SMOG / Catalytic Question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 25, 2017
Threads
33
Messages
276
Location
San Diego, SoCal, USA
I've been dealing with undoing some of the errors of the prior owner and my truck's now failed smog 2x, specifically was running high on HC's at idle. I've made a few changes and tuning updates in the engine bay but just discovered that one of the cats was eliminated and the one I had on there was bad (rattled like a baby's toy).

So here's the question, will cat's alone eliminate/reduce HC's? Here's the crux of the question, my truck passed HC's at 2500 RPM, so is there any difference to how the engine runs at idle vs. load? Is more fuel being pumped at idle than load, maybe an efficiency issue? I haven't checked the MAF yet but I don't know how far to keep digging before going back to the smog guy for a retest, don't want to keep throwing money at the truck and the smog guy unnecessarily. TIA!
 
Run the fuel level down, like less than 1/4 tank, add ~half a gallon of denatured alcohol, or ~a gallon of E85 if you have access. Drive a bit, do the swerve to mix it, and get the motor running on the mix. For what you are talking about this has worked for us every time.

Drill and remove the plug on the flapper box, loosen the adjustment screw under it to lean. It works like an idle mixture adjustment on a carb. So if the timing jumper is in, can do a lean drop adjustment just like a carb, or 8-12 turns has worked.
 
wouldn't start the other day and thought I'd run it dry so it's currently running a 18:1 ratio of 87 octane and VP M5 Methanol. Was planning on running that mix for smog anyway, will that work the same as the alcohol or E85?

And by flapper box you're referring to the MAF just off the air filter box?
 
Yep, AFM, the idle mixture adjustment is under a soft alloy plug. We use ~1/8" drill to drill into it, then a sheet metal screw in the hole to get hold of it, claw hammer to remove.

SmAFM1-th.jpg
 
And you just leave it like that permanently?

We do, our emissions don't care anymore. In the old days had to replace them, were available from the dealer, haven't replaced one in a couple of decades, and haven't been dinked on them. The other way is to shallow drill, not all of the way through, then put it back upside down.
 
Why don't you replace the cats?, you know it needs it. One is missing and the other has a loose element. Why continue looking for parts to replace/repair when there are parts that you know for sure are bad?

I wouldn't recommend messing with the AFM since as we discovered from your earlier thread (ran the numbers from the smog report through a Lambda calculator) that your engine is in nearly perfect fuel control during idle and 2500rpm operation. Why mess with a component that in all likeliness is working perfectly while there are other parts that are definitely bad?

And to answer your question, yes, that is a classic symptom of a weak/bad cat, decent numbers at 2500 rpm and total lack of operation at idle. Not only do the cats cool at idle, the engine will inherently run cleaner as the rpms increase, especially under no load.

My advise is to replace the cats and go from there. Can't guarantee it'll pass but I suspect it will pass with flying colors.
 
Sorry, just to clarify, I wrote this while waiting for cats to be installed at muffler shop, just got back from there just now...two new maganaflow cats and a new muffler are now installed. Also, there was just the one jankey cat, one had been eliminated. Thanks for the response @dugsgms, I'd forgotten your original comment since I'd been treading water for a bit. Will try to take it down to a pass or free shop this weekend and see what happens. Just didn't know how an engine works at idle vs. load. Will report back!
 
I had a BMW that wouldn't pass with high HC's. If I changed the oil prior to the test, it would pass with flying colors. I ended up selling to my friend and he asked me if I ever had failing smog. I told him the trick it worked for him as well.

If I were you I'd double check your timing is set at 5-7° (I think that is 3FE spec). The new cats should definitely help with HC.
 
Items that can cause your high HC are as follows 1.improper ignition timing, 2. defective ignition components, 3. Lean Fuel Mixture,4. Defective catalytic converter 5. defective air injection components, 6. low cylinder compression. One of the most common causes of high HC on my customers cars at idle was due to vacuum leaks, causing a lean misfire. One of the first items i would check, would be the vacuum hoses. At idle i would spray some carb cleaner around the intake and over the vacuum hoses, if the idle changes, you've found a leak. The next common problem was bad spark plug wires, along with the timing being set wrong.http://www.smogtips.com/cat.cfm
 
Last edited:
Report back on the Magnaflow cats. I assume Kalifornia kompliant? Gotta figure at some point cats fail regardless?
 
Back
Top Bottom