Tire Size Dilema

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 8, 2024
Threads
5
Messages
69
Location
Phoenix Area, Arizona
Hey folks,

Wanted to get some ideas for my next tire size as I've been considering all different sizes but haven't been able to make a solid decision.

Im looking for slightly bigger tires but dont want to kill daily driving manners or have to do anything crazy with making them fit.

Just for context, I have Standard Load 265/70r17 Cooper ATs, on 17x9, 0ET wheels.

Tires I've been considering:
-255/70/r17: cons-would need to get different rim set (9" is too wide for 255), reports of feeling squirrely on road with crosswinds/maneuvers, Pros- slightly larger, fits in spare tire location, available in load range C
-255/80r17s: cons-would need to get different rim set, reports of feeling squirrely on road with crosswinds/maneuvers, doesnt fit in spare tire location, only E load range
Pros- larger tire, looks great and performs great (pizza cutter)
-275/70r17: cons-mostly available in E load range, heavier than 255's
Pros-fits in spare tire location (maybe?), larger tire,
-285/70r17:cons-heavier than 255s, reduces road mannerisms, need external spare tire carrier
Pros- larger tire, available in load range C
-34×10.5r17 (toyot at3):cons-heavier than 255's, need external spare tire carrier
Pros- largest tire, looks great, not much heavier than 275/285 option

Questions i have:
-Will the 34x10.5r17 Toyo AT3s require bump stops extensions? Will it rub pinch weld with 0 offset?
-Is a 255/80r17 really all that rough riding (load range E) and squirrely on freeway as reports say? Mix reviews on this make it difficult to know.

Looks like all options have some sort of compromise. Part of me wants to keep it simple and go with 255/70r17s but if im getting different tires then I would also like the most tire I can get, like 255/80r17s or 34x10.5r17s.
 
Is your GX stock height or lifted?

As for "feeling squirrely" with 255/80/17, I can assure you that's not the case. I've had 285/70/17, 34x10.5R17, and 255/80/17 on the GX. As long as you drive it like a sane person and aren't comparing the cornering and handling characteristics at 9/10ths, you'll be fine.
 
Is your GX stock height or lifted?

As for "feeling squirrely" with 255/80/17, I can assure you that's not the case. I've had 285/70/17, 34x10.5R17, and 255/80/17 on the GX. As long as you drive it like a sane person and aren't comparing the cornering and handling characteristics at 9/10ths, you'll be fine.
Ive got an icon lift, so im about 2inches lifted up front and 3 in rear, stock bump stops.

Would you recommend 34x10.5r17s or 255/80r17s? I would want the one thats more on-road complaint as I anticipate they'd both perform well offroad.
For 34x10.5r17s, im considering the Toyo AT3s
For 255/80r17s, im considering either Toyot AT3s or Nitto Ridge grappler
 
Both sizes are good, wouldn't have a strong preference one way or another. The 34s will be marginally taller, if that's what you're going for. I love the Toyo A/T IIIs and everyone I've recommended them to that has bought them has loved them as well.
Gotcha. Did you have to extend bump stops for the 34x10.5s? Front or rear?
 
So you still have the JW Carrier? I recall reading you had some issues with it. Do you recommend any specific tire carrier?
I have never had issues with the JW spare tire carrier other than a few inconsequential nuts/bolts rusted which they sent me replacements for at N/C. Very minimal as far as a modification goes... though the door definitely does squeak dramatically when I close it, but that's to be expected with ~90 pounds hanging off the back where it was never meant to. Structurally totally sound though.
 
You've posted a lot of tire sizes but no manufacturer's or whether they were A/T's, M/T's or ??
The same size tire of different manufacturers will behave differently, so all that info you posted in actually inconclusive.

Just a suggestion:
  1. If you need new rims, get as narrow as possible, e.g.: 8.5". Less likely to blow a bead when aired down for off roading, if you do that type of thing.
  2. Decide upon the largest tire that'll fit in your spare.
  3. Decide upon what type of terrain you'll be on. Myself, for off road: mostly dirt, sand, rock, not really ever mud (that's for the folks back east!). For pavement, wet, snow, a little ice. Get a tire that works for what you'll be using it for.
  4. Decide upon what type of tread, A/T, M/T, etc.
  5. Go with a soft side wall. You'll get a smoother ride and if you air down, a larger tire contact patch.

For myself, I swear by BFG, either the A/T's or M/T's. Been using them for decades. I get about 60,000 miles from a set. They are very good in almost ALL conditions, quiet, and even the M/T's are quiet, until the tread gets about half worn. Not cheap, but about middle of the road for pricing.
Check TireRack for the tires you want. They have reviews on almost every tire and how they're rated for various conditions, e.g.: wet, snow, ice, rock, etc.
 
Last edited:
You've posted a lot of tire sizes but no manufacturer's or whether they were A/T's, M/T's or ??
The same size tire of different manufacturers will behave differently, so all that info you posted in actually inconclusive.

Just a suggestion:
If you need new rims, get as narrow as possible, e.g.: 8.5". Less likely to blow a bead when aired down for off roading, if you do that type of thing.
Decide upon the largest tire that'll fit in your spare.
Decide up on what type of terrain you'll be on. Myself, for off road: mostly dirt, sand, rock, not really ever mud (that's for the folks back east!). For pavement, wet, snow, a little ice. Get a tire that works for what you'll be using it for.
Decide up what type of tread, A/T, M/T, etc.
Go with a soft side wall. You'll get a smoother ride and if you air down, a larger tire contact patch.

For myself, I swear by BFG, either the A/T's or M/T's. Been using them for decades. I get about 60,000 miles from a set. They are very good in almost ALL conditions, quiet, and even the M/T's are quiet, until the tread gets about half worn. Not cheap, but about middle of the road for pricing.
Check TireRack for the tires you want. They have reviews on almost every tire and how they're rated for various conditions, e.g.: wet, snow, ice, rock, etc.
Excellent advice, also be sure to stick with 0 offset if not rubbing on fenders and body mount is a consideration
 
Back
Top Bottom