NSS and starter circuit

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 27, 2013
Threads
70
Messages
1,225
Location
Sedro Woolley, WA
Hey all..... posting this for insight and also what I'm doing/will do...

Having a very random starter issue....

I've read through this and while it's similar, it's also dissimilar:
Electrical dilemma

This has happened 2 times - use the vehicle as normal (last time this happened the vehicle had been sitting for 4 days, started/drove without issue - and then coming back to it, it had issues), come out to the vehicle, and the starter won't kick over (by this I mean, the starter does nothing).

I assume the NSS is working fine - because when this happens, there is an apparent load on the system (you can see the stock volt meter drop a bit, not a lot, but a bit). If you put the car in R or any drive gears, there is no 'load' on the system. The load but no click from the starter happens both in P or N.

The first time we thought one of the dogs had jumped onto the LED light bar switch and drained the battery - a jump start and it was perfectly fine to start and drive home. (That was about a month ago)

There were some other wiring issues in the car that I've gone through and cleaned up/fixed, but the starter wire only had a change to the end connector. A big one is I, for the 2nd time, changed the battery terminals due to corrosion along with added a new ground to the fender (4ga), along with removed/fixed some of the "spider webbing" toyota does from stock on their power systems, and reran wiring to the fuse panel on an installed stud.

I have an aftermarket voltmeter (which is unfortunately tied to the cig lighter - and in 'STA' shuts off, so I wasn't able to see the cranking voltage), but while driving the voltmeter usually reads 14.2-14.6. A tad low and has been a bit of a concern. While attempting to crank I could see the voltage was at 12.4.

I thought the battery was bad - primarily because of the corrosion and also because when you tighten the clamp, the terminal is still loose (just a tad - but by this I mean the lug in the battery has the ability to move the terminal, rotationally, about 1/16" or so).

So - I got a new 750CCA battery (turned out to be slightly low, but measured good at about 80% charge) and connected the new battery (via good 2ga jumper cables) with negative to the engine and positive directly to the starter terminal (it had a large terminal that I could connect directly to). No change, nothing.

Banged on the starter (even though gear reducted.... ya know, just cause)..... no change.

Get a friend to jump us - and at first nothing.... but then when I revved their engine, it fired up no problem.


Now - I understand the first consensus is going to be "battery".... but given that I was trying to jump from a new battery tells me that may not be the case....

I'm concerned that something is going on in the NSS or something else in the sta circuit that requires a higher voltage (due to old age or corrosion).

Replacing the engine main ground with a 36" 4ga cable (there was a bit of green corrosion on the end of the block side, but otherwise it 'looked' ok).

Replacing the starter main power with a 42" 2ga cable, just to ensure the cable is good and both ends have a good, solid connection.

Pulling the starter and will take it to a local company where they can do a load / bench test (they claim at 6 different speeds) for me.... and see how that turns out.

Will probably replace the battery with the new one I already bought, just to be "safe".

I'm also considering installing a firewall mounted solenoid and jumpering the main power/solenoid on the starter, then rewiring the stock solenoid wiring to the firewall solenoid.... this way if it happens again, I can simply turn the key to 'on' and jumper the firewall solenoid easily and be on my way (and if it continually happens, install a start button to bypass the stock STA circuit)
 
Hey all..... posting this for insight and also what I'm doing/will do...

Having a very random starter issue....

I've read through this and while it's similar, it's also dissimilar:
Electrical dilemma

This has happened 2 times - use the vehicle as normal (last time this happened the vehicle had been sitting for 4 days, started/drove without issue - and then coming back to it, it had issues), come out to the vehicle, and the starter won't kick over (by this I mean, the starter does nothing).

I assume the NSS is working fine - because when this happens, there is an apparent load on the system (you can see the stock volt meter drop a bit, not a lot, but a bit). If you put the car in R or any drive gears, there is no 'load' on the system. The load but no click from the starter happens both in P or N.

The first time we thought one of the dogs had jumped onto the LED light bar switch and drained the battery - a jump start and it was perfectly fine to start and drive home. (That was about a month ago)

There were some other wiring issues in the car that I've gone through and cleaned up/fixed, but the starter wire only had a change to the end connector. A big one is I, for the 2nd time, changed the battery terminals due to corrosion along with added a new ground to the fender (4ga), along with removed/fixed some of the "spider webbing" toyota does from stock on their power systems, and reran wiring to the fuse panel on an installed stud.

I have an aftermarket voltmeter (which is unfortunately tied to the cig lighter - and in 'STA' shuts off, so I wasn't able to see the cranking voltage), but while driving the voltmeter usually reads 14.2-14.6. A tad low and has been a bit of a concern. While attempting to crank I could see the voltage was at 12.4.

I thought the battery was bad - primarily because of the corrosion and also because when you tighten the clamp, the terminal is still loose (just a tad - but by this I mean the lug in the battery has the ability to move the terminal, rotationally, about 1/16" or so).

So - I got a new 750CCA battery (turned out to be slightly low, but measured good at about 80% charge) and connected the new battery (via good 2ga jumper cables) with negative to the engine and positive directly to the starter terminal (it had a large terminal that I could connect directly to). No change, nothing.

Banged on the starter (even though gear reducted.... ya know, just cause)..... no change.

Get a friend to jump us - and at first nothing.... but then when I revved their engine, it fired up no problem.


Now - I understand the first consensus is going to be "battery".... but given that I was trying to jump from a new battery tells me that may not be the case....

I'm concerned that something is going on in the NSS or something else in the sta circuit that requires a higher voltage (due to old age or corrosion).

Replacing the engine main ground with a 36" 4ga cable (there was a bit of green corrosion on the end of the block side, but otherwise it 'looked' ok).

Replacing the starter main power with a 42" 2ga cable, just to ensure the cable is good and both ends have a good, solid connection.

Pulling the starter and will take it to a local company where they can do a load / bench test (they claim at 6 different speeds) for me.... and see how that turns out.

Will probably replace the battery with the new one I already bought, just to be "safe".

I'm also considering installing a firewall mounted solenoid and jumpering the main power/solenoid on the starter, then rewiring the stock solenoid wiring to the firewall solenoid.... this way if it happens again, I can simply turn the key to 'on' and jumper the firewall solenoid easily and be on my way (and if it continually happens, install a start button to bypass the stock STA circuit)

Have you checked power to the clip that attaches to the starter while attempting to start the LC? Just dealt with a similar issue myself and worked my way through just about the whole starting system.
 
No - both times it happened away from home and nowhere near tools..... the clip doesn't seem easy to get to (and doesn't follow the main power wire for the starter). I was able to get to the starter just fine with the wheel pulled and dust cover removed.

Starter is out - it's definitely original (302k miles). The bolts weren't terrible to get a socket/wrench onto (ended up having to use a variety of tools - bent box end, straight ratchet box end, 3/8 ratchet, 3/8 pry, 1/2 pry, 17mm 12 point shallow, 17mm 6 point deep - just to get the bolts loose due to them being so tight and having little area to move. The once the bolts were out, the starter didn't want to give way - there was corrosion on the lip of the starter where it meets the bellhousing - using a deadblow hammer didn't budge it and I ended up having to pry it out with a 30" prybar.

The cables are ready to go in - I haven't decided what to do about the signal wire yet...


I should add a couple other things..... I think there could be a problem with the NSS connector/harness - being that "D" doesn't display and I have this weird problem that if I go from P to D, it gets stuck in 3rd gear, but if I go P to L it's fine or if I go P to R (then move literally 6") then D, it drops into 1st.... and I have a feeling that has something to do with the NSS or harness.... with that all said, I wouldn't have a problem getting a new NSS if it wasn't $300+ for an offbrand unit, I can't even imagine what Toyota wants for it.
 
Took the starter in to be tested, basically was told they've never heard of an original starter going over 300k miles - and during testing it was identified that the contacts were bad.

Picked up a reman'd unit from them.

Also indicated that the positive post on the battery being loose, at all, means that the seal had been broken, and would highly contribute to the corrosion on the terminals (though didn't say why, my guess is due to venting?)

I've also ordered a momentary switch and a DPST starter solenoid - this way I can rewire the truck to run the aftermarket solenoid off of the stock STA circuit, or I can use the momentary switch if something in there fails. I'll do this by running a 2GA battery cable from battery to aftermarket solenoid, then other end of the solenoid to the starter. At the starter, the solenoid wire will be jumpered directly to the main post on the starter. The 2 terminals on the firewall solenoid will have the stock STA circuit on one and the momentary switch on the other - this way the firewall solenoid will only provide power to the starter (and solenoid) when either the 'STA' circuit is hit or the momentary switch is hit. When I was wiring the FJ40 I was having issues with the 350/th350 starter killing fuses when wired to the starter solenoid, so I went this method and have had zero issues (plus I don't have that large gauge power wire down low active all the time).

(As a side note - with this being a 1993 and having an AFM, I'm almost 100% positive the NSS and circuit opening relay systems are working, because I didn't mention this earlier, but when the vehicle wouldn't start, I could hear something happening.... it didn't click in my brain until later that I was hearing the fuel pump kick on, since an AFM system has a fuel pump prime system that kicks on when the key is set to 'start' and doesn't care whether it sees an ignition event.... which is what I believe the map systems do now)
 
Had to replace my NSS when I had intermittent starting issues at few years back. You must be able to bypass the NSS to determine if it is the cause. I think I ended up doing that on my 97 while waiting for a new NSS I ordered from RockAuto. I would also recommend keeping the wiring stock. FWIW, the more you fool around with alternate "solutions" the further you will be from addressing the real issue.
 
This was copied from an old VW starter upgrade. Is done with a Ford starter solenoid. I did this when I bought my truck in 2009. To this date, never fails. One thing I carry on my other truck is a pick handle. I use it to beat on the starter when it clicks but wont turn. Another old trick.

Puerquito 2.webp
Puerquito diagram.webp
 
This seems to be a recurring theme ;)
The starter circuit is very simple.
The logic side of the starter solenoid: battery positive terminal; fusible link AM1; fuse AM1; ignition switch; neutral start switch; starter solenoid.
The load side of the starter motor is a direct connection to the battery positive terminal.

The fact that you have a loose battery terminal should be a full stop for you. Address that first.

Hooking up a battery to the larger of the 2 terminals on the starter will do NOTHING. That terminal is always a direct connection to the positive battery terminal and has nothing to do with starter logic. The small clip on wire on the side of the starter is the solenoid logic. That is supposed to go +12 when the ignition switch is in the START position.

On another note, if you replaced your starter with a non-OEM unit, you're going to get very good at replacing starters.
 
Back
Top Bottom