SF v.s. FF axle

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 4, 2006
Threads
636
Messages
23,860
Location
Buckley, WA
Which is actually stronger (stock v.s. stock).
I haven't actually seen anyone on hear report a broken sf shaft but have seen some FF shafts brake.
I've heard that the SF shaft is also bigger. I know that the FF has advantages over the SF but i'm just wondering which one actually has the stronger stock shafts.
 
Semi floater shafts are usually stronger for wheeling, often, a larger diameter shaft and spline section, but if you break, you will have to replace them.

full floater is better for load bearing, possibly used in 80s because of the third row seats and the expectation of hauling a lot of people. if you break one of these, the vehicle is still mobile, you just lose drive to that wheel.
 
Semi floater shafts are usually stronger for wheeling, often, a larger diameter shaft and spline section, but if you break, you will have to replace them.

full floater is better for load bearing, possibly used in 80s because of the third row seats and the expectation of hauling a lot of people. if you break one of these, the vehicle is still mobile, you just lose drive to that wheel.

That's what I thought... thanks

What do replacement shafts normally run?? I think toyota are the only ones to get them from??
 
Main reason SF axle shaft is bigger is because it is a load bearing member of the axle, where as FF axle shaft only transfers torque. It does NOT mean SF is stronger for off-roading, just needs to be bigger to survive. Try this link for more info:

Rear Axle Semi-Floating and Full-Floating - Off-Road Magazine
 
Last edited:
Full floater axles are stronger and offer other advantages.


Full Floater Rears Info
[FONT=arial, helvetica]The ideal setup for an axle housing is that of the full floater assembly. First off it’s 20% stronger than a conventional (semi-floater) assembly and the housing is usually 40% stronger. All NASCAR rears are Full-Floaters and use oversize rear bearings in a 4"+ Hub!. FullFloaters are not always used in a production vehicles simply because it costs more to manufacture than that of the semi-floating axle. However, for the Racing and off-road worlds, the advantages of a full floater axle setup far outweigh any cost difference between it and the semi-floater axle.[/FONT]
 
What do replacement shafts normally run?? I think toyota are the only ones to get them from??

I have a set of trail spares I picked up from cruiserparts.net a few years ago, but yes, OEM is the way to go IMO.

I have seen lots of 40 Series break SF rears and only heard of 1 80 Series. It is not a common failure point IMO, but stuff breaks on the trail sometimes. It would absolutely SUCK to have to do that in the field, but I'm not swapping to a FF axle.

FWIW I had all 4 shafts out recently and after the first 200K miles the rears still look new. I was looking specifically for spline twisting and bearing wear. I'm still on my first set of bearings and seals.
 
Thanks but I was talking about SF replacements.



Thanks for the responses and articles but i've also seen others that claim the SF axle shaft is stronger.
The only thing that got me thinking about it is the fact that i've never seen anyone on here report a broken SF shaft but i've seen dozens of FF shafts break. Oh well it doesn't really matter.

Yeah, the SF has to be stronger since it transfers torque while supporting weight.

Not sure about dozens of broken FF axles, but there has been an issue on elocker equipped rear axles where one side has short splines twisting inside of the rear stock locker carrier with 38"+ tires during extreme wheeling. I have heard of this happening 3 or 4 times.

I have never heard of a non-elocker equipped FF axle with or without an aftermarket locker (ARB etc) twisting an axle. The non-locking factory FF axles do not have a short spline side.

I would definitely say that FF are understood in general to be stronger than SF axles aside from any selective poor design characteristics such as the short spline axle found in the Toyota elocker FF axle. If one is running their Cruiser with tires bigger than 35" in extreme situations they may be better off with a SF or else a factory non-locker equipped FF axle (long splines on both sides) with an aftermarket locker.
 
Last edited:
SF is stronger....until I see some numbers I have no reason to believe other wise. Too few reports of broken SF shafts, especially considering the early 80s are being wheeled more/harder than the newer ones; and too many reports of broken FF shafts with rigs on small tires.

Jamisobe, it's not even 38"+ tires. There are reports of those twisted splines on rigs with 315s, 35s, 36s, and 37s.

Have any of you guys compared the two shafts side by side? What about compared them to other axles? The SF shaft looks eerily similar to a 6-lug 14b or SF D60.
 
SF is stronger....until I see some numbers I have no reason to believe other wise. Too few reports of broken SF shafts, especially considering the early 80s are being wheeled more/harder than the newer ones; and too many reports of broken FF shafts with rigs on small tires.

Jamisobe, it's not even 38"+ tires. There are reports of those twisted splines on rigs with 315s, 35s, 36s, and 37s.

Have any of you guys compared the two shafts side by side? What about compared them to other axles? The SF shaft looks eerily similar to a 6-lug 14b or SF D60.
There are no reports I have seen of a factory standard non-locker FF axle twisting in the carrier.

It is a fair statement to say that the poorly designed short spline axle in the factory locker equipped FF axles set-up causes that FF axle to be weaker than both the SF or the standard FF (with two long spline axle shafts).

It is false to say that SF axles are stronger than FF axles as a general statement. The opposite is true.

I suspect that the number of broken SF shafts is similar to the number of twisted short splines with the 80 series.
 
The short spline design issue aside, any search will reveal a decided preference for FF in general terms. Toyota intended for the locking FF axles to be an upgrade.


Ultimate Toyota-Based Axles: Part 3 | Trails Less Traveled
SEMI-FLOATING AXLE

Most cars and trucks on the road with solid rear axles use semi-floating axle-shafts. In this simple and cost-effective design, the axle-shafts support the weight of the vehicle in addition to providing the driving force to the wheels/tires. Semi-floating axles just aren’t the best choice for any vehicle that carries heavy loads or is driven hard off-road. A slightly bent axle-shaft will cause the axle seals to fail prematurely, allowing oil to seep past the wheel bearings, contaminating the drum brakes and rendering them useless. A broken axle-shaft can result in more serious damage if the wheel/tire separates from the vehicle when the axle-shaft fails.

FULL-FLOATING AXLE

Full-floating axles use two sets of tapered wheel bearings per wheel, mounted in tension, to distribute vertical and lateral loads. Full-floating wheel-bearings are typically much larger in diameter because they ride on the spindle instead of inside the axle housing. In contrast, semi-floating axles use a single wheel bearing per wheel, pressed onto the axle-shaft, and the whole assembly is bolted into the axle housing together. For reference, all steering 4WD front axles are ‘full-floaters’ because the wheel/hub has to ride on a spindle that is able to turn/steer.
Full-floating axles are superior to semi-floating axles. It’s a better design, plain and simple.
 
Ok, first we need to define what kind of strength we are talking about. There are two loads here: Static load (weight of the vehicle and payload-bending load), and torque load (turning the tires-torsional load).
I assume the question is: "Which shaft (FF or SF) can handle a larger torque load without breaking (all other things being equal, including static bending load)?"
An SF shaft may be larger in diameter (so far I haven't seen any measurements on either), but because it sees a combination of both loads, its overall stresses may be higher, which would lead to breakage sooner.
A FF shaft only sees the torque load and no bending load, so even if it was smaller in diameter, it theoretically can handle a larger torque load before breaking.
The only way to know for sure would be to either have the measurements of both shafts and do the calculation or do testing like Bobby Long does. However, I would think the tests would only be valid if the SF shafts were also put under a bending load like they would see in the vehicle, otherwise, if they were larger than the FF, they would be able to take a higher torsion load.
This argument doesn't take into account other differences in shaft design other than diameter. Stress risers from diameter changes, spline length and number, shaft mounting design, quality control and design of shaft alignment, etc all contribute to shaft strength.

Overall load bearing strength of the entire axle assmebly is much higher in the FF because of the bearings and hub design, which are also critical components of strength, but I don't think that is what was being considered here.
 
X2 on post#12 by jamisobe! One of the reasons I originally wanted an 80 was the factory FF and rear disk brakes. (Factory elockers was another, but we won't open up that subject, here). The advantages of FF far outweigh any benefits of SF - IMHO.
 
Apparently solidfrontaxle is the only one who gets it. And jamisobe, I'm talking about FJ-80 SF vs FZJ-80 FF...not a general statement of all axles. In that case, it is the SF shaft who takes the cake in strength.

We're not talking about any kind of twisting of splines or any of that nonsense, we're talking about breaking. And everything you guys have just said backs me up more so than it backs yourself up.

We are talking about torsional strength, which a larger shaft will have more of regardless if it's a SF or FF shaft.

Your FF axle may be able to hold up 10 tons more than the SF, but there is nothing a FF axle has over a SF that means more torsional strength will be gained.

The only way to gain more torsional strength is with different metal, metallurgy, or larger diameter shaft. The SF takes the cake here....as its shaft is visually much larger than the FF; assuming that the two are of similar materials and made with the same tolerances and have the same spline count.

The pluses of a FF are evident, and cannot me detracted from it....but carrying a bunch of weight and being able to limp home don't really make it that much better of an axle to me. Especially if it is going to be more prone to breakage in the first place.

Again, I am talking about the 80 series LCs axles when comparing SF to FF.
 
Last edited:
axles

I'd take a full floater any day. I think the main reason you hear about full floaters breaking, from Ih8mud 80 series section, is the high percentage of FZJ80's with full float axles and the factory elockers. The Factory rear elocker design is generally the culprit. Also, models with FF are 1fz rather than 3fe. That said, and ff or sf 80 series are better off in the rearend department than 95% of other vehicles out there!
 
I'll concede that there is a design fault with the short spline axle found on the elocker equipped FF axles. Though, as pointed out, the so equipped axles are still plenty strong (as are the 80series SFs) compared to most SF axles on trucks equipped with rear solid axles.

Beyond that I would have to say that there are multiple advantages to the standard (non-elocker equipped) FF rear axle over the SF including strength. Ever hear of a standard (non-elocker equipped) FF rear axle breaking or twisting on an 80 series? I have heard of a SF breaking.

So if maximum strength is desired for your 80 series the clear choice is a standard (non-elocker equipped) FF. Then addan ARB locker and you will have a bomb proof axle.
 
... especially considering the early 80s are being wheeled more/harder than the newer ones

This is simply not a true statement. There are many, many more FF rear axle trucks and they are being wheeled just as hard or harder than the earlier 80s with SF rear axles.

There are pics here and an article in TT where they spent most of the day dragging a SF earlier 80 off one of the trails out west. I think it was Mudrak and some of the Norcal guys.

When you wheel trails like we have out here in the Southwest and the West, a busted SF axle when you are still on the trail is a major problem. A busted FF axle when you are still on the trail is no big deal.

-B-
 
Ok, so we can stop arguing air back and forth...let's state some facts that none of us can can argue about.

1) FF doesn't have to have a shaft to move.
2) FF has better load bearing ability than a SF.
3) SF shaft is much larger than FF shaft.
4) FF shafts have been known to break more often than SF


Here's my opinion on these facts.

1) Although a FF allows one to limp home easier than a SF does; it is just as, if not more difficult to repair in the field or at home.

2) A 37"+ tire is more likely to cause breaking on either axle than adding 500# of junk. I'd rather my axles handle larger tires than heavier loads.

3) Larger = stronger

4) It's just a matter of numbers. Until we know them...it's all speculation and assumption. Your assumption is that more FFs exist so more must be wheeled. Mine is that there are more early 80s are bought to be abused than later 80s....there are more DD FZJs than FJs and more Beater FJs than FZJs.
 
This is simply not a true statement. There are many, many more FF rear axle trucks and they are being wheeled just as hard or harder than the earlier 80s with SF rear axles.

There are pics here and an article in TT where they spent most of the day dragging a SF earlier 80 off one of the trails out west. I think it was Mudrak and some of the Norcal guys.

When you wheel trails like we have out here in the Southwest and the West, a busted SF axle when you are still on the trail is a major problem. A busted FF axle when you are still on the trail is no big deal.

-B-
Opinion, on both sides....let's just agree to disagree.

Yes...a SF is a pain when it breaks, but you're only speaking of one instance.

What? Wide open deserts without trees or mud? Ever wheeled in the slick, sticky, nasty, narrow, tree-filled trails of the Right Coast? Not breaking in the first place takes greater priority than limp home ability here.
 
Back
Top Bottom