Transmission Choices

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 16, 2006
Threads
13
Messages
102
Location
Salt Lake City, Utah
The dealership says I need a new transmission. I will be taking it to get a second opinion but I thought I would tap into the knowledge on this forum. This is what happens:
When reversing (most pronounced reversing up a hill) the transmission causes a shuddering sensation to go through the vehicle. Let off the gas then re-apply gas (even gas it hard) and it will reverse fine (also seems to reverse fine in 4 low). It should be noted that I allow 1.5 - 3 seconds to go by before applying gas in reverse (slow tranny and all) and am not giving it much gas.
Also once on the highway I went over an overpass and as I came down off it, you know how you get that little air to where your suspension drops, I heard something go zzzzzz. Thoughts?
They gave me a bid of:
New transission installed $5200
Rebuilt transmission installed $3400

I just found a used tranny on Cruiserparts for $750.

1 - What is the forum's opinion on the symptom? Do I actually need a new transmission?
2 - Which would you go with? New, rebuilt, or used?

Thanks for your opinions.
 
Like this?
scan.webp
scan0001.webp
 
From the pics you provided/introduction it said a chatter when shifting from reverse into neutral or park. I don't have that. When I got it I thought it was the infamous slow tranny and followed the prescribed "wait a second or two before giving it gas". It seems to be more than that, to where I am reluctant to park anywhere I have to reverse out at an incline. Needless to say it makes off-roading a little nerve racking. It is a shuddering and the car will move a bit but slippage is evident. But as I said before I will let off the gas and then give it gas again and it seems to reverse fine (even under "aggressive" gas). I am just making sure the dealership isn't making an easy buck - and that if indeed there is a problem a new tranny is the solution.
 
Or are you saying that since I am going FROM park or neutral into reverse that this could be the problem?
 
Chatter and shudder are interchangeable descriptions.
 
So does my description, in your opinion, relate to the chatter described in the pages? Or does the sequence of events rule that out? I know it is hard to troubleshoot without checking it personally but any guidance you can provide is very appreciated.
 
The bulletin may, or may not, provide a solution to your issue. Your transmission may be past the point where the repair described will take care of the issue. You will need to get with your dealer and discuss the options. I would most likely opt for a factory reman transmission if I were in your shoes.
 
The dealership says I need a new transmission. I will be taking it to get a second opinion but I thought I would tap into the knowledge on this forum. This is what happens:
When reversing (most pronounced reversing up a hill) the transmission causes a shuddering sensation to go through the vehicle. Let off the gas then re-apply gas (even gas it hard) and it will reverse fine (also seems to reverse fine in 4 low). It should be noted that I allow 1.5 - 3 seconds to go by before applying gas in reverse (slow tranny and all) and am not giving it much gas.
Also once on the highway I went over an overpass and as I came down off it, you know how you get that little air to where your suspension drops, I heard something go zzzzzz. Thoughts?
They gave me a bid of:
New transission installed $5200
Rebuilt transmission installed $3400

I just found a used tranny on Cruiserparts for $750.

1 - What is the forum's opinion on the symptom? Do I actually need a new transmission?
2 - Which would you go with? New, rebuilt, or used?

Thanks for your opinions.

The first thing I would do is completely flush the tranny.

I had the exact same phenomenon; shudder in reverse only.

This occurred shortly after I had added something called "Shudderfix";
I did not have shudder before, but I was looking for a crisper shift,
and thought that this might give me that; NOPE.
(these are some of the important lessons in life we all have to
learn at one time or another; like not touching a hot stove,etc)

I was traveling out of state; so I stopped at the nearest quick lube
shop, had them drain a few quarts out, and top it off with fresh
ATF. That fixed it for the moment.

The first chance I got, I had my tranny completely flushed;
no more shudder in reverse.

If you have added any additives and/or you are the 2nd,3rd,4th owner and do not know what the previous people added to the tranny or what type ATF has been used, I would definitely do a complete flush.

There is one product I mentioned previously; called LUBEGARD tranny
cleaner/preflush (NAPA can order it if you ask them nicely) I did use two bottles of that prior to doing a complete flush with 16 quarts Mobil 1 Synthetic Dexron ATF.(a bit extra to actually clean it, not just replace what was in there).

Good luck
 
From the pics you provided/introduction it said a chatter when shifting from reverse into neutral or park. I don't have that. When I got it I thought it was the infamous slow tranny and followed the prescribed "wait a second or two before giving it gas". It seems to be more than that, to where I am reluctant to park anywhere I have to reverse out at an incline. Needless to say it makes off-roading a little nerve racking. It is a shuddering and the car will move a bit but slippage is evident. But as I said before I will let off the gas and then give it gas again and it seems to reverse fine (even under "aggressive" gas). I am just making sure the dealership isn't making an easy buck - and that if indeed there is a problem a new tranny is the solution.

Dealerships survive off making a quick buck; always get a second, third and forth opinion, like coming to this forum.

Flush your tranny and put a high quality Dexron II/III ATF, not a multivehicle type ATF.

g
 
Thanks for the input Gray. I think I will try the flush and quality fluids approach. Can't hurt as it is, what, 1/30th the cost of the rebuilt tranny? Thanks again.
 
Back
Top Bottom