Mark-
It was designed with the intent of allowing newer, less experienced members get a feel for who offers what type of service and any extra stuff that they may offer. Yes, it may piss off some vendors. No, if you've been around for long it may not tell you much, but may also help with who to call if you happen to be someplace other that your particular stomping grounds.
If it pisses some vendors off, then so be it. If we don't try something to offer member benefits, then we lose more than we would have gained by trying to keep everybody happy. The reward outweighs the risk in that regard, in my opinion.
If we try and it fails, or is lackluster, or if nobody sees any value in it, then we can easily discontinue the program, and it costs us nothing.
However, if we don't try anything at all, the cost is beyond measure.
Now, if you are dissatisfied with the program, please pm, or call me, and let me know what you see as shortcomings, or what you see that can be improved about the program, and I will try to balance that against the overall goal of the program. I can't fix issues with my work, if you don't tell me what they are. I would love to hear what needs fixing, so that it can be tweaked, This is only the initial offering of the program, and is completely adaptable. Help me fix it, so the benefit is stronger for all!
And for the record, the program was worked out with a member of the club, and when we felt it was reasonably well put together, I brought it to the board. it is by no means solely my baby, but it is adaptable, and changeable to fit our needs as best as possible.