Starter, Battery, or Alternator Problem???

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Threads
13
Messages
85
Location
Yakima, WA
I've done my research on this site and my first tasks will be to check battery voltage and check & clean connections. But here are my symptons and I wanted to know what you guys think. The threads I've researched seem similar in some parts but not completely the same. So here goes:

Yesterday, I drove my 80 to and from work and it started up just fine a few times that whole day. Stopped at the store and when I get back in to start up the 80 it just clicks once and does not start. I do that several more times and no luck. I hear a faint whine which I presume is the starter. All lights are fine, headlights, interior LED, dashboard lights. I turn them on and off just to see if its the battery, but all seems fine there although I did not leave them on for a long time. When I turn the key, the headlights do dim a little, but not much else.

So eventually I get back to the vehicle and jump-start it. It cranks up real slowwwww, but it starts. Now the engine is behaving weak. RPM is much lower, around 400-500rpms and shaking quite a bit more than usual. On the short drive home, drives okay, but when I come to a stop, the rpms drop much lower than usual back down to 400-500rpms and shaking again. Does that every time I slow to a near stop and when just idling. I normally idle 900-1000rpms.

So is this just a weak battery (about 50k mile old yellow top Optima, not sure on age, haven't asked PO), starter contact replacement, or the alternator? I tried to start it again today and no luck, and lights are fine again.

Let me know what you guys think. Thanks ahead for your opinions.
 
My guesses;

starter solenoid
or
fuseble link
 
You can check the charge (but not condition) of the battery with a multi-meter. Also, the alternator.

Don't just throw parts at it.

Good luck, let us know.
 
Thank you for the quick advice guys.

It seems like its the battery. I swapped in my Tacoma's and it cranked right up, actually much faster than before. That Optima must have been on its dying legs.

I will purchase a new one and hope nothing else happens.

Do Optima's not last longer than standard batteries (i.e. Duralast, etc.)? As far as I could tell from the PO, he's had it for under 50k miles but not sure on how many years. Should be a few, and we've had some nasty hot summers the past few (SoCal). I can't justify spending that much if it does not last longer, plus I don't really have any power-hungry accessories yet. From research looks like Costco brand is pretty good.
 
Thank you for the quick advice guys.

It seems like its the battery. I swapped in my Tacoma's and it cranked right up, actually much faster than before. That Optima must have been on its dying legs.

I will purchase a new one and hope nothing else happens.

Do Optima's not last longer than standard batteries (i.e. Duralast, etc.)? As far as I could tell from the PO, he's had it for under 50k miles but not sure on how many years. Should be a few, and we've had some nasty hot summers the past few (SoCal). I can't justify spending that much if it does not last longer, plus I don't really have any power-hungry accessories yet. From research looks like Costco brand is pretty good.

I've heard mixed reviews about Optimas. Personally, I don't care for the "gel-cell" technology. My batteries have been doing fine even when jostled to the extreme (man, those speed bumps, whew), with the exception of the last battery...
 
Back
Top Bottom