Which option would be easier/better?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 24, 2004
Threads
96
Messages
1,599
Location
Monroe, WA
Patient: 1964 FJ40 - basically stock drivetrain except the sm420 (Extreme Bends plate adapter).

Last week I ripped the drain plug out of the transfer case on a rock. The threads got buggered and the rear portion of the boss broke off. There are no other cracks that could spread. In fact, I threaded the plug back in by hand with some teflon tape, drove it home, and it hasn't leaked all week sitting in the garage.

My options for repair:

#1 - pull case, grind the bottom smooth, and have someone weld some 1/2" Al over the bottom of the case. In theory, it would be stronger/smoother in the event of any future rock contact. It would be very nearly free. But I would have to pull the pto cover to drain it.

#2 - I now also have an extra empty 65 case. I've never gutted a tcase before, but I'm not afraid to do it (I rebuilt my sm420). I just don't know how much work or special tools are involved, if any. If I go this route, I think I would prefer to get a complete rebuild kit ($120) since it will be apart anyway. I believe the case has about 45K on a rebuild, but it seems silly not to do it while it's open. Obviously this option would require more work and money, but I'm not sure if it's worth the benefit.

#3 - If I could find one cheap, I'd love to upgrade to a newer 3speed case that's less brittle, but I haven't come across one yet and my budget is limited.

Bearing in mind that it's my daily driver (at least as long as it's too wet & cold to ride my bike), what would you do?

Eric
 
#3 Drill and retap the drain hole or get lucky and find the right size Heli-coil.
If you like the #1 option for strength do that with aluminum thick enough to do #3.
It would be stronger AND you could still drain it easily.
 
Ige, let me know when you're finished with it and how much $$ shipped to 98272. Given the options, I think I'd prefer to upgrade the case if I'm doing all the work anyway.


Quazii - I don't think you really understand how much material is missing :D In order to make a smooth mating surface for the plug, I would only have the thickness of the case (3/16"?) to thread into. If I do end up plating the whole thing, I will certainly consider tapping for a drain plug - that's just not the primary concern at this point.
 
I think you should just keep a close eye on it for a while, JB Weld it if you want to be sure and then go with a newer case or rebuild your spare. If it is working now then just wait until you have the resources to do something better.

I would imagine a shop charging you at least $100 dollars for the weld job, you may get it done for half of that depending on how generous the welder is. Then at best you still have a patch job and a brittle case, limp by and replace with a better case.

Good luck.
 
Well, I'm not driving it the way it is. There is very little metal holding the drain plug in there and I'd have no way of knowing if it lets go. Except for the sound of seizing bearings.

I know a couple people that could do the welding for me, so the cost there would be minimal, but the more I think about it, this is a good time to bite the bullet and invest a little bit in longevity and strength.
 
Look into weld in bungs. Race car shops? Not totally sure where to find em. Oh ya, what ever you do, build or buy a skid plate!!!! ;)
 
That's why I said JB Weld :D

I patched the crankcase of a Honda XR250 with JB Weld and rocks and rode it home...added more oil and rode it all summer until I found another case.

Just put your bike in back if you are worried :D
 
Well I don't know but it sounds to me like you need a lift,for going over speed bumps.I would JB weld it Erik and get the rest of the parts you need.I JB welded a car block on a chevy beteween freeze plugs where it cracked it lasted a couple years then I sold it and it was still fine..
 
wayne_fj40 said:
Well I don't know but it sounds to me like you need a lift,for going over speed bumps.I would JB weld it Erik and get the rest of the parts you need.I JB welded a car block on a chevy beteween freeze plugs where it cracked it lasted a couple years then I sold it and it was still fine..

Hey! :flipoff2: As I recall, one of us went up those rocks. It wasn't you. Even though you've got about 6" more clearance than I do.

My replacement case came on Saturday. I ordered the rebuild kit today. I'll have it done just in time for the new :princess: to arrive next week. :doh: No wheeling for me for a while.
 
Back
Top Bottom