Uneven Brakes

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 16, 2014
Threads
51
Messages
772
Location
Union, Ky
I have a 93 with disks in the back and I have been experiencing significantly more wear on the pads of my P/S rear pads than my D/S. It seemed to be gradually getting worse over the past two years, so over the summer I put new rotors and reman calipers on both sides in the back, and the same thing is still happening, except even worse. It also seems to be wearing more on the outside of the P/S rotor as well. Any help is appreciated, the guys at O'riellys were perplexed.
 
To @mudgudgeon's point, while that's certainly not beyond the realm of possibility, the output line to the rear brakes form the LSBPV is a single point, so it should affect both sides equally. The inside/outside uneven wear on the PS brake leads me to believe there's a problem with the sliding action. The way the system is designed, when the piston extends (outward from the caliper towards the outside of the truck) to push the inner pad onto the rotor, the torque plate is supposed to slide inward (towards the truck centerline), so that the outer pad contacts the rotor.

upload_2017-10-24_8-26-18.webp


If the outer pad drags on the rotor, it'll wear unevenly. You may or may not hear it. I've replaced pads that squeal when new, until they're done, and I've replaced some that don't make a sound, even when they're chewing the rotor. I have yet to figure that out.

Even a rebuilt caliper can fail to operate properly. The rebuilding process only pertains to cleaning and replacing wear parts, such as the piston and seals. They're not functionally checked to determine if they will clamp the rotor evenly. There's really no way to do this, without installing them and the failure rate for this problem is really low.

Here are my thoughts about your problem and its solution:
1. Do flush your brake system, until it runs clear. Pay particular attention to the flow rate, between the PS and DS rear bleeders.
- this should help to ensure that both sides of the brake system are getting the same flow rate and pressure.
- if visual inspection does not confirm that both sides have equal flow, the root cause is most likely blocked lines, from the LSBPV to the caliper. I would recommend replacing both lines, to ensure a balanced system. This isn't absolutely necessary, because these systems have excess capacity and will function reliably even if the flow rates are not optimum. my 2¢

2. Measure (and photograph) your rotor. You need a fairly accurate measure of the thickness, on both sides of the internal vent cavity. You'll need a set of dial calipers, unless you're willing to sacrifice the rotor and grind it down during operation to the point that the wear pattern (inside to outside) is clearly visible. This method will work, it's just expensive. The dial calipers (or verniers, if you hate yourself) will be useful for many other things (they don't have to be expensive, just reliable). You need another tool anyway.

3. Install new pads. You must do this to ensure that you can determine whether your remedial actions have resolved the problem. Measure (and photograph) them during the inspection process. Ensure that you have NEW sliding pins and that they are greased. (You're trying to remove all the possible failure modes from the root cause tree)

4. Pull the PS rear wheel and perform a function check on the brake caliper. This will require a helper to depress the brake pedal. Visually confirm that both sides move and that they move equally and simultaneously.
- if the visual inspection, after the flush, indicates that the caliper function is OK, put a couple of miles on the truck, with heavy braking and inspect again.
- if the visual inspection indicates the inside/outside sliding action is unequal, you have two options.
a. Replace the caliper again. This may or may not solve the problem; you won't know what the problem was because you didn't identify it.
b. Continue to operate the brake and visually inspect the operation until the root cause is determined. This would be my choice, if the problem was mine. Until you identify the problem, you won't be able to solve it, and know what you did.

HTH
 
The inside/outside uneven wear on the PS brake leads me to believe there's a problem with the sliding action. The way the system is designed, when the piston extends (outward from the caliper towards the outside of the truck) to push the inner pad onto the rotor, the torque plate is supposed to slide inward (towards the truck centerline), so that the outer pad contacts the rotor.

If the outer pad drags on the rotor, it'll wear unevenly. You may or may not hear it. I've replaced pads that squeal when new, until they're done, and I've replaced some that don't make a sound, even when they're chewing the rotor. I have yet to figure that out.
...

Kinda, the the torque plate is bolted to the axle, cant move. The caliper should float, center on the rotor, making even clamp on both pads. Uneven pad wear is almost always bind in the sliding pins and/or bushings.
 
Kinda, the the torque plate is bolted to the axle, cant move. The caliper should float, center on the rotor, making even clamp on both pads. Uneven pad wear is almost always bind in the sliding pins and/or bushings.
You're right, I had the front brake stuck in my mind.
 
i have had a similar situation on my truck. I have yet to resolve it.

96LC with 212K at the time.

Front and rear axle rebuilds with all bearings, seals, etc. on the wheels (not differentials)
Installed all new Powerstop drilled rotors on F/R as Powerstop brake pads (100's in the front)
Installed NAPA Gold Reman calipers on all four corners.
Bled all brake lines until was clear and bubble-free using two-man method.
Bled RR, LR, LSPV, RF, LF, then all again.
Parking brake pads replaced and all mechanisms cleaned and lubed for reliable working operation.
ABS has been disabled due to not installing reluctor rings on the front axles when I installed them. Will reinstall at next full front axle service.

RR pads chewed off in under 5000 miles. Replaced with a like set. Gone in another 5000 miles.
Installed the worn original pads (ceramic?) in both sides that were on the truck when I bought it. Still on there 30K miles later.

Most days the brakes work fine. When in a panic brake, the RR grabs before the LR, but then they even out. So, I get a quick, hard jerk to the right under hard heavy braking, then it evens out.

I have checked all lines for dents, smashed points, kinks, and have found none.

All brake hoses are new (45K miles ago at the change-over) of the Slee SS hoses.

The truck has done this for the last 45K miles and I'm not sure what it is. It's irritating to me, particularly on wet days or if traffic stops suddenly. It is my DD and I am primarily a mall crawler, so it's not like I have a lot of rocks and dirt in there. I am in Kansas City, so the rust belt can be a factor, but it's not at this time.

I'm now at 256K (I think) and it still does it, but I have learned to compensate.

I see my "brake" light is on this week, so my fluid is now starting to run low, indicating my pad wear has probably reached critical mass again, so I need to be looking into this a bit more.

I'm open to suggestions as well.
 
I will work on getting some pics soon, I'm pretty busy with school however. I forgot to mention that similar to bilt4me, the truck will tug to the right initially then be straight when braking.
 
I work in this field so I can comment here. One thing that often contributes to accelerated brake wear is exogenous differences in the environments each side lives in. For example, most people consider that a warped brake rotor on one side will rub against the pads and knock them back more than the other side, leading to accelerated wear.... but one thing that often doesn't get considered is how the resonant frequency of the caliper piston and the exhaust note at certain RPMs interact. Ordinarily there are no harmonic imbalances in the mighty Toyota I6 designs (3F or 1FZ, doesn't matter) but when you're starting to exhibit imbalanced compression and misfires, that resonance gets all screwy and it ends up cavitating the brake fluid in the caliper. The cavitated fluid, with entrained air, takes up a larger volume and ends up pushing some fluid back up the line, but often will end up pushing the path of least resistance - the caliper piston itself - into light contact with the rotor and wearing down the pad quite a bit faster.

The fact that you're seeing this happen on the rear passenger side, right where the exhaust note is loudest, is pretty telling. I'd make sure your head gasket isn't on its last legs or already blown.
 
That's amazing insight!
I would not have been able to put that together, but with your clear a d rational explanations, I get it!
 
I work in this field so I can comment here. One thing that often contributes to accelerated brake wear is exogenous differences in the environments each side lives in. For example, most people consider that a warped brake rotor on one side will rub against the pads and knock them back more than the other side, leading to accelerated wear.... but one thing that often doesn't get considered is how the resonant frequency of the caliper piston and the exhaust note at certain RPMs interact. Ordinarily there are no harmonic imbalances in the mighty Toyota I6 designs (3F or 1FZ, doesn't matter) but when you're starting to exhibit imbalanced compression and misfires, that resonance gets all screwy and it ends up cavitating the brake fluid in the caliper. The cavitated fluid, with entrained air, takes up a larger volume and ends up pushing some fluid back up the line, but often will end up pushing the path of least resistance - the caliper piston itself - into light contact with the rotor and wearing down the pad quite a bit faster.

The fact that you're seeing this happen on the rear passenger side, right where the exhaust note is loudest, is pretty telling. I'd make sure your head gasket isn't on its last legs or already blown.


With this being a distinct possibility, I DO need a new stereo in the truck in order to offset the exogent harmonics. And, come to think of it, I WAS listening to Country Music every time I needed to brake in that manner and it would pull to the right.

I think you're onto something here.

I'm not so sure on the head gasket, as mine was replaced by the PO 107K miles ago.

Now, if I look up the sonic frequency of a 33" tire at 70 MPH, it MAY interfere with the wavelength of the drilled holes or the slots in the rotor of the RR. It's possible that the lack of frequency on the LR may be causing air to lift the pads, causing excessive clearance and a millisecond delay in the brake application, but the RR is being hindered due to the angle of projection of the pressure wave induced by the sonic generator.

I am going to have to install the new Sonic Wave Cancellation Generator from Bose in order to get my brakes working properly again.
Noise and Vibration Testing and Analysis solves problems

Man, am I glad to be a part of this Forum?!?! Where else could I get such expert advice to allow me to work through my problems?

Now, If I could only get financial advice or legal counsel for for my marriage from a forum like this!
 
You can get it, but would you want it?
 
... but one thing that often doesn't get considered is how the resonant frequency of the caliper piston and the exhaust note at certain RPMs interact. ... I'd make sure your head gasket isn't on its last legs or already blown.

This makes solid Mud sense. The resonant frequency is often manifested as an acceleration whistle, most of the rigs we have seen with a blown head gasket, also have an acceleration exaust whistle. There is the connection, undeniable Mud proof! :hillbilly:
 
MINE WHISTLES! OH NO!
 
Back
Top Bottom