wheel nut key breakage

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 2, 2006
Threads
5
Messages
13
i was at the tire store yesterday for my rotation / balance service. the tech immediately broke my wheel nut key (put it in the impact wrench and and pulled out a shiny metal shell). the lock part is still on my wheel nut, seems pretty secure, but i don't think that's a good thing...
needless to say i'm pretty skeptical of his story that mine was "cracked already". and more leaning towards "you set the torque up way too high."
just wondering what the word is on those things. do they indeed "break all the time" as the shop manager who i spoke with seemed to indicate? or do they owe me a new one?
tia!
 
I broke three before I said hell with it and stopped using them. I hated ruining a perfectly good socket to try and take off the lock each time.
 
B******s at Discount broke mine too, then cut the rest off and sent me off with only 5 lugs/wheel. I was pissed, but ended up buying another set on my dime. I kinda regret it, and will probably just lose them altogether at some point.
 
Same exact thing just happened to me, but i broke the key (using impact...) Sent off for replacement key via mail, hope the heck that the original manuafacturer of these keys is still in business ( i just used card with their info provided in owners manual). Not sure if they are worth the hassle...kind of depends on weather or not they prevent a theft i guess :grinpimp:
 
Discount broke one of mine also. Told me they never use the impact for locks. When I walked out to my truck to fetch the spare the kid picking the broken pieces from the lug said he put it in the impact and "it just broke."

Get rid of all of them. If a thief wants your wheels that lug will not stop them. But it will stop you.
 
i was at the tire store yesterday for my rotation / balance service. the tech immediately broke my wheel nut key (put it in the impact wrench and and pulled out a shiny metal shell). the lock part is still on my wheel nut, seems pretty secure, but i don't think that's a good thing...
needless to say i'm pretty skeptical of his story that mine was "cracked already". and more leaning towards "you set the torque up way too high."
just wondering what the word is on those things. do they indeed "break all the time" as the shop manager who i spoke with seemed to indicate? or do they owe me a new one?
tia!
Howdy! Based on my son's 5 years at Discount, yes any wheel nut lock can break. The better style, like Gorilla brand that fits over the outside of the wheel nut will usually hold up to air/impact. The endcap style will usually fail with air/impact. Just tell the tire store that you bought the locks from them!! When David worked at Discount, the rule was NO IMPACT GUNS on wheel locks. Period. Run it on by hand and set the torque with a regular lever style torque wrench when doing the rest of the nuts. So far, my Gorillas have lasted over 15 years. John
 
Mine came with a set of those locking lugs, and they broke using a hand wrench. Its a PITA to get the sheared nut off once the keyed section shears off. Those things are junk, if you have them I suggest you get rid of them now. Totally useless on the trail - pretty useless for a mall cruiser too. How many people are stealing old 80 wheels anyway?
 
Mine came with a set of those locking lugs, and they broke using a hand wrench. Its a PITA to get the sheared nut off once the keyed section shears off. Those things are junk, if you have them I suggest you get rid of them now. Totally useless on the trail - pretty useless for a mall cruiser too. How many people are stealing old 80 wheels anyway?

Just for the record - My new 33x12.5 M/Ts were swiped from my 4Runner, wheels and all. Considering how a set of good quality mud tires is easily $1000 they're going to be targeted by thieves. I now use wheel locks, but I have two sets of keys for them.
 
So wait;

Is the locking lug nut still on your rim??

Seems like that's what we really need to be addressing. (Not hard to deal with...)

Curtis

yeah, it still is. since it was the first nut he did, and it broke immediately i figure the nuts are still on as tight as they were when put on (probably at much higher torque than need be as well. sorry, guess i'm still venting.)
so you bring up a good point. i didn't ask, and i did already see something of a suggestion of how to deal with the broken off key; does anyone have other suggestions on how to remove said key?

thanks for all the replies. sometimes when things go wrong i wonder if it's my fault. good to know this is one of those rare times when i'm not to blame.... well, other than trusting a stranger's hands on my rig!
 
Hammer on a socket. You'll ruin the socket, but it's about the only way.
 
(you should have seen all the suggestions when this came up in Chat once :lol:)

Well I guess a plasma torch would do it. :lol:
 
Well I guess a plasma torch would do it. :lol:
Howdy! I have welded a 15/16" nut onto the end of the busted locknut, right thru the middle of the nut. Then just spin it off with a 4-way. John
 
Dealership removes them for $10 around here... in your case, I would ask the shop that broke it on install at least do you the favor of removing the useless nut! 80 lugnuts are not cheap.

IRONYUPPY - man that sucks! (stolen wheels/tires). Sorry to hear, I guess all things are possible.
 
To those of you that had tires stolen off your rig:

Where was it parked and was it for an extended period of time?



I bought 4 new lug nuts from Dan so I wouldn't have to deal with busted/non-removable locknuts when changing a flat tire on desolate stretches of interstates and trails, but I suppose I would have bigger problems if I had all 5 tires jacked by a meth addict.
 
I had three of mine brake...one of them was spinning with the wheel spacer lug. They had to torch that one off and replace the spacer stud. I would not use them EVER again!! Also they do not have the depth of normal toyota lugs and with stretch the threads as they bottom out on the lugs (this is a bigger problem with wheel spacers) but can be a problem on all studs. I can't even imagine if this happened on a trail when you had a side wall cut and had no way to get the remaining caller of metal off the stud.

edit...btw my wheel locks were from a dealer (don't know if they were form Cdan or local)
 
To those of you that had tires stolen off your rig:

Where was it parked and was it for an extended period of time?



I bought 4 new lug nuts from Dan so I wouldn't have to deal with busted/non-removable locknuts when changing a flat tire on desolate stretches of interstates and trails, but I suppose I would have bigger problems if I had all 5 tires jacked by a meth addict.

Well, mine was in my parking garage (condo tower). It was behing TWO security gates. Where there's a will there's a way. I figure it was one of the neighbours in the same building :mad:
 
Back
Top Bottom