Starter or solenoid problem?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Threads
60
Messages
2,750
I had been dealing with an intermittent no-start problem last fall and I thought I had cured it. I replaced my contacts & plunger, no change. I found that my NSS was loose, so after setting it in position and tightening it down I thought I was good to go. Since then I've also pulled the plug off the NSS, cleaned it out and added some dielectric grease.

The problem has resurfaced again in the last few weeks. The symptoms are as follows:

A: Truck starts from cold perfectly in the morning, even with way below freezing temps. No weak cranks, no skipping, no problems.
B: Truck won't crank over at all when the engine is at/near operating temp. No starter crank, no solenoid clicking.
-When B happens I have two options: I can let the truck sit for 15-30 minutes to cool down, or I can use a jumper wire from battery positive to the connector on the solenoid. With either method the truck will start perfectly (like A).

I have gotten to know my multimeter much better since the last time I was diagnosing this problem and I have a few readings that I think might have some importance. When engine is cool and "startable", the voltage between the starter solenoid wire (black-red) and the solenoid terminal connector it plugs into is approximately 11.6v with the ignition at START. It is approximately 3.5v at ON.

After taking those readings I drove the truck around for 20 minutes to make sure I was at operating temperature and then it was back to the driveway. Turned it off and tried to start again, nothing. Took the same readings and had approx 10.6v at START and 3.4v at ON. Is this voltage drop acceptable?

I am thinking it's a problem somewhere within the starter. From my understanding there are two main parts in the starter: the starter motor that turns over the engine, and the solenoid that gets power to the starter motor with a trigger from the ignition switch. A lot of the threads I have seen here recommend replacing the solenoid as a cure for no starts; does that apply to my case? What is it that goes bad inside the solenoid? I am leaning towards the solenoid as the culprit but I would appreciate some input from folks here
:cheers:
 
On my 91 the exhaust runs out on the driver side so it is not near the solenoid. If the starter is on the same side as mine (pass.) then your exhaust runs by it right? On Chevys the solenoid goes because of this it gets really hot then cools and then hot, etc. they wear quick. I would guess that your is getting to that point. I am sure there is someone on here that will have better info for you but my guess is that. One trick that I have had to use before and it works well on my Suburban is to hit the starter with something really trying to tap the solenoid and then try (tanker trick). It can jar loose the solenoid. It works every time on my Chevy too.

Matthew
 
The voltage you are getting at the solenoid during no starts should be sufficient to engage the starter according to the starter shop that rebuilt my starter and helped me troubleshoot my intermittent starting problem. You are getting voltage to the solenoid just like I was, my problem was that I had a broken wire and although I had voltage I could read with a meter the voltage would drop to nothing was it was put under a load because of the very small contact of the broken wires. I was getting voltage with the solenoid wire unplugged and testing with the meter, BUT when I tapped into the wire and left it connected to the solenoid and then tried to start it I was getting next to nothing.

So, make sure that you are getting voltage to the solenoid with the wire still plugged into it. Use a sharp meter tester to push through the insulation in the wire or one of those snap on plastic splicers that are common for hooking up trailer plugs. If you are sure you are getting at least 10 volts under load then I would proceed at looking at the solenoid. I thought it was my solenoid as well because I have dealt with the dreaded heat soaked starter solenoid on both my previous V8 conversions, but I learned it is not a common problem on our 80's. If you think it is your solenoid do what Matthew said and tap on it when you get the no start and see if you can get it to start that way.

If you are not getting voltage to the solenoid under load then I would start looking for a broken wire or bad connection like I had. If it comes to this I an help you with connections to test so you can narrow it down to the problem.

Garett
 
The starter on my truck is on the opposite side from the exhaust.

I had my multimeter hooked up in series between the end of the solenoid wire and the solenoid, does that count as testing it under load? Or does the system have to be hooked up completely, with the multimeter reading from the connection to a ground point?
 
You must test it with the factory wire plugged into the solenoid. That is when I found I wasn't getting voltage during the no start situation.
 
Back
Top Bottom