slosurfer. I like your idea but like any other HID retrofit you defeat the hours of lens and beam development put in by the manufacture of your lights. I think it'd be cool on cheaper lights maybe but not expensive Lightforces.
The area of light creation for an HID bulb is not in the area that the light manufature intended it to be. (There is way more trouble than you think in creating lenses) To your eyes there may be no beam distortion and the increased light output might be an acceptable trade off. You're better off buying true HID lights since the lenses and beam pattern have been formed for an HID bulb.
I understand what you are saying and I did a ton of research on this so that I could be very close.
1. I am no where near the first one to do this, others (mainly in australia) have been doing this for awhile and got the experimenting out of the way. They figured out that the H3 HID bulb puts the source of the light the closest to where the original source of light was.
2. Lightforce uses the same reflector for their HID and Halogens. The 240XGT is the same exact housing/reflector as the 240XGT HID. At this time those are the only HID's they offer, but they will be coming out with the smaller sized ones here soon. We'll see how close the reflectors are when these come out.
3. They made these lights to be very adaptable. For instance, there are many different options for bulbs, not just different watts or 12v/24v, but vertical or horizontal filaments depending on what you want your light to do best. So they were not made to just except one bulb with one type of filament.
4. They are adjustable, therefore if you have the source of light real close to where the original was then you can fine tune it by turning the reflector.
5. My pencil beam with the HID is way better than it was with the halogen. I have a spare 170 that is still stock that I have done side by side tests with, not just comparing photos or "remembering" what they used to look like.
We also did an impromptu comparison test on a recent run between my HID 170 and a 240XGT 100watt halogen and it was pretty much agreed that the spot from my 170 was pretty equal to the spot from the 240XGT as they were shining on a far off mountain. My spare 170 actually came from this guy and he was really impressed with what my HID 170's were doing, and in fact now he is going to be adding HID to one of his 240XGT's.
6. I don't think I defeated their hours of R&D, I think I used it to my advantage.
7. The guy in australia where I got most my info from, has compared his 240Blitz with a 35watt HID with that of a true LF 240XGT HID and lets just say that the owner of the 240XGT HID was pissed that he spent that much more money for the same effect.
8. The $$ I spent on my setup is no where near what I would have to spend to get a comparable setup of true HID's that had as much versatility. Especially considering my whole setup (other than the HID kit) was all bought used or secondhand NIB for really good deals.
That all being said, I don't know if I could go buy a brand new set of LF's with the intention of tearing them apart to make them better (I don't have the money for it), but if you already have them (or find a set used) and want more out of them or want to give your charging system a break, then why not.
In fact, isn't that what the majority of us are doing here anyway, buying an expensive landcruiser and then drilling and welding and cutting on it to make it better (or are we just defeating the hours of R&D that Toyota put into our vehicles)?
My main point for bringing these up in the first place to the OP, was to show the versatility of the Lightforces and that you could use less lights to get the same effect. And to show that HID retros in aux. lighting are a feasable possibility whether it be Hellas, KC's, IPF, Lightforces, etc... Heck, if I didn't already have the LF's, I probably would have gone with the costo IPFs and some Hellas and HID'd them, if for anything to save my charging system till I get a bigger alternator (in the works) and eventually dual batteries (no place under the hood for a second batter with the darn 3.slo).