I've got a buddy that its going to build a bumper for me out of 2x4 channel. I was thinking of making it out of 3/16" but he said that I should consider 1/8" because that is what the frame is made from. I said that places like CCOT use 3/16 in their bumpers. He came back with what do you want to bend first your frame or your bumber? He said that bumper manufacturers will use thicker materal to cut down on having to warranty their stuff. Does anyone care to share their opinion on what I should use?
I used 3/16" 2x3 and incorporated it into my frame, to some point making my frame stronger but yet if there was a hard enough hit (which would have to be very hard) my frame would bend. there was a very good thread awhile back comparing bolting to welding a bumper on and had tons of insight that would answer your question.
Thanks for the input. I will probably have him use the 316" as I would like to have it set up with a winch. I will probably use a BudBuilt mount for it. If I hit something hard enough then the frame will bend anyway. Its not going to be a really wide bumper anyway. And the rear crossmember is part of the frame anyway.
I would use 1/8 material for most of the bumper and maybe 3/16 material for the winch mount parts. You can gain strength by design rather than heavier material. As someone has already meantioned the frame material is largely 3/16 with gussets to add strenth where needed. Just spend a little time thinking about what you want the bumper to do and then pick the appropriate material.
If is too ridgid and you hit something at speed you will have the damage multiply effect. This could do serious damage to parts that you don't want to hurt. Most cars and trucks have crumple zones for good reason. they are designed to absorb some of the shock and disappiate the energy. At slow speeds the forces are not so great so the thicker material will say straight longer but can cause problems with sheared rivets etc. TLC's (40's)are built with rivets and some welding for good reason. Besides the asthetics will look better with the "right size" material.
Most of the failures you will see will be caused by poor design and poor welding rather than inadequte material sizes as long as you stick with what the truck is originally built with.
I built a custom, heavy gauge front bumper after getting tired of having to repeatly "un-bend" the passenger's side corner of the stock front bumper on my FJ40.
I used a piece of 2X6X0.25 inch "C" channel to construct a simple "bobbed" (short) front bumper. The 2X6 inch "C" channel works well with the factory triangular bumper mounting plates, which appear to be designed to bend in case of severe impact.
I have actually been able to damage this 1/4 inch thick front bumper; I hit the driver's corner on a boulder and bent it back a slight amount!
The original bumper was not designed to do much of anything. It'll bend from an impact that you won't even notice inside the rig. And it is not meant for a winch to be mounted to either.
The frame is a lot closer to 3/16 than 1/8. And it is boxed w/crossmembers.
The arguement of building your bumper to fail in an impact so that the frame will not be stressed just doesn't hold water IMHO. I've never seen a situation where a strong bumper has damaged a frame. I've seen a bunch of '40s and a bunch of then that have been trashed in wrecks/collisio.
Your bumper is used for purposes besides "crumble space". A '40 is not designed with crumple space anyway.
If the question was about building a complex shape for a bumper like you see in the late model ARB bumpers, then 1/8 could be considered easily. But the question was about a simple channel (square tube?) bumper.
In that setuop, 1/8 will bend the first time you press it up against a rock or a ditch bank.
I can remember standing at the very first obstacle on the Rubicon and watching 4 rigs in a row trash their Smittybilt 1/8 inch wall section tube bumpers. No impact, just pressing against and dragging over the rocks.
mmmm thats a pretty nice bumper. i think 1/8 is to thin for anything thats gunna see trails, on my stocker (see avatar) iv gotten sick of having to go out and beat my bumper pack into shape with the axe.....i would go with 3/16 or maybe 1/4, i think 1/4 would be pretty bullet proof and yes i read about the guy bending his 1/4 bumper in this thread but....if it happens dig out the BFH and bend it back if it bothers you
I have had several bumpers that I built from 3/16" - 1/4" material. I actually had someone rearend me at slower speeds with any damage at all. The one thing to consider is that if a frame is hit from head on, this is its strongest point. Something like the old trick of being able to stand on an empty beer can. Whereas, the side impact to a frame will cause greater damage. Thus the need for crossmembers. Most of these rigs are moving at slower speeds on the trails anyway. I say bigger is better.
To take care of the metal thickness argument, just make crumple brackets Connecting the bumper to the frame. Simple design, stout for a winch pull but would crush if impacted hard enough. In basic shapes, metal is always stronger in tension than compression.
Build as many as needed. Replace as often as necessary.