Urban carnage

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 19, 2003
Threads
53
Messages
691
Driving down the road on Wednesday. Big bang under the hood
and lots of noise. Pull over and the fan blade is cracked and
partially missing, the water pump is broken and coolant is going
everywhere. Fan shroud has a nasty gash.

I'm running again but want to know what went wrong. Two
theories:

1. Fan was cracked. The crack spread and allowed one of the
blades to fly off, hitting the shroud, which kicked the fan back
and broke the water pump. If you look closely at the fan, you
can see that part of the blade has a crack which is bright and
shiny (thus new) and part of the crack is old and rusty (which
means it has been there for a while).

2. Motor mounts are broken. I still have the old round motor
mounts and they don't look that great. The broken motor mount
allowed the engine to move far enough in the engine bay so
that the fan hit the shroud and then the whole thing fell apart.
Note that I cannot see the engine move one bit in the engine
bay when I rev it, but this is not under a full load.

So. I'd like to know what happened so that I can prevent
this from happening again.
 
Last edited:
Looks like a simple case of metal fatigue. I got a plastic fan lots of give. If your mounts were that loose you would have a noticible shutter in the clutch when starting from a stant still.
 
Maybe you kicked something up in the motor. Thats what happened to mine and it tooks chunks from blade
 
When my blade hit my shroud it ended up being because of a bad mount, took me a couple times to figure it out. Like you said, it moved up and hit it. But it only happened when it was under serious load and I doubt it would have ever done that on hiway driving.

Bad old fan is my guess.
 
Seen it before. Covered it in the "Trails" recently. ;)

In that case, the broken blade from the fan punched through and lodged in the hood.

Metal fatigue weakened your fan blade until it snapped. The vibrations of the extremely unbalanced fan ripped the pump apart.


Mark...
 
I had this same thing happen to me while I was going down I-5 at about 65MPH. It definetly gets your attention real fast! It did a number on my hood too. That was when I had a SB 283 and the fan on it looked the same as the one in your picture. Same situation with metal fatigue
 
You're saying that that dark area where the fan blade separated is an old crack?

Don't you think that you should have seen this coming? Felt a vibration or at least spotted something wrong when checking your oil or something? It looks like that blade was over 2/3 gone before this happened.
 
honk said:
You're saying that that dark area where the fan blade separated is an old crack?

Don't you think that you should have seen this coming? Felt a vibration or at least spotted something wrong when checking your oil or something? It looks like that blade was over 2/3 gone before this happened.


I've seen three of then fail this way. No real warning detectable by the driver. Few people inspect every inch of their motor for cracks or other unspecified and unexpected defects everytime they are under the hood doing routine maintenance. It doesn't create any vibration until after the blade seperates. Then the rest of the danage occurs before the engine can be brought to a stop. The blade doesn't separate at idle speeds, but at much higher engine rpm (running down the highway in the caseof the rigs I have dealt with).


Mark...


Mark...
 
Hey Honk. I think Mark's right. It would be hard to know there was a
crack in the fan without having it magnafluxed (and how many people
would do that!). Metal fatigue and crack growth is typically quite
non-linear and a crack goes from being tiny to being major in little
or no time. I will take off the used blade set I purchased and look
at it very closely but it sure looked good when I got it.

I may take exception with one practice that I used to follow: using
the fan to turn the engine when I am adjusting the valves. This
may cause some bending of the blades right where they cantilever
off of the blade hub.

I am probably lucky as the motor was only spinning at about 2000 r.p.m.
when the fan went. Never found one of the blades.
 
Had this happen in the 40 myself


Burl
 
No need for magnaflux to find cracks in the fans. A simple visual inspection will show the cracks. Look around the bolt holes and where the two blades overlap. It's usually pretty obvious. Look for rust streaking too...

Nick
 
Last edited:
Nick is spot on.




I had a water pump shaft fail on me out in the Hills in 2000. Shaft broke and sent the fan into the radiator and lodged it in the bottom tank, destroying the radiator...there was no warning at all.




1996 Dodge W3500 Cummins....Heading home from a weekend up north...rolling into Hibbing and heard a loud THUD, and then could smell coolant....pulled over and found a fan blade had broke and went into the radiator....parked the truck/camper and trailer at the dealership, unloaded the Red truck and set out on the 250+ mile trip home.


Things break, chit happens.


Good luck!


-Steve
 
When this happened to me, oh, say 6 months ago, we could see on the fractured edges where the preexisting crack was (rusted) and the final snap (fresh metal). Punched my radiator and dented the hood.
 
Anybody want a real nice Cuisinart metal 4-blade? Sheesh.



I only have one word for you, son...................................plastics;)



I have seen the pic of the one with the fan blade through the hood, gives me the heebie jeebies.



Ed
 
rgentry said:
can I just keep my eyes open for fledgling cracks?

This is my plan. Hope it works out. :eek:
 
rgentry said:
How do you retro a plastic fan to an FJ? On the other hand,
now that I know that this is a trouble spot, can I just keep
my eyes open for fledgling cracks?

I've spotted a couple of these in the past by wiping them down with mineral spirits, then watching for "wet lines" as they dry - kind of hard to explain, but once you see one, you'll know.

Idea is, the crack (and the rust therein) will wick up the liquid, and then release it back to the surface as it evaporates. Non cracked areas have no "reserve" of liquid, and will not stay wet after the liquid evaporates. I use this trick on frames, rims, etc. Don't use gasoline! Mineral spirits, only!

I stumbled across this when cleaning up a Chevy I-6 back in 1978. Today, those cruisers we know and love are as old (or older) than my 1955 1/2 ton 3200 pickup was, back then.

Truck had *HIPS*, man. ;) I miss her.

Kirk
 
rgentry said:
How do you retro a plastic fan to an FJ? On the other hand,
now that I know that this is a trouble spot, can I just keep
my eyes open for fledgling cracks?

The Six bladed nylon fan will bolt right up where the metal one went, but you must use a spacer to move it out of the way of the fanbelts. That's the way the factory did it.


Ed
 
Russell,

I had the same thing happen on my 40 about 10 years ago. I was EXTREMELY fortunate that my blade tore the bottom of the shroud and splashpan and went straight out the bottom. As soon as I got home, I changed the blades on every rig I own to the plastic ones, even the resto 45swb.

Like Degnol said, you need an aluminum spacer between the plastic fan and the water pump to keep the wider plastic blades from hitting the alt pulley. Toyota has discontinued the spacer, so I had a batch of them reproduced.:cool:

As far as the motor mount being cracked, the fronts generally don't crack until the rears have been run loose for a while, so you'd better check the back ones real close as well.;)

Mark
 
Back
Top Bottom