Any pilots on here?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Threads
119
Messages
821
Location
Los Angeles
I got a com question.
 
PM sent
 
depends on what you mean by pilots, I'm not up on many types of flying.
 
Last edited:
Go ahead with your question.
 
OK, this is kind of off the wall, but here goes.

I go out into the real boonies sometimes, with several different groups, and we often wonder what we'd do in a bona-fide (medical or other serious) emergency.

Some of the members have even rented sat phones, and the results there are mixed. Sometimes they work, sometimes not. Nothing you can guarantee.

We all run 2meter gear, some of us also have 440, but often there is no repeater coverage, so they're great for simplex between the group members, but useless when trying to contact outside help. And of course, the cell coverage is zip.

So, I was wondering about keeping a hand-held aircraft radio in the truck, only to be used in a true emergency situation.

I am aware of the laws about their usage, I would absolutely not use this unless it was a dire emergency. Use of any radio frequency in a bonafide emergency is lawful.

My question is this: What kind of range would one expect with one of the little 5-watt handhelds, when trying to raise a jetliner or other aircraft going overhead?

I don't know what kind of wattage the com radios on the jetliners put out, but I'm certain it's a lot more than 5 watts. So I'm wondering if this idea even has any merit?

I'm not sure that one of these handhelds would be able to contact a commercial liner at 36,000 feet that's 75 or 100 miles away.

What do you think?
 


Yeah, I suppose that's an option. However, that does require an annual subscription, doesn't it?

I was thinking about buying a used handheld for around $100 and just stashing it in the truck where it would remain until needed.

It just seems that if the range is sufficient, it would be a low-cost way to contact help when needed.
 
I have used radios like this in the past, before there were really good options on sat phones and way before SPOT. I have never had to use one thankfully. The friend of my who has actually used them for medical evac told me that they work but there are multiple issues to keep in mind. They are line of sight. If you don't see the plane it will not work well. It is a PITA to talk to the pilot and actually convey info. Think "telephone game" you played as a kid. It got the job done, but was a huge pain in the ass. We now just carry a sat phone. Are they as reliable as a cell phone in town? Nope, but they are far better the the radio you are proposing as far as ease of use and chances of getting your message out. The SPOT would be even better.
 
Probably better to ask a HAM enthusiast about this. In the military I dialed up CB frequencies and yakked a couple times, I could hear CBs from several states away and they could hear me. Most CBs are many times over legal output so I'm not sure if that's a good comparison. Sometimes guys in operations will talk over their handheld radios to us when we're flying in on an arrival, 10,000 feet and maybe 50 miles. Again, these are probably higher-output handhelds. I haven't used a handheld aircraft radio in an airplane, I think my dad has, I'll ask him how that works. I've heard some guys use handhelds on cross-country flights without a problem.
 
We use handhelds in crew cars while crewing for sailplanes. That little antenna on the handheld radio isn't so good for any long range, so we usually put an antenna on the roof of the truck and run a wire into the rig and hook it up to the handheld. Works much better.

I still think the SPOT setup is probably a better option in your case. Lots of GA pilots and sailplane pilots carrying them these days.
 
Before you buy a handheld you may want to check to see if your 2 meter can be opened up. Most of the smaller airports operate on 122.8 or 122.9. Those are the only frequencies I would monitor while flying around in remote areas. Some of the pilots who regularly fly IFR may have some other ideas on frequencies.

As a ham, I can tell you that all my radios are opened up. I have never transmitted out of band but I can if I need to.

You will probably get a barrage of legal opinions from other pilots and hams but if you have a real emergency the FCC/FAA rule book goes out the window.
 
Before you buy a handheld you may want to check to see if your 2 meter can be opened up. Most of the smaller airports operate on 122.8 or 122.9. Those are the only frequencies I would monitor while flying around in remote areas. Some of the pilots who regularly fly IFR may have some other ideas on frequencies.

As a ham, I can tell you that all my radios are opened up. I have never transmitted out of band but I can if I need to.

You will probably get a barrage of legal opinions from other pilots and hams but if you have a real emergency the FCC/FAA rule book goes out the window.


Thanks to all, so far, for the replies.

I did think about modifying my 2m to go into aircraft band, but the big problem is the 2M radios are usually set to emit FM, whereas the aircraft band customarily uses AM. Not compatible.

The other problem is that being so far out of the band that it was designed to operate in, the radio would probably function poorly. On the other hand, perhaps it would still beat the output of a 5 watt handheld aircraft radio, especially if you had an antenna cut to the proper aircraft band.

Another issue, and hopefully some of you flyers can educate me about this is:

Assuming I was to do this, buy a handheld and use an external antenna, how would I know what frequency to call out on? I know there is the universal emergency frequency, I think it's 121.5 Mhz, but who monitors that, pilots in the air, or only ground stations listening for aircraft in distress?

If the latter, than that wouldn't do any good for my use unless I was close to an airport, (and then other radios would probably work fine then.) So then I'd be up against trying to find which frequency that AA 767 flying overhead is set on.

Or, is there a universal channel that most pilots are listening to?

And you're right, in a true, bona-fide emergency, it is totally legal to transmit in ANY frequency in order to call for and/or render aid.

Of course, some folks might have differing opinions as to what constitutes a "bona-fide" emergency.

:hhmm:

thanks
 
Assuming I was to do this, buy a handheld and use an external antenna, how would I know what frequency to call out on? I know there is the universal emergency frequency, I think it's 121.5 Mhz, but who monitors that, pilots in the air, or only ground stations listening for aircraft in distress?

The only people who have to monitor 121.5 are ground based operators such as ATC towers, FSS services and national ATC centers. Some carriers may require their pilots to monitor this band but I don't know who. Military pilots have to monitor 'guard' but they use 243 MHz.

That is why I thought your best bet would be transmitting on 122.8 or 122.9 as most small airports without a tower designate those frequencies for pilots to send and receive comm for deconfliction purposes.
 
Most corporate aircraft and airlines monitor 121.5 aka "guard frequency" while flying. It allows ATC to get ahold of pilots in case of a wrong frequency assignment or poor reception on another frequency. One can also pick up ELT signals. An ELT is an Emergency Locator Transmitter that emits a signal that search and rescue (SAR) can triangulate on to determine your fix. Pilots typically monitor it and report to ATC when and where they picked up an ELT signal to assist in SAR.
 
Here is the FAA's chapter and verse on emergency assistance:

http://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/ATpubs/AIM/Chap6/aim0603.html

And info for ditching and hijacking, just in case.

very interesting reading, especially the bit about ditching in the water.

However, that treatise is from the perspective of the aircraft being in distress, so it doesn't contemplate the situation I am discussing in this thread: a distressed landlubber reaching out to an aircraft for help.

I doubt the FAA has any thoughts on that subject, but maybe I'm wrong.

;p
 
Airliners are supposed to have one radio monitoring 121.5, but we often go to company ops freq when approaching the airport to check our gate. Sometimes we or ATC misses a frequency change as we're leaving a sector, 121.5 is how they can call us, or have another airplane call us. If it's an emergency, there are no rules. We probably can't turn around and loiter to stay in range, company doesn't give us any extra gas these days.
 
Back
Top Bottom