Longfield vs Birfield eleminator

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

They still make a bifield eliminator?

Longs all the way, my old 40 is still on its first, first gen set. Going on 5 years.... Add to that I have always had good service and support from Bobby.....
 
From what I've found, the consensus has always been that the Longs were considerably stronger, not to mention cheaper in most cases. Doesn't the Warn kit use Dana 44 u-joints?
 
I've got the Eliminators. I think they are using the U-joints from the Dana 60. I have not had an issue with them in about 7 years.

However there are two things to concider with these:
1) I don't think Warn supports any of its LC products any more, which I find disturbing because I bought their front and rear rear axles and the XCL suspension, fully believing I was never going to have an expence in those areas again as long as I lived. Warn really had a good warrentee and outstanding customer service, and they are local to me.

2) The Longfields are a CV joint, the Eliminators are not. And the difference is noticable if you are used to the CV joint being there. When I go around a tight slow corner in four wheel drive, the Eliminators will lobe, birfields will run smooth. On some surfaces, smooth is a good thing.

If there is a CV joint that does not break, I would recommend you take that over a U-joint design.

gary
 
I've got the Eliminators. I think they are using the U-joints from the Dana 60. I have not had an issue with them in about 7 years.



It is not a 60 joint...it is a 44.

Warn made a claim, which was true, that the outer stub on the fing birfield eliminator kits were 30 spline, using the same one-ton lock out as a later stock Dana 60 front axle, however, that is where the one-ton/Dana 60 equivalent/comparison ends. The axles in that kit are equivalent to Dana 44, and use a Dana 44 u-joint.



I have not had an issue with them in about 7 years.




Gary,

You have to be one of the only folks out there running that front axle kit that has not had a failure. :beer:



I sold and installed at least a dozen of those kits, and as far as I know there are only three left in ‘limited service’. The rest have been removed after multiple failures and replaced with 30 spline longs, and since doing so, have worked flawlessly and not experienced a single failure.




I planning swaping my stock birfield, and i gatering info and feedback on both products!

Can you give me some feedback on both products!
Thanks




Go 30 spline longs and do not look back.




Brian,
Did you finally break 27spline chromo-longs?

inquiring minds want to know :p



A (pig/polyperformance) 27 spline chromo inner axle was broken on his truck, but the long did not fail.


:beer:




Again,



Go 30 spline longs and do not look back.



Good luck!


-Steve
 
Brian,
Did you finally break 27spline chromo-longs?

inquiring minds want to know :p

never ran them...

I did break a short side Poly Performance Gen2 4340 inner tho....IMO, the "necked down" theory behind that isn't "all that"....
 
look at it this way. if your on the trail and break the warn kit whats the odds someone has a spare warn shaft? where as i know in my group theres enough to build a whole front axle
 
I bought both the Warn front B/E & rear F/F kits quite a few years ago. I have never had a problem with the rear F/F, except for those damn hubs that split the innermost splined sleeve. As far as the B/E kit goes, that's another story. I have broken long and short side axles. The failure is always in the yoke, which also takes out the u-joint. I've also broken the front hubs in the same way as the rears. These are Warn's 1-ton hubs, whatever that means.

Now about Warn's customer service -
A++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Even though they no longer make these kits, they STILL DO REPLACE BROKEN PARTS - FREE!!!!!!
Warn has always replaced my broken axles & hubs without charge to me, except for the cost of postage sending back the broken part. And as long as they still have stock, they will continue to replace my axles. The hubs are a current-production item.
:bounce: :bounce2: :bounce: :bounce2:
 
personally i think alot of bobby longs birfs and axles and thats what i plan on using in my rig during my build up...when it finally begins so IMO i would put in the 30 spline longs and be done with it...
 
I bought both the Warn front B/E & rear F/F kits quite a few years ago. I have never had a problem with the rear F/F, except for those damn hubs that split the innermost splined sleeve.



30 spline chromo drive slugs will end this...


I now have 35 spline chromo drive slugs in the rear of my junk so that this will not happen again....


:beer:
Junk01.webp
Junk02.webp
 
Poser, thanks for the info about the longs. I do not have them in my cruiser yet but they are on the list. I have heard nothing but exactly what you said about them. Your links are a help to. I have a Currie high 9" and have been told to look out. When it goes, I now have a link for proper replacement.

Braden
 
had a lifetime warrantee with my PIG inners....it still sucks when you break, since you are replacing with stock stuff and then worried the rest of the weekend about breakage...

I run my 30 spline longs with NO steering stops...none....and still haven't broken them...anyone who saw me in the rock garden at camp during GSMTR will attest to my abusive driving ;)

the Long outers I run are the same ones that were installed when I broke the PIG inner...Bobby rebuilt them with 30-spline stars...even he mentioned how beat to crap they were....yet they don't break...
 
Back
Top Bottom