3FE on it's way out?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Threads
103
Messages
3,952
Location
Utah
UPDATED 7/24/09- See post #30


Ok, since the first thread failed miserably, I'm just going to put it out there.

My 3FE is starting to knock. It's knocked 3 times now in the past 10,000 miles, the first time at exactly 250,000; second just 100 miles ago; and the third just 15 miles ago (yesterday).

There's a strange thing though. Each time, the knocking has been preceded by the throttle sticking. Scares the living $#!t out of me because it's sudden and unpredictable, and I can't stop the truck unless I put the tranny in N or shut off the engine.

Now to state the obvious: Putting the tranny in N with a stuck throttle isn't the best idea. Neither is shutting off the engine in the middle of traffic. The throttle is easily unstuck, though, by hitting the pedal once. Then the knocking starts. The last time only lasted about two seconds.


Now for the vital info:

Been running Valvoline 20W-50 and the big Napa Gold 1515 oil filter, changed about every 3,000 miles. It leaks oil, about a quart or so every 1500 miles. Regularly topped off. It doesn't burn oil, at least not to my knowledge. No blue smoke. Some white smoke at the first start of the morning, but it goes away once warmed up. The oil was NOT low when the knocking happened.

So... I still drive it, as it's my only vehicle. What do I do?

TIA...
-Lane
 
Last edited:
As of right now, I need to run to Provo, but I'm actually afraid to run it on the freeway.

I've seen people driving cars with knocking engines without a care in the world, but frankly this just scares me. I don't want a rod deciding to leave the engine in the middle of the Hell I call I-15...
 
So it's only done this after the throttle sticks? If so, it stands to reason that solving the sticky throttle should be your priority. You say the knocking only lasted 2 seconds the last time, how long has it lasted other times? Has the engine over-revved with each stuck throttle episode?

What exactly do you mean by knock? A mechanical clunk, or something more like ping/spark knock?
 
Serious knocking doesn't come and go. Are you sure you don't have a cylinder misfiring when the throttle sticks? Just put in a new throttle cable and see if that solves your problem (or lube your existing one).
 
Has the engine over-revved with each stuck throttle episode?

I believe it did the first time... might have just been at redline though. I can't remember too much about it...

What exactly do you mean by knock? A mechanical clunk, or something more like ping/spark knock?

Rod knock.
 
Serious knocking doesn't come and go. Are you sure you don't have a cylinder misfiring when the throttle sticks? Just put in a new throttle cable and see if that solves your problem (or lube your existing one).

It has misfired once, a few miles after the second knocking incident. Then it knocked for a second, and went away. The only time the throttle didn't stick beforehand. I just remembered about that one.

Then, a few days later, the throttle stuck going into a left-hand turn lane. Then knocked for ~two seconds. That was the third incident yesterday.
 
take State street instead of I-15? :hhmm: Good luck. Let me know if something happens and you'd want a 1FZ-FE. I have one with 30k on a rebuild sitting in a rolled 94 that I was going to transplant into a 96, but then I sold the 96.
 
State is too slow. :flipoff2:

I stole my bro's car. 1997 Kia Sephia.

There are three things I like about it: Mazda 1.8L, 5-speed, and stops faster than mine. That's it.

[/end self-hijack]
 
Last edited:
You say the knocking only lasted 2 seconds the last time, how long has it lasted other times?

First time totaled a few minutes. The throttle stuck then redlined because I put it into N (not a good idea, I know). The engine knocked for a minute then stopped. I drove it home very carefully, got into my driveway, and it began knocking again.

I remember, to the best of my recollection, popping the hood and listening to where it was coming from....back of the motor, towards the bottom. I turned it off, went inside for a little bit, then came back outside and started it up. I cannot remember if it was knocking or not during that little time period. All I remember is that it stopped knocking for another 9000+ miles.


The second incident happened in my own neighborhood. I turned left to leave my culdesac, let off the throttle, but it continued to accelerate. Scared me half to death because there are usually a lot of little children running around, and I couldn't stop properly. A quick tap on the pedal unstuck the throttle, and I was able to coast to the stop sign in N, engine idling, like I usually do (sans the pounding heart).

I hit the gas to go around the corner, and the engine started knocking like crazy! I pulled over, but it was still knocking. Popped the hood...sounded like it was coming from the same area as the first incident. So I turned it off and checked the oil. Less than a quart low. I started it back up, but it was still knocking a bit. Revved it up a bit, and the knocking got faster (duh), but quieted down. Then it stopped.


Clear as mud? heh heh...
 
I'm gonna get a Blackstone report on this oil when I change it, provided the motor doesn't puke a connecting rod or 4...

If I remember, I'll post up the results. It won't be for another 1400 miles, or it will be when I pull the oil pan to replace the bearings. Not sure yet.
 
This knock you speak of, how loud is it? Can you hear it from inside the cab?

Mine had a pretty nasty knocking sound that lasted for about 3-5 seconds upon start up after it had sat for 2 months in the middle of a nasty winter. It didn't help that the oil was cold. The engine was really struggling and idling rough. However, it went away after the oil started flowing and hasn't returned since. I'm wondering if it sounded like what yours sounds like.

Listening to the 1FZ with the hood open, I swear my motor has a slight knocking sound, almost like a really, really quiet diesel motor. I'm not sure if that's normal or the sign of something more ominous.

So is your knock pretty loud or more faint?
 
The knocking sound you're thinking of is either valves or injectors. Mine makes the same sound, but slightly louder, and has been doing it since before I can remember.

When it knocks, I can definitely hear it inside the cab. That's why I pulled over the second time it happened cause it was so loud.

I'm not sure this has to do with oil flow, to be honest. It's sporadic and unpredictable.
 
Lane,

If this was rod, wristpin knock it wouldn't come and go. Doesn't make sense to me.

Are you SURE you're not hearing exhaust banging on the frame rail or something other than internal bottom end craziness? Rock stuck in an engine mount...something you can't see.

I've heard bad bottom end knock before on a 1FZ-FE. Stomach wrenching sound. You don't "think it might be bad". You KNOW it's "game over". There is NO doubt.
 
I don't think it's bad. I know it's bad. But it's only done it a few times. Which doesn't make sense to me, either.

The knock was definitely inside the engine. Changes speed with RPMs. The exhaust is mounted solid up front, new USDS motor mount less than a year old.
 
The knock sounds kind of hollow, like rapping on a hollow door made from sturdy wood. I think... That's the best way I can describe it.
 
Been there done that. Mine knocked more often than yours though. Then, I rolled the vehicle the motor used to be in and moved it over to a different roller, mysteriously the knock went away. Haven't heard it since. Are you sure it's the motor? I was.

EDIT: I moved the trans and xfer too.
 
I don't plan to roll my truck....yet.

If it is what I think it is, what is involved in fixing it?
 
I would check your throttle body for buildup, that could be an easy fix to your throttle sticking. Secondly if your only getting "knocking" occasionally it could just be pinging caused by high temperatures. If there is a fair amount of buildup in the throttle body, there could also be some major build up in the cylinder causing a ping. Just my $.02, keep the change.
 
Could the knocking be related to timing, distributor, or as blzrfn says, carbon build-up in the cylinder from ?burning oil, or even water in the cylinder (leaky HG) ??? Just my newb $.01
 
x2 on it not being possible to be a rod knock. That doesn't come and go. I've heard enough of those and seen a few rods fly out of cars, two with me in the car.
 
Back
Top Bottom