Bad EGR question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Its funny how questions arise exactly when I am experiencing and asking the same thing. Apparently the answer is yes because if the EGR is not working properly, it causes the cylinders to run hotter than normal whick will cause pinging. Mine does the exact same thing and my EGR insifficient flow code has been up for a while now (PO401 & P042). I have done everything I could find on the subject here on MUD so now I am just thinking I may replace the EGR vacume modulator and EGR valve itself. The modulator did not pass the FSM blow test very well so I think there may be some blackage inside. I'll be sure and follow up with my findings as soon as I correct the problem.
Mark
 
I am having a similar problem and am going to try replacing the pc valve first...that can pull up similar problems when it fails and it is a lot cheaper to fix.
 
okefenokeefzj80- I have replaced my PCV several times (if that's what you mean) but the thing keeps on rattling.

Imagery- i found the EGR at autozone for $169.00, sounds like a reasonable price, question is will it work right?
 
Yea, that is the price I found somewhere and the modulator is about $60 I think. I will just call CDan when I am ready and have it within a couple days.

What part of the EGR system is in the back and underneath the manifokd? I ask because about two months ago, when I was having new tires put on, I asked the mechanic to see if he could figure out why the CEL (0401 &402 keeps coning on. He did replace something but it was behind the manifold somewhere and I am not sure what he replaced. The CEL stayed off for a couple weeks and then is came back on.
 
EGR has been replaced and the check engine light is back on again.

I took the 80 and had them reset the computer at Autozone, then after a day or so the light came back on.

Could there be another sensor that can be causing this?

Any suggetions?
 
Could there be another sensor that can be causing this?

Any suggetions?

There is probably more information on the P0401 code than any other topic except maybe "Which is the best tyre?".

There are 4 components to the EGR system plus the interconecting hoses and tubes. In decreasing probability of being the defective part:

* Interconnecting hoses and tube through the intake
* VSV for EGR
* EGR Modulator
* EGR Valve
* EGR temp sensor
* Wiring to the EGR temp sensor or the ECM (never seen this)

Failures of the EGR valve and the EGR temp sensor are rare but a few have reported that replacing these fixed the problem. Some guys have just replaced all of the above in one service so they have no idea what component failed.

-B-
 
About a year ago I was trying to fix the same CEL code on mine. I systematicly replaced all the EGR components. Nothing worked. Finally I tore off the top half of the intake to clean out the EGR tube through the plenium. Its a couple hr job and I wasnt sure I could do it. Well, the EGR path/tube was completely blocked solid with guk. It took quite a while to clean it as nothing disoves that stuff well. In the end the thing that worked best was boiling water poured in/through there repeatedly(it is off the engine at that point). That finally cleared my code and it hasn't come back since. Before replacing anything I would tear it down enough to see if this passage is blocked/constricted. Live and learn.
 
Thanks for the advice guys, looks like I’m going to tear into it this weekend.

I seems that ever since my check engine light came on my engine rattles like nobody's business. (I think it's because the cylinders are running hotter due to the EGR valve not working properly)

Is that also your experience?
 
Last edited:
About a year ago I was trying to fix the same CEL code on mine. I systematicly replaced all the EGR components. Nothing worked. Finally I tore off the top half of the intake to clean out the EGR tube through the plenium. Its a couple hr job and I wasnt sure I could do it. Well, the EGR path/tube was completely blocked solid with guk. It took quite a while to clean it as nothing disoves that stuff well. In the end the thing that worked best was boiling water poured in/through there repeatedly(it is off the engine at that point). That finally cleared my code and it hasn't come back since. Before replacing anything I would tear it down enough to see if this passage is blocked/constricted. Live and learn.

If you're talking about the tube that runs through the intake to the hose that connects to the VSV - mine was completely full of corrosion/carbon. I passed small drill bit through it on the top side and used a pick to clean the other side then blew it and the hose out with compressed air until it was clean/clear of crap. I replaced the VSV (also corroded) and modulator and cleaned temp sensor and all the hoses. Code was off for about 10 miles, now cel is back. :crybaby:

All that's left to replace is the EGR valve. I wonder how much those are?
 
About a year ago I was trying to fix the same CEL code on mine. I systematicly replaced all the EGR components. Nothing worked. Finally I tore off the top half of the intake to clean out the EGR tube through the plenium. Its a couple hr job and I wasnt sure I could do it. Well, the EGR path/tube was completely blocked solid with guk. It took quite a while to clean it as nothing disoves that stuff well. In the end the thing that worked best was boiling water poured in/through there repeatedly(it is off the engine at that point). That finally cleared my code and it hasn't come back since. Before replacing anything I would tear it down enough to see if this passage is blocked/constricted. Live and learn.

The way to tell if your passage is blocked is fairly simple. If you have a vacuum pump, hook it to the EGR valve with the engine idling. As you apply vacuum, the engine should start to run rough and, if everything is clear, the engine should stall/die. The optional methods are to use an engine vacuum source instead of the vacuum pump, or to reach through the bottom of the valve with a BLUNT instrument and lift the valve manually.
 
There is probably more information on the P0401 code than any other topic except maybe "Which is the best tyre?".

There are 4 components to the EGR system plus the interconecting hoses and tubes. In decreasing probability of being the defective part:

* Interconnecting hoses and tube through the intake
* VSV for EGR
* EGR Modulator
* EGR Valve
* EGR temp sensor
* Wiring to the EGR temp sensor or the ECM (never seen this)

Failures of the EGR valve and the EGR temp sensor are rare but a few have reported that replacing these fixed the problem. Some guys have just replaced all of the above in one service so they have no idea what component failed.

-B-

Very good advice! IMO you can spend more $$ replacing parts, than letting a professional diagnose the problem.;)

BTW-The part under the intake is the EGR Vacuum Switching Valve(VSV).
 
The way to tell if your passage is blocked is fairly simple. If you have a vacuum pump, hook it to the EGR valve with the engine idling. As you apply vacuum, the engine should start to run rough and, if everything is clear, the engine should stall/die. The optional methods are to use an engine vacuum source instead of the vacuum pump, or to reach through the bottom of the valve with a BLUNT instrument and lift the valve manually.

This test on my clogged system did produce results. I can't explain it but it did change how the engine was idling. The engine began to lope a bit and run rough. It came nowhere near dieing though.
 
I installed a new EGR back in Feb. and instantly witnessed the engine running smoother. Additionally, I did hear less of the pinging from before and notice my engine would idle much lower (from 800 - 900 down to 600 - 700 rpms)
 
Very good advice! IMO you can spend more $$ replacing parts, than letting a professional diagnose the problem.;)

Or, you can spend even less money by learning how to diagnose the problem yourself, buy any bad parts from CruiserDan, and completely leave the "professional" from the equation. ;)

-B-
 
Back
Top Bottom