aluminum radiator

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Shoot, I did mean rows, not cores. Sorry for the confusion. Anyway it sounds like the article I read was oversimplifying the issue and that there is more going on here. I would be very interested if someone could clarify this or had additional insight. Aluminum radiators do usually have only 1 or 2. There must be a reason for this other than "because they can". Anyone?
 
I guess I misspoke. I was not referring to the weight of a radiator. I was referring to the size of the rows. A larger diameter row will have a lower suface area to volume ratio than a smaller diameter row. It's a fact. Moby stated, "Larger cores within the same physical dimensions means more surface area (usually aluminum rads are 1 or 2 cores vs. 3 or 4 for a quality brass unit)," which is incorrect. He may have meant something else, but that's not what he said.

I've never studied thermal or fluid dynamics, but the larger frontal area of each aluminum row may outweigh the smaller overall surface area when it comes to the transfer of heat from the radiator to mono directional air. Physical design probably outweighs thermal conductivity such that a radiatorl of better design, but less conductive material will outperform a radiator of lesser design and more conductive material. Of course this is all probably a moot point for an LC.

Again, respectfully, you are trying to apply things that don't. It doesn't matter whatsoever what the ratio is between the tube's surface area and the tube's volume and it doesn't matter whatsoever what the displaced volume of the tubes is either (not to be confused with internal volume of coolant the tube holds which does matter much); it just matters the surface area and surface shape (again oval vs. round) of the rows. Additionally the "frontal area" of the tube is less important by design; the intent of ovaling the tubes in fact is to get more contact area between all the fins and the rows and with round copper tubes the contact area is MUCH less than between overall same size ovalized aluminum tubes or even of round aluminum tubes of a larger diameter. So although the frontal area helps some on its own, because it and the rear facing area don't have connection to the corrugated fins, they intentionally help less than the side facing areas with all the connections to the corrugated fins. So, ovalizing tubes which if I'm not mistaken is mostly with Al tubes intentionally reduces the "frontal areas and rear facing areas" area. Again volume has nothing to do with this neither does the ratio btwn volume and area. What has to do with this is surface area, surface shape (which really just lends itself to much more effective surface area via the fins attached to the tubes) and the stacking effect of extra tubes. :cheers:
 
Shoot, I did mean rows, not cores. Sorry for the confusion. Anyway it sounds like the article I read was oversimplifying the issue and that there is more going on here. I would be very interested if someone could clarify this or had additional insight. Aluminum radiators do usually have only 1 or 2. There must be a reason for this other than "because they can". Anyone?

I am going to call Ron Davis on Monday and ask that very question.

I don't want to hijack here but, suffices to say my radiator just went south and this thread was started at just the right time. All things considered. I am leaning towards a aluminum because of my future plans and the strong opinions of folks far smarter than myself.
 
Again, respectfully, you are trying to apply things that don't. It doesn't matter whatsoever what the ratio is between the tube's surface area and the tube's volume and it doesn't matter whatsoever what the displaced volume of the tubes is either (not to be confused with internal volume of coolant the tube holds which does matter much); it just matters the surface area and surface shape (again oval vs. round) of the rows. Additionally the "frontal area" of the tube is less important by design; the intent of ovaling the tubes in fact is to get more contact area between all the fins and the rows and with round copper tubes the contact area is MUCH less than between overall same size ovalized aluminum tubes or even of round aluminum tubes of a larger diameter. So although the frontal area helps some on its own, because it and the rear facing area don't have connection to the corrugated fins, they intentionally help less than the side facing areas with all the connections to the corrugated fins. So, ovalizing tubes which if I'm not mistaken is mostly with Al tubes intentionally reduces the "frontal areas and rear facing areas" area. Again volume has nothing to do with this neither does the ratio btwn volume and area. What has to do with this is surface area, surface shape (which really just lends itself to much more effective surface area via the fins attached to the tubes) and the stacking effect of extra tubes. :cheers:

turbocruiser, I'm not trying to apply anything that isn't applicable. Surface area to volume ratio absolutely matters. We're trying to transfer heat. The larger the surface area per volume is, the more quickly heat will be transfered. You support this by stating that aluminum tubes are ovalized for to increase the fin/core contact area. I was just guessing about frontal area as I'm not familiar with radiator design. If only the side of the row have cooling fins attached, then ovalized tubes are definitely better than round ones. That makes a lot of sense and is where design is more important than material properties.

I'm a little confused because you denounce my statements in one breath and support them in the next (perhaps unintentionally). All I was trying to do was point out that Moby made an incorrect statement. I think he was talking about the row design options available for aluminum and brass. I did not understand this before and interpreted his statement at face value. Now I understand what Moby was trying to say. Thanks.
 
turbocruiser, I'm not trying to apply anything that isn't applicable. Surface area to volume ratio absolutely matters. We're trying to transfer heat. The larger the surface area per volume is, the more quickly heat will be transfered. You support this by stating that aluminum tubes are ovalized for to increase the fin/core contact area. I was just guessing about frontal area as I'm not familiar with radiator design. If only the side of the row have cooling fins attached, then ovalized tubes are definitely better than round ones. That makes a lot of sense and is where design is more important than material properties.

I'm a little confused because you denounce my statements in one breath and support them in the next (perhaps unintentionally). All I was trying to do was point out that Moby made an incorrect statement. I think he was talking about the row design options available for aluminum and brass. I did not understand this before and interpreted his statement at face value. Now I understand what Moby was trying to say. Thanks.

Buddy, I'm not trying to denounce anything at all here and I'm not trying to argue but actually to debate and to educate in a polite and personable way, I'm just trying to say that while surface area matters in all sorts of ways, volume does not! Neither does the ratio btwn the two. Your statement above "The larger the surface area per volume is, the more quickly heat will be transfered." would be correct in context if you would simply remove "per volume" from your statement. I know you're not trying to but you're basically mixing up concepts here. Your originally offered law of as the mass of something increases the ratio btwn surface area and volume decreases is actually one more often applied to the biology of organisms and it also applies to chemical reactions where the surface area to volume ratio makes a major difference in reactivity. Again, I'm not trying to denounce what you wrote, just trying to politely correct it - i think the net makes context of communication hard to tease out - but please trust me then when I say that this isn't an attack at all on you. :cheers:
 
I understand now that the design of the rows makes more of a difference than the material used. Larger, ovalized (flattened) rows will increase the amount of area cooling fins can be soldered to which will increase the amount of cooling that row can accomplish. I'm not debating that. It makes sense. Moby's statement was very simple and I responded to that single simple statement. I now understand what he was talking about, but how can volume of the row not matter? I now know that design makes the most difference , but consider the following example:

A 3" diameter row will have a surface area per volume ratio of 9.43/7.07=1.33 per inch height.
A 2" diameter row will have a surface area per volume ratio of 6.29/3.14=2.00 per inch height.

There are many more factors involved such as thermal transfer of the material in question, coolant flow rate, air flow, etc, but all things being equal coolant in the smaller diameter row will be cooled more quickly than coolant in the larger diameter row.
 
I understand now that the design of the rows makes more of a difference than the material used. Larger, ovalized (flattened) rows will increase the amount of area cooling fins can be soldered to which will increase the amount of cooling that row can accomplish. I'm not debating that. It makes sense. Moby's statement was very simple and I responded to that single simple statement. I now understand what he was talking about, but how can volume of the row not matter? I now know that design makes the most difference , but consider the following example:

A 3" diameter row will have a surface area per volume ratio of 9.43/7.07=1.33 per inch height.
A 2" diameter row will have a surface area per volume ratio of 6.29/3.14=2.00 per inch height.

There are many more factors involved such as thermal transfer of the material in question, coolant flow rate, air flow, etc, but all things being equal coolant in the smaller diameter row will be cooled more quickly than coolant in the larger diameter row.

Right, but now you're mixing displaced volume (as in how much the tube displaces) with internal volume (as in how much coolant capacity the tube has) which is what I wrote above I think. You're also mixing that those rows are all circular in shape; the area calculations above are all based on circles true? Lastly you're negating the very verified principle that the fewer rows get stacked in front of other rows, the better; just like your AC condenser anything that is shedding heat in front of one particular row, like another particular row or series of rows even worse will reduce the efficiency of that row making its "surface area less effective" as noted already. It is much more than proven that fewer larger rows is better than more smaller stacked rows, the physics of why that is is all within the things I'm saying go into the interdependent design of materials and shapes and sizes. :cheers:
 
Displaced volume is virtually the same as internal volume unless the tube wall is very thick. I accept that radiators have specific application variables that I did not understand previously. Yes, I based my calculations and first post observations on circles because they are a simple shape. I assumed Moby's statement was simple, but now realize that it wasn't. He was speaking in terms of radiator rows, not general principles, so it is reasonable to make certain assumptions that I overlooked. The more complicated variables involved in radiator specific applied physics (that was long) would make that statement true. I was not able to make these assumptions because of my ignorance. I can understand the interdependence of design (stacked rows and shape of those rows) and material. I'm glad I broadcast my ignorance, though. I've learned a lot more about radiators that I ever thought I would.

I'm sure the oem brass radiator or oem aluminum would be fine (though I'm partial to brass) if I ever need to replace mine, but man I really want the aluminum one from man-a-fre now. I'll need to first save the truck from frame rust. New England is not kind. Cheers!
 
Last edited:
I think most would agree the man-a-fre aluminum radiator is an upgrade from the oem. However, if you're going to stick with oem, nobody has any hard numbers on whether the brass or aluminum radiator is better. I think it comes down to personal preference and cost, oem brass < oem aluminum < man-a-fre aluminum.
 
I priced-out a custom-made alum rad at a local speed shop. They told me it would be around $900, so the MAF isn't too far out of line if you want all aluminum.
 
Quick check on Summit found some all aluminum radiators priced in-line with the Man-it-ain't-Free radiator.
 
I think most would agree the man-a-fre aluminum radiator is an upgrade from the oem. However, if you're going to stick with oem, nobody has any hard numbers on whether the brass or aluminum radiator is better. I think it comes down to personal preference and cost, oem brass < oem aluminum < man-a-fre aluminum.

Very well put, I'd add that the MAF radiator is not a necessary upgrade at all; I rarely ever wanted for more from my stock radiator even with the turbo pushing things pretty hard. So there's nothing wrong with the two OEM rads and they apparently have an admirable reserve of cooling capacity if things throughout the cooling system are all alright. I'll also add that between the two OEM's I'd personally put in the brass/copper for two reasons 1- cost and 2-easier to repair through regular trail means. It would be incredibly interesting to really do a diligent back-to-back comparison between the two but I think they're both terrific for the 80. I just wanted to emphasize that my RDR was definitely not a necessary upgrade; I just thought it was sexy! :grinpimp: and I wanted to avoid at almost all costs (few hundred dollars here apparently) leaning on that one freakin plastic bypass part even one more time. I dodged the bullet on that one countless times and sort of sacrificially took plunges to the bull bar to avoid busting that bit off :o. Now I don't worry about breaking that bit off ... I just avoid the area totally cause I wouldn't want to scratch the purty top on my radiator! Just joking. :D:D:D Anyways again very well put! :cheers:
 
Back
Top Bottom