Hub issues

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 18, 2005
Threads
81
Messages
4,158
Location
Fort St John, BC
Hey all,
I have a question, I have had my hubs off a million times, and never had a problem. However after having my tires changed, the idiots striped a wheel stud, so I had them replace it. On saturday I got stuck in a ditch so I went to lock my hubs, and it didn't move. it was in the free position, yet it was locked, because when I hammered on it, the tire spun. I tried taking it off, but after pulling all the 10mm bolts, it would not slide out, and I was just pulling it apart, the springs were getting yanked apart. I didn't want to wreck the hub, so I bolted it back on and now took it back to the tire shop for them to fix their own F-up. What the hell did they do????? how dumb can you be to put a hub on wrong? I am really mad, and want this nightmare to end, I don't want to go back any more. Has anyone had this happen, or know what is wrong, and how to fix it?
I am going to pick it up at lunch today, so I am wondering what to do if they tell me they can't fix it.
Thanks,
Deny
 
Last edited:
I tried everything, it won't move either way. what gets me is it wouldn't slide out. I have never had a problem before, until they touched it. my only guess is that the put it to a position where it wouldn't go on, and instead of rotating it to get it to a spot where it would slide right on, they hammered it on. when I tried taking it apart, I tried twisting the hub, but it didn't help either.
 
I have aisins. Does anyone know how much they cost from Toyota, so I have some numbers to throw down when I go back to see what they have done?
 
Just yank it off and do a post mortem. If its fubared I'll bring out another one to Cruiser Day in Vancouver next weekend. Chances are that it is just assembled wrong and you should be able to reassemble it right.

I hate letting other people work on my trucks. As bad a mechanic as I am, there are plenty of 'professionals' who are far and away worse.
 
What did the inside look like.Grease or 30wt,Grease makes it stuck,common tire shop mistake.In free,it should slide out because the spring is pulled back.I have seen people spin the hub so it's locked,"spring out"then use bearing grease.So it's stuck and won't slide.Good luck with shop time.Rob
 
Last edited:
Yeah Bruce,
I feel the same way, initially I just wanted to just leave the stud stripped, but then I was mad that they messed up, and I changed my appointment to after the long weekend, because I was scared they would screw up something. I though they would over or under tighten my wheel bearings, not mess up installing the hub. I think a monkey could do that. Thanks for the hub offer, but we have a bunch at home. My plans are if they mess it up, get them to give me all my money back for the tire install, borrow a hub form a local cruiser guy up here in FSJ, then grab one at home during cruiser days.
So how would I yank it apart if it doesn't come out? just pull till the springs let go, then somehow jim shim the rest out?
Cheers,
Deny
 
my guess it they put the hub back on with the spring tight (compresssed, Ie for the free position) than then put the dial in the lock position. Anyway.. I would just deal with it myself. Here is a nice page for you to look at if you do. It's pretty easy to pull apart and put back together. I have some parts if needed. Also part off a sammi will work too.

http://www.pirate4x4.com/forum/showthread.php?t=281879
 
Thanks guys,
Rob, it did have grease, maybe if I pulled harder, it would have come off, I just didn't want to break it, and wanted them to either fix it of pay, because I am really getting tired of their stupidness.
Wes, it is locked, but in the free position?
I will see what they say today at noon, and give you guys an update, I have a feeling they will break it, not say anything and say they fixed it, I don't trust these guys at all anymore.
Cheers,
Deny
 
if they installed the hub with the spring compressed for a free position but in a lock mode you would be able to turn the dial. So who knows what they did. ;)
 
wesintl said:
if they installed the hub with the spring compressed for a free position but in a lock mode you would be able to turn the dial. ;)
:grinpimp:" Bingo" I'v seen that more than once.
 
Well, I got my truck back, and according to the service writer, the mechanic said that "it was slightly rotated around, and he must of put it in a little bit off, and it works perfectly now." I will pull it apart, and make sure it works before I believe them though. I still don't get how it could have happened, I just hope it's still good and they didn't really wreck it. I have faith that the Hub is pretty tough, and an idiot pulling on it will not break it.
Thanks again guys,
Deny
 
glad ya got it fixed. FYI new Aisan hubs are $300 or so each

Deny said:
I have aisins. Does anyone know how much they cost from Toyota, so I have some numbers to throw down when I go back to see what they have done?
 
Good that was most common rookie hub problem.When you have it off look at the cast"tit"where the steel ring is clocked on the body.That is where it will crack if loaded wrong and torqued down.Most times it makes the hub not slide together,so the installer knows he did somthing wrong.And starts rotating the outer body. :cheers: weekend is almost here.
 
< most common rookie hub problem.>

See I thought this at first too, but I remember pulling the hub the first time, and I pulled it out in the free position, put it to the side, then when I went to bolt it up I put it back in the same position, it just seems too easy, and I don't understand how they messed up. Oh well, hopefully it is good now, especially for my long trip down south, can't wait!
 
Well the Nightmare continues!
I got home yesturday, and took the cover of my hub off, and all they did was simply take the spring off the cover, so now instead of it being perminantly on, it is perminantly on, with it being able to swing from free to lock, but nothing happens inside. I took a closer look at the inside gears, and saw that they put the one tooth that can go into one of only two places into a place where only the normal teeth can fit. Don't ask me how they did it, cause I can only imagine them hammering it on. I am really pissed, and they are looking at it right now, I don't know how that will help, if they already seen it and lied to me that it was fixed, but apparently they had the junior mechanic doing it and now are putting the head mechanic on it. I am curious to see what they will tell me now. Any suggestions?
 
Sometimes it's better to cut your losses.

If you are deturmined to win this one, make sure to try it out before it leaves the shop. Tell them you want to inspect it while still on the hoist. If it fails this time, tell them you are taking it to the dealer on their dime and have the wheel bearings inspected, repacked, and retorqued and he hub replaced. If they did not replace the star washer you should probably inspect it anyway. They are technically not reusable even though we generally do.

After three return visits I believe you are within your rights to have another shop do the work and back charge them. It might cost you a day in court though. Alternatively if you paid with a credit card. (which you should always do with an unknown vender) you can call the CC and have them withhold the payment, pending rectification of the problems.
 
Yeah,
I'm hoping they say they can't fix it and have to order a new hub from Toyota, and I will offer that they pay me the 100 bucks I spent for the tire replacement, then just rip it off, and take one of the hubs from one of our parts trucks back home. I am tired of them just monkeying around, and am scared everytime I leave it there that they will mess something else up. I did notice I can get to the axle snap ring, so it will be easy to rip off, maybe I can even hammer the inner part right through, then attach it to the spring and put it all back together properly.
The CC company probably already paid them, because the tires were put on almost a month ago, it's just the never ending story.
 
Back
Top Bottom