Starter clunking noise

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 29, 2015
Threads
18
Messages
107
Location
Bay Area, CA
Hi,
I'm new here thought I am active on other Toyota forums, however this is my first FJ80

I just bought it a week ago. The starter cables were disconnected. Got them back on and every now and then I hear a loud clucnking nose while trying to start it. It does start and the clucnking does not happen eve tatie but often. I noticed the top larger bolt on the starter was loose. I tighten it and the problem still exists.
Has anyone here encountered the issue? What could it possibly be?

This in advance
 
tacorican, welcome to the forum and congrats on your new to you Cruiser. We need more info to help troubleshoot the starter problem. What year is your Cruiser, why was the battery disconnected, and why was the starter mounting bolt loose? Did the PO mess with the starter him/herself, if so, what did they do and why? I would pull the starter and inspect it, solenoid contacts (burnt) and drive gears teeth (chipped or missing). The fusible link coming off the positive side of the battery cable can cause starting problems, although I'm not sure about intermittent clunking, but it's a definite maybe.
 
Last edited:
Hi. My apologies. It's a 1996 LX450. It was stored/parked at the previous owners business hence why they disconnected / removed the battery to use on another vehicle. They say it sat for about a month though I feel it sat for most likely close to 6 months going based on the Expired Tags. The Power Steering and Starter appear to be replaced. PS Pump says Reman on it and the starter looks a bit too new. I checked upon hearing the clunking noises and noticed the top bolt was not tightened all the way. Also, it didn't start when I first put the battery in. That's when I found that the starter cables were not connected. It looks like the original connection is there but they used some type of "Speaker Wire' with a female connector hooked up to the starter.
 
Yes, you can post a youtube video here.

There are two electrical connections hooked to the starter, a large cable (the power (+) from the battery), and a small wire (from the ignition switch to the starter solenoid) with a female connector on it. The large cable is attached to the starter with a nut (12mm, best I can remember) and the small wire attaches with the female connector. Two 17mm bolts hold the starter to the engine. There is a common problem that occurs with the solenoid contacts, they burn and sometimes weld themselves together causing the starter to continue running after releasing the ignition switch, and even with the key removed from the switch. You have to disconnect the negative battery cable in order to get it stopped. The fusible link comes off the positive side of the battery at the cable and can cause starter problems. Consider replacing it ($10-12).
 
Sounds like the solenoid dying, if so not worth repairing that starter. My first choice for replacement is the Denso 280-0169.
 
Yep, that sounds like the solenoid contacts failing to maintain contact. You can buy a solenoid contact rebuild kit from supporting vendors on this forum, aka Cdan or Beno.
 
Ok, I got a starter from Toyota and the occasional clunking continues.
Is there anything that the cable shown here could be causing an issue? I believe this one had an alarm installed and later removed so they rigged it by using this speaker wire. What does that do?
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1452732692.636853.webp



Sent from my iPhone
 
tacorican, that brown wire definitely isn't original and I'd be very suspect that it's related to the clunking problem. See the small black connector to the left of the long starter bolt head in the your picture. The original wire looks like that, and the one in the picture doesn't look like it's hooked up to anything. Do you know what that connector is supposed to hook up to? It might be the original starter wire and was unhooked to be replaced with the brown one as part of a remote start system. Is there a Mud member close to you that'll help you troubleshoot the starter system? Do you have the FSM and the EWD? There's some pretty savvy members on here that can help you better than I can with electrical issues. Don't give up and keep us posted as to what you've done and how it turned out. Keep the faith.
 
I don't have the FSM. Here is what I found from the ignition connecting to the engine wire harness. I removed the wire from the one that it was spliced into and plugged the original plug back into the starter. That now does nothing. All the lights turn on in the dash when ignition is on but if I try to start it, nothing happens at the starter. The black plug is what connects from the ignition switch to the starter. The white one is at the ignition switch. On the black plug, next to the black and red wire there's an empty spot. I didn't see if anything was cut off, however on the white one, that spot has a brown / red wire. Does anyone know what that's for? Looks like the 80 had a remote starter. Are there any other wires that are messed with upon installation of a remote starter? Any mudders familiar with the electronic wiring? I need to get the 80 moved. :(
Thanks again in advance
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1453648501.170083.webp
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1453648509.904315.webp
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1453648517.871561.webp



Sent from my iPhone
 
Here's the FSM pages for the starter circuit. Hopefully this will help you with this puzzle! See if you can ID the two connectors you're working with from the pdf.
 

Attachments

I don't believe that chipped tooth will cause that type of issue. If you were to completely missing few teeth in a row, then the starter would just wind up like a typical electrical motor. That isn't the case here.



View attachment 1202032
I believe I have Found the problem. Could this be it? Chipped tooth on the drive plate/flex plate.


Sent from my iPhone
 
Hmm, mine has done this about 3-4 times since I had the starter out in January. But only a single clunk, then starts right up. I was leaning toward a chipped flex plate although, not sure if that is the case with mine or not.

Kind of discouraging that the new starter did not solve the issue for you. Are you still experiencing problems?
 
I'm curious also, did you ever find the starting problem? If you did, what was it and what did you do to fix it?
 
So, it may be coincidental, but my starter just began to do this after running heavier gauge cable from battery to the starter. Never made this sound in the three years that I've owned the truck. This was all part of a dual battery set up with upgraded 150 amp alternator. Like I said, it could be coincidental, but it is seems to be directly linked to the new work. Any thoughts?
 
So, it may be coincidental, but my starter just began to do this after running heavier gauge cable from battery to the starter. Never made this sound in the three years that I've owned the truck. This was all part of a dual battery set up with upgraded 150 amp alternator. Like I said, it could be coincidental, but it is seems to be directly linked to the new work. Any thoughts?
Interesting, that’s when mine started as well.
 
My uneducated guess about a system I don't fully comprehend the functionality of, is as follows: The oversized wire is supplying a little more voltage to my original starter and is revealing the beginnings of a failure. The starter does crank a little faster after the dual battery install. I'm using a Blue Sea 7622 without the start isolation hooked up, so I presume both batteries are being used when starting. I may be wrong on this. Hopefully someone more intelligent will chime in and correct any of my inaccurate ramblings. I have a new Toyota starter on order, and I'll report back when I get some time with it installed. If this doesn't work, I guess it's broken teeth on the flywheel....or a lack of cup holders.
 
Well, after 20 or so starts with a remanufactured Toyota starter, I'm inclined to say the problem has been fixed. Perfect operation every time with no horrifyingly loud clunking. However, this did not fix my lack of cup holders, so I guess I'll need to deal with that problem separately. I hope this helps someone else out!
 
Back
Top Bottom