I had a good conversation with an engineer at AutoMeter a few years ago about this. He felt very strongly that mechanical gauges were much more accurate and reliable. The down side is they are harder to install, as the temp gauges use a thin capillary tube with a larger sender at the end, you can't open this connection. So, you end up drilling a larger hole in the firewall to get from the cab to the engine. You also are limited in the length of the tube, it can't be extended.
It was awhile ago, maybe things are different now.