Thermostat Question (s)?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jun 18, 2003
Threads
706
Messages
9,047
Location
Oriental, NC
I have been reading all about the thermostat on this board and it is great info. The question I have is this, if I use the old method of removing the radiator cap, letting the vehicle idle to warm up, when is the thermostat suppose to open and suck the coolant down? I have been having cooling issues and wanted to make sure the mechanic added enough coolant so this morning, I removed the radiator cap and let the vehicle warm up, the collant never got sucked, not even after 20 minutes. This seems strange to me like the thermostat is stuck.

Chain of events
2 saturdays ago the vehicle began to run towards the red, I took it in to a mechanic. The replaced the heater control valve and a heater hose.

Yesterday, I took the truck in for an oil change and ac recharge. The ac worked for a bit on the way home but then stopped colling once the truck got past the middle on the heat gauge. Once I slowed from highway speed the ac began to cool again.

This moning on the way to work, the ac worked great the entire time. The temp gauge mever moved past the middle.

On another note, I set the CC and a check engine light came on. The CC continued to function and the truck was running fine.

96 LX450 with 157k miles.

At this point I think I need a new thermostat because the coolant was never sucked down this morning and I do not know the last time the thermostat was changed.

Any insight would be greatly appreciated.

uzj100
 
I'm not sure what you're referring to by "coolant sucked down". With the radiator cap off I would expect the coolant to overflow out of the radiator as it warms up and expands. This is why you have an overflow bottle.
 
Jon,

Good point however when the thermostat opens (on other cars I have worked on) at some point the coolant gets sucked down, circulates around. So at some point with the cap off the fluid should move. Maybe the 4.5l is newer than what I use to work on.

Is this the same Jon Held from the original yahoo 80 series board?

Thanks,

uzj100
Andrew Roane
 
I think you are working on the assumption that the coolant level is not full and that the engine is not full. If that were the case then when the thermostat opened the coolant level would drop as it filled the engine.

Your coolant must already be full...filling all of the engine and radiator. Then it would not suck-down when it heated up.
 
Ok, gotcha. Now the question is why is my engine heating up past half on the temp gauge? This has not happened in the past.

It should be an interesting ride home today. 87 out now and suppose to be 90 on the way home.

uzj100
 
If you have an un-modded temperature gage then I caution you to watch that needle very closely. That gage doesn't show problems until you have one. You should pull over and park/shutdown as soon as the temp climbs above normal.

My truck is in the shop for a head gasket right now and I can trace it back to not respecting that gage enough.
 
Since you don't know when the thermostat was replaced last, I'd start by just changing it. It's not difficult and inexpensive.

Also check that your fan clutch is working properly. (Listen for a cold start-up 'rush' and/or spin 'test')

Finally, if you can, do the RT temp gauge mod. It's worth it.
 
The first time the gauge ever moved is when a hose busted and coolant was going everywhere. I shut it down right before red at the mechanic and did not restart until the hose was fixed. The gauge moved yesterday in 90 weather, in traffic. I was running pretty strong and it moved a little above middle, the AC stopped cooling and then the needle came right back down to the middle. The gauge has acted normal today. This is why i keep coming back to the thermostat because it does seem to be opening soon enough.

What is the spin test?

Thanks,

uzj100
 
I found it. Thanks.

I have all the records on the truck since new. I am going to review them for fan clutch, thermostat and radiator.

Thanks for all the good info.

uzj100
 
Is this the same Jon Held from the original yahoo 80 series board?

Hey Drew, it's been a while. Hope you and yours are well.

If the stat was faultly I don't think the temp would ever settle into it's normal range. It would just start cold and climb to hot. At least that has been my experience with a faulty stat. This sounds like fan clutch to me. Certainly change the stat in any case.

BTW, fan clutches can fail in a variety of ways and should be replaced every 100K miles. Some have replaced the fluid with good results, some have not. IMO after 100K miles just replace the whole thing and move on. Make sure you stick to OEM parts.
 
if the coolant isn't getting "sucked down" then system is full.... if it is full you'll never be able to see when it opens by looking in the cap. At most the coolant might swirl a little
 
X3 on the fan clutch, your AC cut off because your engine temp reached 226 degrees.

If I were you I would do the following in this order.

1. verify fan clutch is working and R/R as necessary
2. Bubble test to make sure you didn't toast your head gasket.
3. Coolant flush and check for sludge
4. replace PHH (if not already done, why drain and fill twice?)
4. replace thermostat
5. refill coolant
6. test drive
7. RT temp gage mod.
 
I am on it. Fan clutch first. No swoosh at start up. The coolant and PHH have been replaced last week. I will do the bubble test after all this.

Thanks for everyones input.

uzj100
 
I would do the bubble test first to ensure that you don't need to tear it down first. If it needs to be torn down, you may as well do everything else while you have it apart, rather than putting new parts on and then taking them off again if you have to tear it down.
 
Ordered the fan clutch and it will be here tomorrow. No bubbles that I can tell and no funny sweet smell at start up.

uzj100
 
I replaced the fan clutch this morning. The clutch was the original and rusted on. It took a bit to remove. I can not tell if this has helped any since the temps have dropped back to the 60s.

I highly recommend everyone change their fan clutch. It is a 1 banana job and can save a bunch of cooling issues.

Thanks for all the help.

uzj100
 
suck the coolant down?


last vehicle I worked on that did this was a '72 el camino with a cross flow radiator, you could look down the side tank with the cap off and watch the level drop and the coolant flow out of the cores when the thermostat opens,


the 1FZ has a much more advanced coolant flow pattern, if you want to know when the thermostat opens feel the top hose, when it is hot the thermostat is open.
 
Back
Top Bottom