Knuckle Service - what went wrong?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Threads
79
Messages
417
Location
Calgary, AB.
Did the knuckle service on my wifes 81 about 2 months ago, just noticed they are wet around the bottom. Any ideas on what went wrong? I took my time and was sure everything was done properly and tourqued to spec... anyone else have this problem after a fresh knuckle service?
trucks 002.webp
trucks 003.webp
 
there are fresh drops of oil beading on the bottom of each of the 4 bolts on either side...
 
well, you hear about grease separating a bit sometimes (you did fill it with grease, not oil, right:)?)

if you have the torques right and new seals etc in the correct orientation, then it's probably a grease issue?


stick a screwdriver in the knuckle through the fill hole and see if the grease got soupy, a la damaged axleshaft seal...?
 
a la damaged axleshaft seal...?

That was my first thought...buggered up the inner axle seal when putting it back together.

The Marlin Crawler seals are far better than the OEM ones, and much less likely to be damaged.
 
yeah, I did use moly grease... guess I gotta check the inner seal, was worried about that.

just for the record I used Valvoline Special Moly EP grease...

I am darn near positive I didnt damage the new seals in any way when I did the job...
trucks 003.webp
 
sorry I meant to upload this pic of the grease I used
trucks.webp
 
That is probably normal. Mine look that way when I use the Vallvoline 985 synthetic. Pull one of the screw plugs and stick a wire in the knuckle and see what comes out. Also check the lower knuckle nuts an make sure they are tight.
 
thanks so much for the reply guys! I will be dipping in to check the contents, hopefully its not soupy. I am also going to recheck the bottom nuts. Thanks for the reply Dan.

I will post back the results!
 
That seepage is more consistant with the light oils in molly separating out.
 
well this sucks, I dipped into the knuckles and it seems to be pure grease, clean as the day I put it in. however the bottom is obviously moist with oil and the only place it would be coming from is the diff. so regardless I think its time to tear it apart. kinda weird how it is the same at both ends and not just one?
knuckles 002.webp
knuckles 004.webp
 
maybe I should spray it down with degreaser and clean them really well and see how long it really takes for the oil to appear?

would it be common for oil in the knuckle to settle and possibly i just didnt get to the bottom of the knuckle to pick up oil? I would think it would be mixed and soupy, my dip came out with pure grease...
 
If it were my truck I'd probably run it that way for a while and keep a close eye on it. If it gets worse, then tear it apart.
 
I was thinking of that... what does everyone else think?
 
If it were my truck I'd probably run it that way for a while and keep a close eye on it. If it gets worse, then tear it apart.

+1, and double check the torque of the bottom nuts. I suppose it is unlike that you'd damage the inner seals on both sides.
 
Clean it up real good, check all the nuts and drive it.
Just keep and eye on it and dip a wire in the knuckle from time to time.
 
Another vote on keeping an eye on it. I use the same grease Dan uses (per his recommendation) and I have the exact same wet-looking birf and my rebuild was a little over a year ago. The seepage is lessening and my knuckle grease appears to be normal. Dan Kunz sp? (not the avocado owner) had the same issue and we both came to the conclusion that it is the grease separating.

As long as you followed the axle service protocol you should be fine. Keep an eye on things and make sure the nuts stay tight. With the additional oil seepage, I'd imagine it would give those pesky buggers even more coercion to come loose. As long as the nuts are tight, the knuckle is full of grease, and there is no oil/grease exchange between the diff/knuckle you should be good to go. It's prolly not a bad idea to top the knuckles off with a little more moly grease down the road to help compensate for any oil separation/loss.
 
I use the same grease and when it sits in the gun for to long I get a bunch of oil seperation, there is actually a little puddle where the gun is sitting in my self.
 
It's totally normal. The better greases are ofter over saturated with oil and a little separates. Wipe off what you don't like, check it again in a couple of months.

When the seals leak, it's pretty obvious, and there is a lot more goo around the knuckle ball.
 
Back
Top Bottom