OBDII reader or cable?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 10, 2006
Threads
115
Messages
948
Location
Bonsall, CA
Hello

I am wondering whether it is better to buy an OBD2 reader or maybe a cable to connect to a laptop.

My problem is that I can't read the codes anywhere where I live. Toyota dealers haven't got readers for american versions so when I plug my LX450 they just see nothing. I have just bought the Lex and I have CEL so I want to get rid of it ASAP.

My only solution is Ebay, but all the auctions are virtually the same. No matter what you click in the $50 range, you get the same options. Is this true? Are $50 readers any good or cr#p?

My other option is a cable (which costs around $30) and connects to the serial port in a laptop. It gives the additional options of reading detailed live information, which helps much better to determine if a sensor is working or maybe becoming dead. But has anyone downloaded the free software and connected it to a Lex? Does it work? I heard that the Lex has an early version of OBD2 and many functions are missing?

I am really confused because I have no help from any local people as they don't know the car at all.

OK, to cut it short... What should I buy? Cable or reader?

Thanks in advance for your replies, you're my only help :doh:
 
I am really confused because I have no help from any local people as they don't know the car at all.

Yes, Mike, you are really confused.

Start by reading up on OBD-II readers/scan tools here on 'Mud and with Google. There is a LOT of information available.

I will clarify a couple of your misconceptions:

1. The LX450 (available 1996 & 1997 in US) is fully OBD-II compliant.

2. The "Toyota Scan Tool" is not exactly an OBD-II scan tool. It is a specific device engineered by Toyota for doing advanced diagnostics on Toyotas. It may or may not work on an LX; I don't know.

3. There are no $30 OBD-II scanner cables that I know of. The reason is that there needs to be another device that converts OBD-II signals to RS-232 serial signals. I don't think this can be done with a cable and the inexpensive scan tools that come with the "black-box" decoder, plus the OBD-II/RS232 cable, plus the ODB-II software are ~$150 and up (way up!)

4. The OBD-II readers are relatively inexpensive (~$50) and will pull the code(s) and display them and give you the option of clearing the codes. You would then need to reference a manual (like the FSM) to tell you what the code is and how to "fix" the problem.

5. OBD-II is a US specification so it is unlikely that European mechanics are going to help you with this. The good news is that the US government mandated the adoption of this spec and the equipping of vehicles sold in the US. The primary function of OBD-II is to notify you of emission systems failures. That being said, you can find out a lot of other important data from the OBD-II data such as individual cylinder misfires and cooling system temps.

You asked to give you a recommendation and my recommendation would be to buy a moderately priced OBD-II scan tool that connects to a notebook PC or a PDA (or both.) About 5 years ago, I selected the Harrison R&D scan tool (<$200) with software for PC and Palm PDA.

-B-
 
Last edited:
I ended up with Autoenginuity which is similar to what -B- has. There is a bunch of free software out there for this, you just need the interface cable. I haven't researched this in like 4 years so I can't make a good recommendation oyther than to say be care what you buy to make sure it will work for you.
 
I use this:

http://www.auterraweb.com

I am pleased with it but have no experience with other solutions.

I found it most useful to monitor coolant temperatures when I was playing with my modifications to the temperature gauge mod.
 
Mike,
IMHO, those links you posted are tools for computer hobbyists. If you are a strong low-level computer guy then I'm sure you can have a lot of fun making those things work. Personally, I am intrigued and probably would have purchased the one in that 1st eBay auction had it been available when I was looking.

However, for the masses, those tools look inappropriate to me. I would recommend for most guys on this forum to seek out a commercial product, supplied by a vendor that is likely to be around in a few years, and attempt to select a product that will be upgraded/upgradeable. I would also check out the software they supply as it is more important than the "black box" used to connect to the vehicle's OBD-II port.

My 2c.

-B-
 
I use a cheap reader, borrowed but cost the guy about $50. Pulls the codes and clears them. My CEL came on, I borrowed the reader, got the code and came to this site to get some troubleshooting info that helped me fix it. Go for the cheap one if you just want to read & reset the codes it will work fine. Plenty of info here to help you fix it once you get the codes.
 
So what is the protocol for Toyota and what is the protocol for the 450?

In 1996 and 1997, the LX450 and the Toyota Land Cruiser will use the same protocol. I'll have to look it up and post back but simply saying "ISO" doesn't tell you enough.

I'll be back in a minute....

Your LX450 (and all US 80-Series built in 1996 & 1997) is ISO-9141-2
It appears common to abbreviate this standard as ISO (vs PWM, CAN, VPW)

See this reference.

-B-
 
Last edited:
I have to add that there are no guarantees in this business--especially on the "less expensive" tools.

I too have the Harrison unit and love it, and while it works quite well, there are some peculiarities. For example, it works well on my '97 Cruiser, and my '02 Sypder, but on my wife's '01 Avalon, it has serious issues (it doesn't even register that there's a car on the other end). The owner of the company (Dan) is a good guy and tries to help, but be aware that in the low-cost solutions, you many be part of the beta testing...
 
Let's just say it's told me everything I ever wanted to know about it. :flipoff2:
 
I just set up the Pro Scan Software and scanner I mentioned in my post above. I did some on-line reading and assumed my '97 cruiser was ISO, it is NOT. Looking at the pins it is VPW and now I have to send back the ISO tool and just pony up for the little more expensive universal reader. But so far the software looks pretty nice and if the reader works, it should work out nicely.
 
Hmmm.... You've got me confused a bit. Can someone actually confirm the protocol for the 1996 LX? I have assumed it is ISO-9141-2 basing on Beowulf's post. Imagine that I was going to buy the ISO scanner when suddenly the post of Bear80 appeared (virtually seconds separated me from the purchase). Now I don't know what to do again.

I planned to buy an ELM323 interface cable which supports IS0 9141-2 and 14230-4 (KWP 2000). $75

Buying an ELM327 interface cable which supports all protocols is out of the question due to the price, $150.

Does anybody have both a '96 LX450 and a cable, and could confirm the transmission protocol? I really need a cable as nobody is able to read my codes here and I can't drive forever with CEL on, not knowing what the problem is.
 
Below is the pinout of the socket in my LX450, I've just checked it.

This looks like J1850 VPW standard, according to this site:
http://www.mymp3car.com/MP3Car/obdII pinout.html

Correct me if I'm wrong...
OBD2-pinout-for-LX450.gif
 
I have the laptop version mentioned by Bear80, the universal $150 version, I've used it on many cars. The latest software version doesn't work on my BMW, so I'm using the previous version. They keep updating the software, which I get free with my original purchase, so I'm not worried. I like being able to watch various parameters real-time, and it's nice to be able to post the graphs here when asking for help or helping someone else.

Here's a post with a graph, some more links to other graphs I've posted.
https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=123722
 
I planned to buy an ELM323 interface cable which supports IS0 9141-2 and 14230-4 (KWP 2000). $75

Buying an ELM327 interface cable which supports all protocols is out of the question due to the price, $150.

For the price and your case I'd just buy the VPW for the $90. I'm going to up to the universal since I'll at minimum pay return shipping and shipping on the correct unit and I have other Toyotas and I won't be happy if they are ISO.
 
I highly recommend the BR-3 scan tool and cable if you already have a laptop. The software is free and you can cobble together the bits to make your own cable; or buy one off their website.

It runs on Windows, and I had it running under Wine on Suse Linux 10, I'm going to try it here soon on Ubuntu 6.10.

More than just codes, this s/w will give you real time sensor data and engine characteristics - see Dan's article linked above. It's pretty amazing open source software.
 
Back
Top Bottom