Painless dual batt question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 21, 2003
Threads
861
Messages
17,055
Location
Tijeras, NM
I'm asking this question on behalf of a good buddy since I'm unable to figure out what's going on here :frown: We've doing telephone troubleshooting off and on this week.

He has a Painless dual batt system and wired it up the system according to their instructions and is able to switch the 250 amp relay on to mode 1 (normal charge both batt with IGN on) or mode 2(self jump start).

What we can't figure out is how did the 250 amp cont duty solenoid go belly up? He can hear it click when he activates the coil but the dry contact shows an open circuit.

Ok, so he gets another 200 amp cont duty solenoid, installed it in his vehicle and after a short while, same thing happens :hhmm: He can make the solenoid "click" but the dry contacts are showing open circuit.

The IGN source that controls this circuit is rock solid. He gets a 12.5 with IGN ON/ENGINE OFF and 14.5 with IGN ON/ENGINE ON.

After receiving the second solenoid, he ran a test using his DVM for contact open and closed continuity and it checked out. So the solenoid tested ok before it was put into service.

Needless to say, he is very PO'ed and frustrated :mad: as you can imagine. I can't understand how it's even possible to smoke the solenoids in this manner. Any ideas?

As an aside, I have a similar dual batt system and still going strong on the original solenoid, going on five years now.
 
Check the ground side of the coil. If you have appropriate voltage/current on one side, and the ground is crappy, the contacts will bounce and open. You can use a jumper wire/cable and connect in parallel to troubleshoot. Another thought, what battery is the solenoid being powered from?
 
Painfull dual batt question

Mobi-arc

The ground on the coil is good and the main batt powers the coil - brand new Die Hard platinum

Dude,

Thanks for posting this for me. Too bad Fram & Fleet didn't carry any 250 amp solenoid.
 
He has a Painless dual batt system and wired it up the system according to their instructions and is able to switch the 250 amp relay on to mode 1 (normal charge both batt with IGN on) or mode 2(self jump start).

Here is a description of the modes I found:

"Painless Wiring 250 amp dual battery controller includes a three position switch to control the second battery through the operation of the solenoid.


  • Switch position one isolates the secondary battery so that the charging system charges the primary battery and not the secondary battery.
  • Switch position two connects the secondary battery while the ignition is on and disconnects the secondary battery from charging while the ignition is off.
  • Switch position three connects the second battery at all times so that the cars charging system charges the secondary battery at all times.
"

So I am assuming that the first state is with the toggle switch in the middle position with no light? The second state is with the switch in the 'red' position and the third is with the switch in the 'green' position?

Is this correct? Did you wire it exactly like the diagram indicates?

What we can't figure out is how did the 250 amp cont duty solenoid go belly up? He can hear it click when he activates the coil but the dry contact shows an open circuit.

How do you know it's bad? It could just be that the coil isn't getting enough juice to close the contacts.

Is it a 12V solenoid?

Is the coil connected the right way (there may be an internal diode)?

It looks like a pretty simple system. I doubt you could have two bad solenoids in a row (but it is possible I suppose). My guess is the problem is external to the solenoid.
 
Here is a description of the modes I found:

"Painless Wiring 250 amp dual battery controller includes a three position switch to control the second battery through the operation of the solenoid.


  • Switch position one isolates the secondary battery so that the charging system charges the primary battery and not the secondary battery.
  • Switch position two connects the secondary battery while the ignition is on and disconnects the secondary battery from charging while the ignition is off.
  • Switch position three connects the second battery at all times so that the cars charging system charges the secondary battery at all times.
"

So I am assuming that the first state is with the toggle switch in the middle position with no light? The second state is with the switch in the 'red' position and the third is with the switch in the 'green' position?

Is this correct? Did you wire it exactly like the diagram indicates?

Center is just your primary battery, green is both with ignition "on" and red is both batteries with ignition off...

That said, I have this system and I am starting to not like it more and more and might go with a custom set up.

-o-
 
Center is just your primary battery, green is both with ignition "on" and red is both batteries with ignition off...

That said, I have this system and I am starting to not like it more and more and might go with a custom set up.

-o-

The more I've been reading about these systems the more I have been happy with my HellRoaring choice.
 
Any chance they sent you 24v relay(s)?

>No, it's a 12volts. And it worked for a short term.


Did you wire it exactly like the diagram indicates?
How do you know it's bad? It could just be that the coil isn't getting enough juice to close the contacts.

>Yes, it is wired per Painless.
>Well, this is a simple relay: energize the coil and the contact closes. When energized, the continuity across the dry contacts is some where north of 1k ohm. The reading should be somewhere near 0 ohm or close.

Is it a 12V solenoid?

>Yes.

Is the coil connected the right way (there may be an internal diode)?

>This is a simple, dumb solenoid relay.
No internal diodes. Think "ford starter solenoids"!

It looks like a pretty simple system. I doubt you could have two bad solenoids in a row (but it is possible I suppose). My guess is the problem is external to the solenoid.

>Yeah, quite possible and that's where we're scratching our heads. :hhmm:

Center is just your primary battery, green is both with ignition "on" and red is both batteries with ignition off...

That said, I have this system and I am starting to not like it more and more and might go with a custom set up.

-o-

>tell me why you're thinking of going with a custom system. Is your system not functioning properly?

The more I've been reading about these systems the more I have been happy with my HellRoaring choice.

A dual batt system is very similar to a CB antenna installation IMHO. They're both very simple systems but a simple installation mistake can make you pull out your hair :doh:

Obviously, one can spend as much as he'd like on a dual batt system with all kinds of bells and whistles but a solenoid to connect two batteries together has been in use longer than most of us can remember. My old neighbor who was a rancher had this system in his 60's era Jeep CJ5 along with an old Belvedere (Warn 8274) winch. His solenoid was a simple Ford Starter type that was probably 15 years old by the time I saw it and it still worked great.

Thanks for the input fellas.
 
>

Obviously, one can spend as much as he'd like on a dual batt system with all kinds of bells and whistles but a solenoid to connect two batteries together has been in use longer than most of us can remember. My old neighbor who was a rancher had this system in his 60's era Jeep CJ5 along with an old Belvedere (Warn 8274) winch. His solenoid was a simple Ford Starter type that was probably 15 years old by the time I saw it and it still worked great.

Thanks for the input fellas.

Believe it or not but I may just use a Ford Solenoid for my 60 install just for simplicity. Heck I use to use Ford Solenoids with Chevy starters back in my chevy days.
 
Believe it or not but I may just use a Ford Solenoid for my 60 install just for simplicity. Heck I use to use Ford Solenoids with Chevy starters back in my chevy days.

Just make sure that it's a cont duty solenoid vs an intermittent duty starter solenoid.
 
oh yeah, I already learned that the hard way.

BTW, I was just thinking about the cost aspect that you mentioned. When I do a project like this I always try not to think about price. Its not like buying tires or sliders. There is always so much involved and I need to be very fluid in my decisions. Thats part of why I tend to go overboard. I always want to make sure that I am getting the most functionality out of what I am doing. Right or wrong. OCD and ADHD doesnt help.
 
Believe it or not but I may just use a Ford Solenoid for my 60 install just for simplicity. Heck I use to use Ford Solenoids with Chevy starters back in my chevy days.



Please check your terminology the "Ford solenoid" you are refering to is not a solenoid it is a relay. :bang:
 
When energized, the continuity across the dry contacts is some where north of 1k ohm. The reading should be somewhere near 0 ohm or close.

Well, I would expect the resistance to be infinity when open and close to zero when closed. That's probably what you are reading? If it's somewhere around 1k ohm, that is a problem.
 
Back
Top Bottom