P401 = new computer?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 14, 2006
Threads
9
Messages
37
Location
Davis, CA
Hi all

Does anybody near Sacramento have a test computer I could borrow before I buy a new one? Anybody have comments on OEM computer versus aftermarket computer?

I'm looking for a little sanity check. My 94 FJ80 (280k miles) has been in the shop for a month with a P401 CEL. It's been a mess, they've replaced the EGR and the VSV. The modulator tested OK, but they have a new one ready to go. They've cleaned out all the gunk in all the ports and replaced leaking vacuum lines. They even found water (clean water, not coolant) in the EGR valve itself.

After all of this work, everything tests out fine on a component level. But the system doesn't work. The EGR is not getting a signal to open consistently. We're stuck thinking it's a computer problem, or possibly a wiring problem. The shop wants to test it with a spare computer, but we can't find one. I'm hoping someone local might have one for testing?

Thanks.
-Dan
 
First there is some disconnect, what do you have? A FJ80 is a 3FE rig, doesn't monitor the EGR, a '94 is a OBD1 rig, will not set a P0401, that is an OBD2 code.

If you don't understand it, the EGR system can be a frustrating diagnosis. It doesn't sound like they are familiar with the job at hand, have fought this battle many times and have never seen an EGR problem need an ECU.
 
Yeah, sorry, I misstated the code after reading too many forum posts. It's a 94 with OBD1, the code wasn't P401, it was a 71, still EGR.

The guys at the shop have gone through all the diagnostics on each component and everything works (now at least), the EGR just isn't getting a signal to open when it's supposed to be getting a signal, which points to computer or wiring. The shop is highly regarded and has been around a long time, I've known the owner for many years, so I'm confident they know how to diagnose an EGR system much better than I.

Thanks.
 
How worried are you about the EGR? Code 71 can be a pain to diagnose but easy to put to bed by disabling the EGR via the resistor method. EGR only functions at highway speed so its not the going to turn your cruiser into some major polluter if not operational.

My guess is that its an issue with the EGR VSV which lives under the intake manifold. Does the shop have access to a 1994 FSM? If not give them the attached file for the EGR system.
 

Attachments

Just read that they replaced the VSV, sounds like the modulator is next. Remember the EGR won't get a signal until the truck is at highway speed.

I don't think you'll end up needing a new computer.
 
Thanks, Zack, I passed the pages on to the shop, hopefully they'll see something they haven't already tried. This is a CA truck and I have to clear the CEL to pass the smog inspection and renew my registration.
 
Quick test for the modulator...put a vacuum gauge onto port q (disconnect from the EGR). Then start it and rev it a little. The gauge should move. If not modulator for sure has a problem. (I just did this last week on mine). VSV will not engage unless you are going between I think 44 and 56 MPH for a certain time. You cant engage it standing still unless you have an OBD tool with mode 8 commands....or you can go to the ECU and ground out the correct wire to force it, but that is a pain and risky as you dont want to do that to the wrong wire in there and damage your ECU.
 
@dxwilson - Good luck and let us know what you hear back. FYI as a last resort the resistor method would turn off the CEL but I'm not sure how the CA emission game works or if they would notice it. To accurately test the EGR system they would need to get the vehicle to 50mph for a certain time as @RyRoRyan mentioned which seems unlikely.
 
Thanks, everyone, for your help. I picked up my truck on Friday. The mechanic was stuck, he had replaced the ECR and and vacuum switching valve, replaced a bazillion leaky vacuum hoses, and cleaned out all the ports. The EGR vacuum modulator and the EGR temperature sensors were testing correct so he didn't really want to swap them. He said that the vacuum switching valve was not getting an electrical signal to tell it to switch, and he thought it was probably the computer, but spare test computers are not common to borrow.

The CEL was off when I left the shop. I brought it home, replaced the vacuum modulator and the EGR temperature sensor for lack of any better ideas. I drove it a few miles at 55 mph, went to the smog shop and it passed.

My guess is the modulator and/or temperature sensor weren't working right even when the tests indicated they were. The modulator had been taken apart at least a couple times and cleaned in the past, and it was the original green top, so I figured it couldn't hurt to replace. Or maybe it was a gremlin that finally decided to leave. Either way, I pass smog now so I can move on to things like fixing my alignment...
 
Back
Top Bottom