get ripped off on the trail, they should put them on the inside of the rim
 
Back
Top Bottom