Some good info here.
@land cruiser kid you ever figure it out?
@bj40green “So it's not an electrical problem. If it was, the starter would come free at the first time you switched it off.”
Mine has stayed cranking and I can’t get it to stop. Even with no keys in the ignition. If I cut the fuel and pull the battery cable the engine dies and the starter stops. But with the engine off, no keys in the ignition, and as soon as I hook the battery up it starts cranking again. Seems like there is an electrical problem somewhere?
Tried the “hit it” technique and nothing. Will try it again with a bigger hammer

But it seems that should only work with an already running engine?
@Rustbustr I’m wondering if mine is doing what yours was and is shorting itself to always be engaged. Would yours start cranking as soon as you reconnected the battery?
Also this is a 1979 BJ40 with a B engine.