Por-15

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Soul_Man said:
I'm going to POR my frame, hopefully in about a month. Before the POR I'm going to have it galvanized :D

Why waste money? if you have the frame galvanized all you will need is a good primer (zero rust it also a primer) and a chassis black
 
burnttoastburgos said:
Whats the difference in protection between the Zero and POR.or is it the price. I just want whatever offers the strongest protection.


Do a search on Google for rust encapsulator from eastwood there is an indipendent test somewhere on the net .
Rust incapsulator is very similar to ZR in fact I started mine with RE and switched to ZR.
I honestly think it is the same product but ZR is less expensive

http://www.zero-rust.com/index.html
 
I POR15'd my FJ40 frame, axles, driveshafts, steering parts, engine(POR engine paints), transmission housing, etc; I aslo used Zerorust(spraycans) and had some parts powder coated. The POR15 isn't nearly as tough as it's advertised to be, but it has held up well on parts that had been sandblasted or very thoroughly cleaned. It didn't work so well on brand new metal and doesn't work period on aluminum, peels right off. The parts I've used Zerorust on are also holding up very well; I like the Zerorust finish (flat not shiny) on frame and drivetrain components. I recently did the frame on a F250 work truck with Zerorust, it doesn't seem to chip as easy, but it seemed more viscous than POR15, making the application(using a brush) a PITA(reducing it a little would have been a good idea). All that said, I like powder coated parts way more than the other two coatings, much, much stronger, better looking, the only downside it's friggin pricey.
If you're going to have the frame galvanized I'd just use an epoxy primer, like PPG DP50LF(I think that's what PPG calls the stuff), it dries to a nice flat black finish.
 
I'll just throw in my 2 pennies. I just yesterday picked up my frame from the powdercoater. They did a pretty good job, didn't get inside the frame rails as well as i wood have liked. Sandblasted and coated for $189. Everywhere else wanted 350 to 400.:eek: You may want to look at powder vs POR 15. Also talked to them and they said you can touch up powder coating with acrylic enamel, I did that this morning on the inside frame rails.
 
Cornbread said:
I'll just throw in my 2 pennies. I just yesterday picked up my frame from the powdercoater. They did a pretty good job, didn't get inside the frame rails as well as i wood have liked. Sandblasted and coated for $189. Everywhere else wanted 350 to 400.:eek: You may want to look at powder vs POR 15. Also talked to them and they said you can touch up powder coating with acrylic enamel, I did that this morning on the inside frame rails.

That's a great price.... man it's a ridiculously low price
:)
 
Cornbread said:
I know, I was kinda humoring myself by calling all the powder coaters around here. I was gonna paint it.

I could drive up there from NY with a frame and have it done
even adding gas and time etc.. it will still cost me less then to have done here in NY
:mad:
 
Cornbread said:
I'll just throw in my 2 pennies. I just yesterday picked up my frame from the powdercoater. They did a pretty good job, didn't get inside the frame rails as well as i wood have liked. Sandblasted and coated for $189. Everywhere else wanted 350 to 400.:eek: You may want to look at powder vs POR 15. Also talked to them and they said you can touch up powder coating with acrylic enamel, I did that this morning on the inside frame rails.

That is an amazing price, it'd be worth powdercoating the majority of the cruiser with prices like that.
 
I'm not sure what the fascination for powdercoating is based on, other than parts come back from the powdercoaters looking so beautiful. It is not especially abrasion resistant and is impossible to repair. Once corrosion gets underneath it doesn't provide much protection from lateral penetration. Concourse restorers use powdercoating because it looks so nice, but they don't take their junk out on the trail. If you plan to really use your rig, just paint it with one of the rust paints. If prep is done properly they're all pretty good. If rust develops wirebush it off and repaint the spot. I've used all of them except Rust Bullet. My favorite combination is to prep with Marine Clean and Metal Ready, and then paint with Zero Rust. For topcoat I use POR's ChassisCoat Black. This has held up incredibly well in the North East slush and salt. YMMV

Bill
 
I've not heard great things about POR 15, and it's expensive... Plus brake fluid takes it right off!

I would shoot for either:

Magnet Paints chassis saver, impervious to chemicals, salt and corrosives

or Eastwood's chassis black, cool thing is they sell aerosol cans too

www.eastwood.com

www.magnetpaints.com


I have a friend that got a sample of the Magnet product and he can bend the sample enless times and it will not crack or pop off!
 
billmc said:
I'm not sure what the fascination for powdercoating is based on, other than parts come back from the powdercoaters looking so beautiful. It is not especially abrasion resistant and is impossible to repair. Once corrosion gets underneath it doesn't provide much protection from lateral penetration. Concourse restorers use powdercoating because it looks so nice, but they don't take their junk out on the trail. If you plan to really use your rig, just paint it with one of the rust paints. If prep is done properly they're all pretty good. If rust develops wirebush it off and repaint the spot. I've used all of them except Rust Bullet. My favorite combination is to prep with Marine Clean and Metal Ready, and then paint with Zero Rust. For topcoat I use POR's ChassisCoat Black. This has held up incredibly well in the North East slush and salt. YMMV

Bill
What about rustproofing over por 15? I'm close to buying a 40 that the frame and undercarrige are por-ed but I want to drive it in the slush and snow in Pa. Thanks, John
 
jwildzza said:
What about rustproofing over por 15? I'm close to buying a 40 that the frame and undercarrige are por-ed but I want to drive it in the slush and snow in Pa. Thanks, John

I wouldn't do anything to rustproof it. If it was applied properly it should be fine. To apply paint over POR you would need to scuff the surface and use their Tie-coat primer.

Bill
 
Soul_Man said:
I'm going to POR my frame, hopefully in about a month. Before the POR I'm going to have it galvanized :D

Don't do this. Hot dip galvanising will harden the steel and cause it to crack under continual vibration and flexing. After galvanising you cannot anneal the steel frame because the melting temperature of zinc is below the annealing temperature of steel. If you do this you will break your chassis.
 
Milo, I'm sending an e-mail to the American Galvanizers Association to try to clear that up. I know about warping (which is why I'm not going to dip my body parts). If that is a problem I'll forget the dip :eek:

For powdercoating, I agree that it is not durable. Specifically, I've had problems with the lateral spread of rust like billmc said. I notice that small scratches will rust, and the rust then spreads like wildfire under the powdercoat to where the powdercoat starts to lift off in sheets.

I'm using POR-15 and topcoating that with POR's "Hardnose" paint. For my frame and undersurface of the body I will probably put on a tar-based undercoat to minimize chip damage from rocks.
 
Here's the reply from the galvanizer association:

Mr. Solis,



Hot-dip galvanizing is perfectly suitable for automobile frames. The process of hot-dip galvanizing steel does not alter the mechanical properties of the steel. There has been extensive research over the past 30 years to back that up. Also, trailer frames are quite frequently galvanized. A couple of examples are boat trailers and U-haul trailers. If you would like more information on the matter or would like to specifically see some examples, please let me know and I’ll be more than happy to provide you with some literature.



Sincerely,

John Krzywicki
Marketing Manager
American Galvanizers Association
"Protecting Steel for Generations"
jkrzywicki@galvanizeit.org
Phone: 720.554.0900x16 Fax: 720.554.0909
www.galvanizeit.org


So, I'm back to galvanizing. I know with the galvanizing I could go with regular paint/primer (and I may change my mind and do just that) but I REALLY HATE rust. Also I do a fair bit of beach driving with my trucks (to launch my jet skis) and I want to "overkill" it.
 
You can buy zero rust in rattle cans, qts and gallons. It is thick and has to be thinned to spray in an HVLP. Thins with laquer thinner and sprays great. I have read you can also use an airless to spray it direct from the can. I would suspect a primer gun and perhaps an under coating gun would also work without thinning. I too like the finish. I believe por has some nasty stuff in it and is not supposed to be sprayed without a mask. Cynates I think. ZR is really easy to use. Comes in colors. Just be sure to get a couple of good coats on.
 
llih said:
I believe por has some nasty stuff in it and is not supposed to be sprayed without a mask. Cynates I think. .

Correct, POR has isocyanates and you need a fresh air supplied mask if spraying it. Filters do NOT work with isocyanates, bad stuff..... Same thing in almost all clear coats (and I think a lot of bases have them), so if you have the set-up to to a clearcoat, the POR isn't any different.
 
Well, go ahead. Bad corrosion is a lot more dangerous than any minor weakening that may occur due to low temperature heat treatment.

Reading further into it, typical galvanizing temperatures are about 435 degC. This places the heat treament only in the minor stress relieving temperatures. If the temperatures reach above 538 degC then you enter into the full stress relieving areas. However, it is not until you reach 727 degC (the transition temperature from Ferrite to Austenite) that any annealing, normalizing or hardenning may occur. So I guess I jumped the gun a bit there. Sorry. The only references to weakening that I have been able to find are hydrogen embrittlement caused by the pickling and strain age embrittlement in susceptible steels. Both of which are explained here; http://www.gaa.com.au/page15-17.pdf

The reason that I mentioned it is that I know of someone who has galvanized a chassis and had it fail. After getting a few more details, it appears that the galvanizing process itself caused the failure. When he received the chassis back from the galvanizers it had multiple cracks through the parent metal. I would expect these cracks were a result of heat induced stress in the material. This is most likely a result of poor preparation on behalf of the galvanizers. Preheat may have been required to prevent excessive stress and distortion. Although it also could have been a result of hydrogen embrittlement as mentioned above.

I too do a lot of beach driving in my vehicle, plus the mud around here contains very high levels of salt. Every time I get back from Esperance or have been out in the mud I get it up on the ramps at work and give it at least an hours worth of cleaning from the pressure cleaner. A good galvanized chassis would be ideal for me too. Hmm...

Soul_Man said:
So, I'm back to galvanizing. I know with the galvanizing I could go with regular paint/primer (and I may change my mind and do just that) but I REALLY HATE rust. Also I do a fair bit of beach driving with my trucks (to launch my jet skis) and I want to "overkill" it.
 
Milo, can you give a link to the entire pdf document? That's some cool stuff. I'd like to learn more about galvanizing...

I had planned to dip my tub and cowl, but I understand the heat can warp the sheetmetal. I keep hoping to find some way around that (without destroying my cowl as a "test") :eek:
 
Back
Top Bottom