Injector Balance vs OEM replacement

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 5, 2006
Threads
404
Messages
1,234
Post #55 on a thread that lost it's way, reminded me of a question I have been meaning to ask.

https://forum.ih8mud.com/80-series-...d-would-you-supercharge-all-over-again-2.html


What is the benefit (performance & cost) of having the injectors balanced & rebuilt vs just getting a fresh set ?

Do you know how much new injectors cost--even with the CDan price break?

For 6?

Not something I would want to do unless I was doing an entire long block rebuild.

I had my injectors done for $110 shipped and when they got back they pretty much looked just like they did before except a lot prettier.

Now, the spec. sheet had all sorts of technical flow information/drop per minute etc. And some of those improved from before to after. But most of the injectors--4 of them IIRC, were within OEM spec. for what they come new.

IMHO, send them out and be done with it.
-o-
 
I have no idea on the cost. My question was two parts, both the cost benefit & performance over OEM
 
I have no idea on the cost. My question was two parts, both the cost benefit & performance over OEM

Well injectors cost well over $100 a piece if not more....

From my (limited) understanding of the process of balancing and tuning injectors, you can get original OEM performance through this process.

-o-
 
the cost for that is going to be around 250.00. A good chuck of that is the next day shipping there and back so you have less down time. I don't think there is any performance benefit over going new it's just that you reclaim that performance again. I don't know what year truck you are driving but the O2 sensors are used for tuning the AFR in our trucks. Since they see more than on cylinder at a time it's more of an average and not specific to each injector. So having them balanced helps keep all the cylinders running correctly. That helps with performance and fuel economy.
 
Who is the best on cleaning them? Mike

Both RC Engineering and Witchhunter are reputable shops for injector servicing. Both places have been used by any number of Mudders and I don't remember ever reading a compliant about either one.
 
Just as another option, Robbie recommended Witch Hunter Performance for my injectors. They were 1/2 to 1/3 as expensive as RC Engineering and all my injectors came back within .06% (not 6% or .6% but .06% !!!) from highest to lowest. BTW, there was another thread around recently where someone who should remain nameless disputed the benefits of balancing and cleaning injectors and suggested that BG alone does the same thing. Well, in the real world I know that I use BG 44K every 5K miles and have also done the fuel rail regimen and my injectors, while pretty good to start with, still benefited from balancing and cleaning. YMWV (your mileage won't vary) :D :flipoff2: :D
 
Just as another option, Robbie recommended Witch Hunter Performance for my injectors. They were 1/2 to 1/3 as expensive as RC Engineering and all my injectors came back within .06% (not 6% or .6% but .06% !!!) from highest to lowest. BTW, there was another thread around recently where someone who should remain nameless disputed the benefits of balancing and cleaning injectors and suggested that BG alone does the same thing. Well, in the real world I know that I use BG 44K every 5K miles and have also done the fuel rail regimen and my injectors, while pretty good to start with, still benefited from balancing and cleaning. YMWV (your mileage won't vary) :D :flipoff2: :D

I resemble that remark. Do what you want, I claim if an injector is in spec, you won't measure an engine performance difference. I won't argue the point, but will say injector cleaning isn't rocket science either. And IME/O the biggest benefit from any injector recon comes from just replacing the screen and putting the injector back in the rail - btdt many times. Ebay "Mr. Injector" ( http://stores.ebay.com/Mr-Injector ) for 25bucks you can do this yourself and learn one more thing about your truck - hint get the 8cylinder service kit, allows you to screw up on 2. He also offers injector cleaning, AND give you tips on how to do it yourself.

Ask any factory/independent marque shop if this is a recommended procedure. Not many will agree - injectors either pass a series of specifications or they fail them. I have a couple sets of injector bench testing tools, one for CIS and one for EFI, I rarely use them, because poor engine performance is rarely an injector problem (and OBDII all but took bench testing out of the equation). I saw a report posted on this forum that 'claimed' benefit at 4%. 2% difference is within Bosch factory tolerance of a Type I or II injector. So, is the 2% 'effective' gain worth the 200?

If it passes the FSM tests, I recommend leaving it alone. Injector service/PM is not part of toyota manufacturer recommendation at any mileage. If an injector is out of spec, cleaning may prove cheaper than replacement. But as a PM, I think there's better places to throw your money. You don't need to spend 200 bucks to find out if an injector is bad or needs attention.

YOMV

Scott J
'94 FZJ80 Supercharged - 166k, 55k with SC on stock injectors
 
Last edited:
I don't have the needed equipment to properly evaluate an injector as being in spec or not. So I have a reputable company do that for me. I'm good with having spent a little money to ensure that my injectors are operating at peak performance. On my truck I saw a MPG increase afterward so it wasn't a waste of time at all.
 
I don't have the needed equipment to properly evaluate an injector as being in spec or not. So I have a reputable company do that for me. I'm good with having spent a little money to ensure that my injectors are operating at peak performance. On my truck I saw a MPG increase afterward so it wasn't a waste of time at all.

According to the FSM, you only need a beaker, a MM, and some 12 v jumpers. I used to steal the beaker from the kitchen back in the 80's cking my CIS cars. Simple easy tests, the Haynes manuals even have pictures of injector spray patterns to compare if you are unsure.

Increase in mileage on a 4% difference? How 'much' better? The 'after' results on the injectors you posted didn't even get mid factory spec. Thinking about this excellent post....
https://forum.ih8mud.com/80-series-tech/251986-heres-why-your-mileage-varies.html

If you have 'a' bad injector, clean or replace it. To do them all just because, especially on an OBDII truck, seems like a waste of good money. Millions of cars and trucks running around this country with hundreds of thousands of miles on them. The overwhelming majority (even on this forum) without replacing or servicing a single injector. Maybe Dan can ask some of his master techs about the *value* of this procedure (not the 'added value' of this service to the ticket). I say it's unnecessary, and by the FSM specs, not even qualifying as overkill.

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
Last edited:
I resemble that remark. Do what you want, I claim if an injector is in spec, you won't measure an engine performance difference.

Sheesh, not even I can save you from yourself! :D :flipoff2: :D I didn't claim a "performance difference" in terms of the HP or torque or anything but it simply stands to reason that with the injectors balanced and all running 308+ versus a range of say "288 to 302", "performance" will increase in the sense of much more similar combustion chamber energies, much more similar emissions chamber to chamber and a much better reading and response from the O2 sensors as a result. I don't think there's a "2+2" out there that can argue against that but whip out the fuzzy math foolishness if you want. In any event also not "recommending" this as another PM on its own; in my case we had the injectors out for the HG PM (pulease don't try to math out the value of that either) and it was a "might as well" thing that I decided to do and also based basically on Robbie's recommendation. Lastly, my experience essentially proves that the performance of the injectors does degrade even with extra maintenance by way of BG 44K and BG fuel rail flush which I thought was what you arguing about in the other thread? Anyhoo, with or without your permission or recommendation I will do what I want and I'm glad I did, thanks. :bang:
 
lots of words + sumotoy=word vomit
 
Sheesh, not even I can save you from yourself! :D :flipoff2: :D I didn't claim a "performance difference" in terms of the HP or torque or anything but it simply stands to reason that with the injectors balanced and all running 308+ versus a range of say "288 to 302", "performance" will increase in the sense of much more similar combustion chamber energies, much more similar emissions chamber to chamber and a much better reading and response from the O2 sensors as a result. I don't think there's a "2+2" out there that can argue against that but whip out the fuzzy math foolishness if you want. In any event also not "recommending" this as another PM on its own; in my case we had the injectors out for the HG PM (pulease don't try to math out the value of that either) and it was a "might as well" thing that I decided to do and also based basically on Robbie's recommendation. Lastly, my experience essentially proves that the performance of the injectors does degrade even with extra maintenance by way of BG 44K and BG fuel rail flush which I thought was what you arguing about in the other thread? Anyhoo, with or without your permission or recommendation I will do what I want and I'm glad I did, thanks. :bang:

I could care less *if* you do it. I don't agree it's PM, I don't agree you can measure a difference, and I don't believe it should be a recommended procedure. I claim the cylinder variance on a 100k (even a freshly rebuilt) motor is beyond injector balancing by a significant factor. Do a compression ck, or a leak down test, what's the variance between cylinders? The FSM lists 8% variance between cylinder pressures on the highest/new motor compression spec (171psi and 14psi variance=8%). FSM on Fuel Injector flow is avg296cc x 8% = 264cc, which just happens to be the 'low' fuel injector spec variance. So what good is a 'balanced' injector, as long as it's within factory spec?

The difference between what I read here, and guys that deal with CIS and EFI all the time for a living, is just 'n'. The stock injectors on the 80 are overkill. The stock Bosch production tolerance would be excellent at 2% differences. The stock FSM diagnostic for fuel injectors is well documented. Servicing them in any fashion, lacks documentation for good reason. The logic should be to just get new injectors, cuz cleaning only gets you to mid spec. So new should get you the 'best' spec?

I know what this procedure does, and it's potential benefits. 25 years of turbo cars running 3-4 times the boost level of any truck here, never did a batch injector clean as PM. Never had to. Have I diagnosed bad injectors? Sure. Have I replaced screens and cleaned out injectors with compressed air and some solvent? Sure. Would I ever recommend taking 6 good injectors and dumping 200bucks having them cleaned and balanced (there is no such thing in reality). Never. At most, use the FSM, diagnose which are bad, and send those off if Mr. Injector parts install are intimidating.

I just don't find injectors mysterious or require expertise to diagnose and service properly. The argument starts because folks want to justify the expense. I say you can't unless you did the FSM test, and then it's per injector service, not the lot.

The hardest part of injector service is the R&R of the injector. I claim if you can do that correctly on your own without blowing up the truck, you can spend 20bucks with Mr. Injector, and save 10 times the money you spent. Again, I'd love to hear C-dan's comments via his master techs.

YOMV

Scott J
'94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
Last edited:
OK, before this thread get's off track as usual, there was a thread a while back in which it was discussed if your injectors really could possibly be "balanced". My opinion is you can't balance them. You can clean them up to like new condition, but i don't see how you would balance them. Only changing the injector tip or the amount of fuel being sent to them can change how much spray they emit. That's just my opinion.

I personally am seriously considering purchasing a $60 ultra sonic jewelry cleaner. Put them in the jewelry cleaning machine that sonically cleans them. I won't be able to have fancy paper work but i could do all my vehicles plus some friends and family for a small investment.
 
I read Robbie's posts from 04 and 05 on the topic. Without putting words in his mouth, I'm not sure he disagrees with anything I posted. The easiest thing to do is to pull them and ship them off. That's different from necessary, or recommended. They are not balanced, they are cleaned then flow tested per the FSM. Which can be done without shipping them anywhere.

Otherwise, he has good advice on which additives to use and how. He claims the R&R time on the injectors is 3hrs, which tends to confirm my claim that's the 'hard' part of this R&R.

I don't jump with him or anyone here, to the 'do them all' conclusion, even installing a SC. The factory tests are adequate to evaluate the need to clean or replace any given injector. I still don't know how an injector in specification vs one in specification realizes a performance gain. That was not explained to me well.

Concrete Jungle, there are several guys on other forums that used jewelry cleaners to clean injectors. And, in fact, IIRC there are many cleaning services that show pictures of commonly available jewelry cleaners as part of the cleaning process. And I agree fully, that 'balancing' is not an appropriate term for this procedure. At best, an incidental coincidence of the before and after cleaning process.

Thanks for any patience to my position that the FSM appears to be the best reference material to identifying the need for this procedure.

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
Last edited:
OK, before this thread get's off track as usual, there was a thread a while back in which it was discussed if your injectors really could possibly be "balanced". My opinion is you can't balance them. You can clean them up to like new condition, but i don't see how you would balance them. Only changing the injector tip or the amount of fuel being sent to them can change how much spray they emit. That's just my opinion.

I personally am seriously considering purchasing a $60 ultra sonic jewelry cleaner. Put them in the jewelry cleaning machine that sonically cleans them. I won't be able to have fancy paper work but i could do all my vehicles plus some friends and family for a small investment.

For the record I don't think that they can be balanced either at least in the sense of shaving some here or adding some there as in "balancing a block" what I'm referring to as the balance is the fact that after their cleaning they came out within .06% of one another. The right word isn't balancing so please pardon me for throwing that term out. Still I argue that whether it results in more HP or torque (which I never implied) the combustion chamber energies, emissions etc will be better balanced (again prolly the wrong term here) then they were when the lowest injector was at 288 and the highest was at 302. That's all. I do agree about what yer sayin here. :cheers:
 
Back
Top Bottom