Options for engine swap

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 3, 2015
Threads
20
Messages
571
Location
Lower Alabama
Need some advice before I start the big engine rebuild. My 97 threw at least one rod bearing, may have more damage below once I get her pulled apart. My biggest concern is the crank condition.

The current plan was to tear mine down and send out the crank if needed and have the head reworked. Then these two came up.

Options for donor engines
1) 180k miles, no oil pans, accessories, sensors, oil pump, manifolds, valves, or valve springs. Nothing extra, no valve cover, Not protected but kept in shop. Removed from truck bc of a "tick"-$500

2) 289k miles, includes everything except for one emissions device. Includes manifolds, shields, brackets, everything. Was running when removed. $1200

So question is, which way would cause less pain and $ but provide the most reliability?
Thanks for the advice.
 
The second one ... For the price of the first

Sorry but neither of those seem that appealing to me. Sure deals come and go but I sold a running motor with the same mileage no tick and all accessories for 500.

1st seems like a lot of missing pieces. Granted you have most the pieces you have on your motor but then it comes down to the tick. Could have been the power steering maybe. Maybe not. Hard to diagnose now

Second is a lot of miles for 1200 dollars and probably needs a rebuild before too long; or maybe not but it's an old motor to be throwing in without addressing some issues

Motor Rebuild using your resources here and I your local market as well as supporting vendors should be estimated at 3500 I would think.
 
If it was me, and I've done this before, I would rebuild what I have. Only then do you truly know what you have because you know what's been done and what's in there.

You might get lucky and buy something else with zero issue but you never truly know what you have. That first little mysterious noise that none of us can guess on will have you wondering.....and wondering.

I guess a lot depends on budget ? Doing it the 'right way' and dealing with all the 'while I'm in there' items can push your budget.
 
You don't need the shields, manifolds, etc. I'd offer $700 and a case of his favorite beer. Work from there.

I agree, you don't want that other engine.

Is the one you found OBD2? That makes a big difference in my opinion.

There's lots of room to overbore, and the high mileage one probably still has cross hatch marks on the cylinder walls. Rebuild it with overbore and new pistons unless the ones in it look good, and they actually might.

I want to get over there and listen to it before you tear it down, but that probably won't happen. Do you have any video of how bad it ran? A thrown rod is pretty much a trashed engine I'd think.

Good luck!
 
Back
Top Bottom