Relay v's Circuit Breaker

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 24, 2015
Threads
110
Messages
2,663
Location
Orlando, Florida
I am getting a little fed up with coming back to a flat house battery after i leave my truck in the airport for a week. I have a few electronics that pull a little current but when combined and left for more than 4 days i end up with a battery with about 9.6v. The bummer is that the ACR won't allow the charging voltage through if the house battery is below 10v so i have to wait until i get home then wire up the charger.
Time for a relay or a circuit breaker on the feed to my cabin fuse block.
I am tempted to go with a 100Amp relay so i can engage/disengage from the cabin versus a circuit breaker which i would have to install under the hood.
Have you guys got any experience /recomendations of either solutions?

J
 
Either one would work, the CB would protect your fuse block as well as isolate the circuit. But you would have to pop the hood to disconnect.
A relay could be tied into your start/run circuit and would be an automatic solution. I run the ACR as well and I dont like how it auto charges the house battery from the start battery if it senses low voltage, even when parked without the charging system active. I would like to isolate that charging switch/trigger so it only auto charges the house battery if the charging system is active.
 
Time for a relay or a circuit breaker on the feed to my cabin fuse block.
Are you saying you don't already have some form of protection between the house battery and the cabin?
You NEED a fuse or breaker for safety. The breaker provides a convenient disconnect.
 
I have a 100 amp breaker which goes out to my distribution block for my accessories. Sure I have to pop the hood but it's not a big deal. What's not switched is my fridge which has been running 24/7 for the past 6 years. That will drain it down over time. I added a 100w solar panel and problem solved. They are so inexpensive these days. I would recommend spending the money on that. A solenoid is convenient but does draw power while engaged. I wouldn't use one personally. Additionally, you do want ALL wires circuit protected in some way regardless of the direction you choose.
 
Are you saying you don't already have some form of protection between the house battery and the cabin?
You NEED a fuse or breaker for safety. The breaker provides a convenient disconnect.

I have a 100 A ANL fuse protecting the cabling between the battery and the fuse block.
 
I have a 100 amp breaker which goes out to my distribution block for my accessories. Sure I have to pop the hood but it's not a big deal. What's not switched is my fridge which has been running 24/7 for the past 6 years. That will drain it down over time. I added a 100w solar panel and problem solved. They are so inexpensive these days. I would recommend spending the money on that. A solenoid is convenient but does draw power while engaged. I wouldn't use one personally. Additionally, you do want ALL wires circuit protected in some way regardless of the direction you choose.

Actually i have the Renogy solar panel sitting in the workshop but i am just missing the roof rack to bolt it to. I considered buying one of the little tiddler panels that plug into the cigar lighter.
Plan is to finalize my rack choice later this year and install over the winter.
 
I have a 100 A ANL fuse...
Seems like the easiest thing would be to replace that with a breaker. Probably wouldn't even need to redo any wiring.
 
Seems like the easiest thing would be to replace that with a breaker. Probably wouldn't even need to redo any wiring.

I am starting to warm to that idea. It certainly looks like it would be the simplest solution.
 
You should kill off the drains that are going to ruin your house battery sooner rather than later.
 
Neither, use a 12V disconnect for vehicle storage. It is cheaper and more robust can a relay or breaker.
 
Neither, use a 12V disconnect for vehicle storage. It is cheaper and more robust can a relay or breaker.
I did think about that but the options i saw online looked pretty big. I dont have much room on the passenger side under the hood so kinda ruled it out.
 
Back
Top Bottom