As far as I know GM tapper and toyota tapper are different, at least that is the sorta answer I got from marlin.
I sent my pitmit arm into marlin to have them drill and 1" hole in my arm and have them put a insert in with the proper tapper. They did it for free for me but I bout my high steer arms and rods from them.
My pitmit arm was off a wagoneer, completly flat. Dosn't a TJ have like a 3" drop on it? How tall is this 40? Or do you just have your box mounted weird, like angled up or somthing? My steering angles are perfect, I was excited

If you go the marlin rout you will need more meat on the end of the pitmit then a TJ has got. I know some full size dodges have a big end on them and a large drop.