Full steel rear bumper vs Pakmule Pro Cargo Carrier vs Hitch Tire Swing

[hskb]

Hi all,
I am looking for a good way to carry the tire. Weight is an important factor, $ is always matter, but it's one time thing, so I don't mind spending it for the right reasons.
For the pakmule, it looks real tough, and can carry lot of gears
Thanks for your inputs.


Pakmule Pro Cargo Carrier / Hitch Tire Swing / Full steel rear bumper with swings out
1. Cheapest one. Pakmule Pro Cargo Carrier Black - $1500 shipped

PAKMULE PRO

The PAKMULE PRO is the next evolution in hitch racks—stronger, tougher, and more capable than ever, legit, try and find us a better one.

pakmule.com

I already have a high GenY hitch, and thinking of using the third hole to get some ground clearance.

Amazon.com: GEN-Y Hitch Tow Hitch with Dual-Ball Mount for 2" Receiver - 5" Drop/Rise with 3 Adjustable Positions, 16,000 lbs Towing Capacity, 2,000 lbs Tongue Weight, Silver : Automotive

Buy GEN-Y Hitch Tow Hitch with Dual-Ball Mount for 2" Receiver - 5" Drop/Rise with 3 Adjustable Positions, 16,000 lbs Towing Capacity, 2,000 lbs Tongue Weight, Silver: Receivers - Amazon.com ✓ FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases

www.amazon.com

2. Hitch Tire Swing $2000 (Ultra Swing or Trail Swing)


3. Full steel rear bumper with swings out $ 3200
(Victory4x4 rear bumper + 2 swings out + tire mount )

 

[David310]

The goal is to move the spare tire out from under the vehicle? Is there a reason such as bigger tires? 35s clear in stock location. I have gone through all 3. I still have the PakMule for cargo but sold the Rig’d swingout.

 

[hskb]

Thanks Dave, 35s clear in stock option?
Mine is only 33.4, and I don't think I need a tire carrier then.

In terms of of protection off roading? How useful is a rear bumper?

 

[GTV]

I have a 35x11.50 in the stock location. All I had to do to get it to fit was remove the hitch. I also then raised the spare for more clearance. A steel bumper obviously will offer more protection but that depends on how you use it and if that is really needed.

 

[David310]

Yes, 35” tires will fit without the under bumper hitch. If you need a hitch, you can bolt one to the crossmember mount. Since you’re on 33s, you could run a setup like the one in this image, but for technical trails it’s better to relocate the spare. I’d recommend a rear bumper with a swing-out since on tough terrain you’ll end up leaving the PakMule behind, and the Rig’D sits too far off the body hurting departure angle.

 

[hskb]

I know I will regret, but I just ordered the Pakmule. I really don't want to carry all that weight in the back for little protection on extreme departure angle.
As for the tire carrier, I just use the Pakmule on fireroad, camping, and the like. For technical trails, i might just put the spare in the back of the truck

By the way, the stock spare tire carrier CAN NOT hold bigger tire unless the OEM hitch removed, and I am not willing to remove the hitch.

 

[David310]

Can’t go wrong. Perfect for urban duty. Took mine on a trip from Dallas to Chicago.