Is this water pump bad?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 26, 2004
Threads
116
Messages
1,282
Location
Oregon
Website
www.brian894x4.com
Getting started on a major coolent PM and now that I most everything torn down, I inspected the water pump on the engine. With only about 96,000 miles, I wasn't expecting to replace it, but now I'm not so sure.

It's been a while since I've played with a water pump, but I seem to remember that they are usually very smooth and make no noise when you turn them.

On mine, there is definately slight drag and it's somewhat of a jerky drag when I turn the pump. Also, it makes a constant sound, when turning either direction that sounds like a faint door creaking. I have no in and out movement and essentially no side to side movement. I mean can just barely feel a very, very slight movement if I push on it, but I think this is normal. There's no weaping that I can see.

Based on this, I'm pretty sure the pump is bad, but I want to get some opinions before I order and make sure this isn't perfectly normal somehow. Even if the pump is only starting to go bad, I'd figure now is a good time to replace since everything is apart and it's right there easy to R & R.

Thanks for any opinions.
 
Well, I wouldn't want to convince you to leave it in and then find out you had problems later, but: I'll bet it's fine.

1) The "slight creaking" sounds to me like just a very tight seal with no coolant (it's drained, right?) to lubricate it.

2) The only thing that concerns me at all is that you say the drag is "somewhat jerky". If you really mean that when you try to rotate it as steadily and constantly as possible, it stil "grabs" at a certain point, then yeah, that doesn't sound good. But I'll bet you just mean that the static friction (as you start to try to spin it) is a bit stronger than the rolling friction (while it's spinning).

3) The bearings (which I'd think are fine from your desription) and weep hole seem like by far the most important aspects to me.

Maybe others have had a different experience and will disagree.

We'll see,

Curtis
 
It's junk. Even if it didn't feel like a bad bearing (which is what it sounds like from my chair), it's in your hand, it has 100,THOUSAND miles on it, and it's in your hand. Replace it. Even if you don't actually buy one, get your hands on a new factory WP and compare the feel of them side by side. Give yourself an idea what they're supposed to feel like.

-Spike
 
I'm with Spike. It's one of things, you are there at home, the pump has 100k and 13 years on it. Do you want to replace it trailside at midnight? You can pick up a Japanese Aisin/asco pump for around $50... well worth it.

You're kidding...that cheap? The same pump as from the dealer I assume? The best non-C-dan price I've seen on a '95 pump from the dealer (they claim wholesale price) was about $140. Retail is over $170. This is the most expensive water pump I've seen. Most of the Toyota and Subaru pumps I've bought in the past, even from dealers were around $60.
 
List on a new OEM pump is $176.89.
 
Now that I've pulled my off to inspect, I can see why it costs so much. This is the heaviest duty water pump that I've seen. Not that I've seen that many. It looks like it has multiple shaft bearings, which probably is why most last so long.

The noise and feel I had I think can be attributed to the shaft seal. Once I fiddled with, there was no more noise and the drag seemed fairly smooth and normal. Pump will probably last another 150K. The only thing I'm not sure about is the shaft seal.
 
Back
Top Bottom