Open/closed loop annoyances

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 5, 2005
Threads
116
Messages
1,273
Location
Calgary
I have been paying close attention to when my cruiser goes open loop. My motivation has been based on landtanks maf and mileage concerns. I recently took a 6 hour round trip from Calgary to Edmonton and back (about 372 miles) and that trip surprised me in that my truck went open loop at 23-35%tps on slight inclines. Even in town I have occasionally made it go into open loop without going wot. For example rounding a corner at about 25kph and 33tps.

My first response to this weird behaviour was to change both o2 sensors. This however, netted no change in behaviour. Now my overactive imagination is thinking its the sc doing this because the ecu cant react quickly enough to the added air. Applying simple bottle neck reasoning I feel that the problem lies in the maf, intake air temp sensor (sc heats the air), and/or the o2 sensors.

Anyone have any feedback for me?

Karl
 
I have been paying close attention to when my cruiser goes open loop. My motivation has been based on landtanks maf and mileage concerns. I recently took a 6 hour round trip from Calgary to Edmonton and back (about 372 miles) and that trip surprised me in that my truck went open loop at 23-35%tps on slight inclines. Even in town I have occasionally made it go into open loop without going wot. For example rounding a corner at about 25kph and 33tps.

My first response to this weird behaviour was to change both o2 sensors. This however, netted no change in behaviour. Now my overactive imagination is thinking its the sc doing this because the ecu cant react quickly enough to the added air. Applying simple bottle neck reasoning I feel that the problem lies in the maf, intake air temp sensor (sc heats the air), and/or the o2 sensors.

Anyone have any feedback for me?

Karl

I don't have a scangauge, so I don't know what mine is doing and I have only had my S/C installed for less than 40 miles. I did some extensive reading on the landtank MAF threads and I was convinced that I should go ahead and purchase one. I'll have to see if it makes a difference in mileage after I install it since that is the only reference I can provide right now. The data seems to show that his MAF will help the engine stay in closed loop.
 
I have both the supercharger and landtanks MAF and monitor by scanguage as well. I did notice after installing the new MAF it was easier for my vehicle to achieve open loop scenarios.

i think you may be right about the ecu not being able to read the amount of air flowed. i havent correlated it to tps so ill have to play around this weekend on a trip to the mtns.
 
Switching between open and closed loop has to do with the amount of fuel the ECU is metering. It will be early in the RPM band if you are in a low altitude cool environment than in a high altitude hot one. It's not surprising to see my MAF trigger this earlier as it's letting more air in at lower RPMs which requires more fuel as well.

It's just part of the how feed back circuit's work. As the volume of fuel increases the % or error decreases and becomes unmanageable through the feed back control. Remember these ECUs are using 13 year old technology and they are only as fast as they were back then. That and narrow band O2 sensors really don't provide a high enough resolution to make accurate decisions at those higher volumes.
 
Karl,
It sounds like you are monitoring TPS and Open/Closed Loop mode with the Scangauge. Have you tried monitoring Short Term Fuel Trim too? It's slightly more complicated because you have to enter a small program into the Scangauge using the XGAUGE feature. I'm wondering how STFT changes with Rick's MAF. I should be able to provide feedback on this myself in a few weeks if no one posts up before then.
 
You have to decode bits from one of the PIDs to get the fuel system status. PID 03 is the one you want, which returns 2 bytes. The bits in the first byte are set as follows (only one bit should ever be set):
A0 Open loop due to insufficient engine temperature
A1 Closed loop, using oxygen sensor feedback to determine fuel mix
A2 Open loop due to engine load
A3 Open loop due to system failure
A4 Closed loop, using at least one oxygen sensor but there is a fault in the feedback system
A5-A7 Always zero
 
You might also track/log your engine load.

I have a SGII, Rick's MAF, and new O2 sensors. I have only seen mine go into Open Loop when load is >60% and RPM is above 3550. Of course, the other time is WOT.

I did a bunch of testing going over passes (long periods of high load), and varying the throttle position made no difference. Neither did gear (except when the gear forced the RPM over the threshold).

Edit: I live at 7,300 feet
 
Last edited:
You might also track/log your engine load.

I have a SGII, Rick's MAF, and new O2 sensors. I have only seen mine go into Open Loop when load is >60% and RPM is above 3550. Of course, the other time is WOT.

I did a bunch of testing going over passes (long periods of high load), and varying the throttle position made no difference. Neither did gear (except when the gear forced the RPM over the threshold).

Edit: I live at 7,300 feet

Haven't you ordered a Supercharger yet? I figured we'd hear from you as soon as we got those suckers in at AmToy!

;)

-o-
 
Haven't you ordered a Supercharger yet? I figured we'd hear from you as soon as we got those suckers in at AmToy!

;)

-o-

Beno,

Any Idea how many superchargers are left in the US from this "limited run."
 
Landtank: I am using the stock MAF. Perhaps I have a strange understanding of the ECU. As I understand it, when the ecu flips to open loop loop is is using a look up table base on MAP, IAT, and RPM to specifiy fuel. In closed loop it relies (mostly) on the o2 sensors to specify the fuel that need to be delivered. I think you made a comment sometime ago that was quite important. You mentioned that at high rpm the MAF gets saturated, and at low rpm it does not have the resolution to accurately monitor fuel trim at idle. My interest in observing closed and open loop status was to convince myself to try your maf; kinda a understand before you buy approach. This is not to say I doubt anyones observations, I just wanna understand first.

TricktT: Correct I have been using my scangauge, but have not programmed in STFT. I will try this ASAP. Unfortunately, I have no software to log data, so my results will be biased by my observations. I understand part of the bits and byte thing you are trying to get at. These are the the codes that the SCII ecu spits out and that I might be able to program my SCII to read, but I dont know the scalars I need to get to the required address locations in the ecu. I need to see if these are posted at the SCII website. Thanks for posting the codes that would cause open loop. I have been thinking on the engine load. Perhaps the SC screws with the engine load calc and because it is running more efficiently under the SC that equations in the ecu are no longer valid.

Hants. Elevation is important in all this. My elevation (Calgary) is 1170m (3800ft) Edmonton is at 668 M (2191.6ft). At 33%TPS, I was at 2600ish rpm, and at open loop, climbing a shallow hill, overdrive on, and running around 125kph (77mph).

I have not checked my mileage. part of the reason for this is that I dont want to know - ignorance is bliss isnt it?

I wonder if the newer maf and ecu (south american maf) are compatible with our remaining sensors and if one could swap them out.

Karl
 
In closed loop the ECU adjusts the STFT% from readings it sees from the front O2 sensor. This is done continuously while in that state. What we saw was a 2-3% fluctuation around 0% as we drove.

Open loop this does not happen and then the fuel is metered based on the MAF sensor and the LTFT% calculated during closed loop to calculate the injector duty cycle. The O2 sensor is still active but is no longer in the mix for determining the injector duty cycle.

When the MAF gets saturated it no longer shows and increase in air flow but the ECU knows different as the RPMs are still climbing. This causes a fault in the system just as any bad sensor would and the ECU then shuts down some of the sensors and defaults to a predetermined metering scheme which results in a very rich condition.
 
...TrickyT: Correct I have been using my scangauge, but have not programmed in STFT. I will try this ASAP. Unfortunately, I have no software to log data, so my results will be biased by my observations. I understand part of the bits and byte thing you are trying to get at. These are the the codes that the SCII ecu spits out and that I might be able to program my SCII to read, but I dont know the scalars I need to get to the required address locations in the ecu. I need to see if these are posted at the SCII website...

Karl,
There's a PDF document on the ScanGauge web site that describes how to program your gauge for STFT. It's here: www.scangauge.com/support/pdfs/XGAUGE.pdf

You want Short Term Fuel Trim Bank 1, in the section for ISO and VPW type vehicles. Readout should be in percentage, so no need to scale the values.

I need to try doing this myself, hopefully tonight or tomorrow.
 
Back
Top Bottom