Hey all..... posting this for insight and also what I'm doing/will do...
Having a very random starter issue....
I've read through this and while it's similar, it's also dissimilar:
Electrical dilemma
This has happened 2 times - use the vehicle as normal (last time this happened the vehicle had been sitting for 4 days, started/drove without issue - and then coming back to it, it had issues), come out to the vehicle, and the starter won't kick over (by this I mean, the starter does nothing).
I assume the NSS is working fine - because when this happens, there is an apparent load on the system (you can see the stock volt meter drop a bit, not a lot, but a bit). If you put the car in R or any drive gears, there is no 'load' on the system. The load but no click from the starter happens both in P or N.
The first time we thought one of the dogs had jumped onto the LED light bar switch and drained the battery - a jump start and it was perfectly fine to start and drive home. (That was about a month ago)
There were some other wiring issues in the car that I've gone through and cleaned up/fixed, but the starter wire only had a change to the end connector. A big one is I, for the 2nd time, changed the battery terminals due to corrosion along with added a new ground to the fender (4ga), along with removed/fixed some of the "spider webbing" toyota does from stock on their power systems, and reran wiring to the fuse panel on an installed stud.
I have an aftermarket voltmeter (which is unfortunately tied to the cig lighter - and in 'STA' shuts off, so I wasn't able to see the cranking voltage), but while driving the voltmeter usually reads 14.2-14.6. A tad low and has been a bit of a concern. While attempting to crank I could see the voltage was at 12.4.
I thought the battery was bad - primarily because of the corrosion and also because when you tighten the clamp, the terminal is still loose (just a tad - but by this I mean the lug in the battery has the ability to move the terminal, rotationally, about 1/16" or so).
So - I got a new 750CCA battery (turned out to be slightly low, but measured good at about 80% charge) and connected the new battery (via good 2ga jumper cables) with negative to the engine and positive directly to the starter terminal (it had a large terminal that I could connect directly to). No change, nothing.
Banged on the starter (even though gear reducted.... ya know, just cause)..... no change.
Get a friend to jump us - and at first nothing.... but then when I revved their engine, it fired up no problem.
Now - I understand the first consensus is going to be "battery".... but given that I was trying to jump from a new battery tells me that may not be the case....
I'm concerned that something is going on in the NSS or something else in the sta circuit that requires a higher voltage (due to old age or corrosion).
Replacing the engine main ground with a 36" 4ga cable (there was a bit of green corrosion on the end of the block side, but otherwise it 'looked' ok).
Replacing the starter main power with a 42" 2ga cable, just to ensure the cable is good and both ends have a good, solid connection.
Pulling the starter and will take it to a local company where they can do a load / bench test (they claim at 6 different speeds) for me.... and see how that turns out.
Will probably replace the battery with the new one I already bought, just to be "safe".
I'm also considering installing a firewall mounted solenoid and jumpering the main power/solenoid on the starter, then rewiring the stock solenoid wiring to the firewall solenoid.... this way if it happens again, I can simply turn the key to 'on' and jumper the firewall solenoid easily and be on my way (and if it continually happens, install a start button to bypass the stock STA circuit)
Having a very random starter issue....
I've read through this and while it's similar, it's also dissimilar:
Electrical dilemma
This has happened 2 times - use the vehicle as normal (last time this happened the vehicle had been sitting for 4 days, started/drove without issue - and then coming back to it, it had issues), come out to the vehicle, and the starter won't kick over (by this I mean, the starter does nothing).
I assume the NSS is working fine - because when this happens, there is an apparent load on the system (you can see the stock volt meter drop a bit, not a lot, but a bit). If you put the car in R or any drive gears, there is no 'load' on the system. The load but no click from the starter happens both in P or N.
The first time we thought one of the dogs had jumped onto the LED light bar switch and drained the battery - a jump start and it was perfectly fine to start and drive home. (That was about a month ago)
There were some other wiring issues in the car that I've gone through and cleaned up/fixed, but the starter wire only had a change to the end connector. A big one is I, for the 2nd time, changed the battery terminals due to corrosion along with added a new ground to the fender (4ga), along with removed/fixed some of the "spider webbing" toyota does from stock on their power systems, and reran wiring to the fuse panel on an installed stud.
I have an aftermarket voltmeter (which is unfortunately tied to the cig lighter - and in 'STA' shuts off, so I wasn't able to see the cranking voltage), but while driving the voltmeter usually reads 14.2-14.6. A tad low and has been a bit of a concern. While attempting to crank I could see the voltage was at 12.4.
I thought the battery was bad - primarily because of the corrosion and also because when you tighten the clamp, the terminal is still loose (just a tad - but by this I mean the lug in the battery has the ability to move the terminal, rotationally, about 1/16" or so).
So - I got a new 750CCA battery (turned out to be slightly low, but measured good at about 80% charge) and connected the new battery (via good 2ga jumper cables) with negative to the engine and positive directly to the starter terminal (it had a large terminal that I could connect directly to). No change, nothing.
Banged on the starter (even though gear reducted.... ya know, just cause)..... no change.
Get a friend to jump us - and at first nothing.... but then when I revved their engine, it fired up no problem.
Now - I understand the first consensus is going to be "battery".... but given that I was trying to jump from a new battery tells me that may not be the case....
I'm concerned that something is going on in the NSS or something else in the sta circuit that requires a higher voltage (due to old age or corrosion).
Replacing the engine main ground with a 36" 4ga cable (there was a bit of green corrosion on the end of the block side, but otherwise it 'looked' ok).
Replacing the starter main power with a 42" 2ga cable, just to ensure the cable is good and both ends have a good, solid connection.
Pulling the starter and will take it to a local company where they can do a load / bench test (they claim at 6 different speeds) for me.... and see how that turns out.
Will probably replace the battery with the new one I already bought, just to be "safe".
I'm also considering installing a firewall mounted solenoid and jumpering the main power/solenoid on the starter, then rewiring the stock solenoid wiring to the firewall solenoid.... this way if it happens again, I can simply turn the key to 'on' and jumper the firewall solenoid easily and be on my way (and if it continually happens, install a start button to bypass the stock STA circuit)