Non namebrand winch ?'s

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 26, 2002
Threads
215
Messages
994
Location
WI
Looking to get a winch for the front of my next buildup. Had Warns in the past and had no issues at all with them. Always seemed to get me out of whatever I got myself into.

Anyways cruising around the net, I found a atlas 12000 winch. I have never heard anything about it, but the specs seem inline or comparable to a warn. Also I found a Magnum 9000 lb winch that supposedly is made by warn. Seems like good specs. Anyone out there try either one or know of someone that has had one? Any good bad uglys about either?
 
from what I've heard, most manuf's put out "no name" knockoffs.....

The Ramsey-clone at Harbor Freight is notorious for needing the motor replaced.

IMO, spend the $$ right the first time and purchase something you know works well....the time you REALLY need the winch is the time the cheapie will fail you....
 
Look into T-Max winches.... seem to be decent quality without breaking the bank. Maybe "SpaceGhost" could offer more first hand info, he uses one on his competition rig. I haven't installed mine yet, but it seems to be well made, (I took it apart to see the quality off the internal pieces, looks very much like Warn.). Luke
 
Buy the cheapest thing you can find.! Cheaper is always awesome.. COMEON!
I've found that by the time I need a winch, it's well worth whatever I've paid for the thing.. Heck usually worth more at that exact moment in time!
What are you going to save? $200 is it worth it when it goes snap crackle pop? Kinda like buying cheap toilet paper.. It's thinner, lighter, cheaper, more on that roll but the first time ya wipe and come back with poop on your hand, you'll never buy the cheap stuff again!..
 
tornadoalleycruiser said:
Kinda like buying cheap toilet paper.. It's thinner, lighter, cheaper, more on that roll but the first time ya wipe and come back with poop on your hand, you'll never buy the cheap stuff again!..

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahaha
 
Well this board sure has alot of experts lately.... :rolleyes:

All I asked has anyone used or heard of either of these winch's or had any experience with either.

No s***, you get what you pay for, I have had WARN's in the past on the numerous vehicles I have wheeled and I have liked them. I didn't say I was buying a winch tomorrow, just looking at the options of different winch's on the market without breaking the bank.

Thanks to those who gave some usefull feedback....
 
WHat are you using the winch for? Lots of winching in rocks or mud or once in awhile when you misjudge? Then by quality based on use. Milemarker is not too much $$$ and works fine every now and then. My Ramsey is a tank but cost more 15 years ago than the milemarker did two years ago. I place my winches based on use.
 
The winch is going to be used mainly for the mud. I probably will be using the winch at least once every time I go out (9 times out of 10 I run into someone stuck that does not have a winch and I will gladly pull them out). I am usually with a diverse group with many other vehicles that are heavier than my own. That is why I was looking at the 9000-12000 winch options. I came across a milemarker 12000 winch. Any good/bad's/uglys?
 
No experience with the larger milemarkers, but a buddy put the 8000 base unit on his rig and that thing is unbelieveably slow....

For an affordable HD winch, check the TMaxx units...someone on PBB (down now, check later) had them new for $750 or so for the 12,500# models....SpaceGhost runs the TMaxx on his comp rig and while he said the speed didn't compare to the Warn, it was a reliable unit.
 
Won a milemarker at a raffle once.. Traded it off to a buddy, his first time using it the soleniod blew and he had to replace it.. Food for thought.. But if you mount the soleniod box under the hood it would be better than in the elements. I think it worked great after that tho.. Might have been a fluke experience.. I never even mounted the winch.
 
Comparing the two, the T-max 11000 and the Milemarker 12000 are the same as far as spec wise. Price is prettty close on both as well. I think as far as the speed goes, the Warns have always been the faster ones on the market. When I got my 1st 8274 warn the PO said it didn't work. Ended up being the solenoids under the box. After those were reqired/replaced. The winch worked like a charm. I will search on pirate a lil bit when it comes back on line. Thanks
 
Back
Top Bottom