For those with WideBands

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 27, 2003
Threads
385
Messages
21,383
Location
Groveland MA
Website
landtankproducts.com
I was hoping that those who have installed wideband O2 sensors could give me a little info. What I'm looking for is the AFR during idling. That's it, nothing too elaborate for now. If you want to add whether it has a stock or modded MAF that's fine but not needed but the age of the front O2 sensor if known would be good.

Thanks
 
Almost always 14.7 unless it is super hot here then it will sometimes sweep to as lean as 16 for a few seconds and then goto 14.7 again. (Of course when we say "14.7" it is switching slowly between 14.5, 14.9 . :cheers:
 
Ooops, just saw the second part of the question, both of my O2 sensors were recently replaced less than a thousand miles ago. HTH. :cheers:
 
I was hoping for more responses but this will have to do.

My thought was to get an idea of where the ECM adjusts AFR for idle. I've read that the most fuel efficient AFR is actually 16:1. Now this isn't a good idea for an engine under load but idling would definitely be OK.

Now considering that boosted trucks are running around 10.8:1 which is on the rich sid, I was looking into augmenting the ECM so that idle it wold be closer to the 16:1 which would also bring down the WOT end to be more in line with what we want.

A lot of this would depend on what the AFR is during the transition from idle to heavy load but if it worked out we would have higher fuel efficiency and better performance.

Since my exhaust is oiut of the truck I'm going to have the wideband bung installed and play around with this.
 
I may be wrong about all this but I would think that as long as the truck is in closed loop operation it is going to strive to stay at around 14.7. :confused:
 
Commonly accepted most "efficient" AFR is the 14.7:1, so that's what the stock ECM works for . .. . Rick, where did you read about this 16:1 school of thought?

edit--actually, the 14.7:1 ratio is just the ratio at which all major pollutants tend to run at their lowest--it's the trade-off AFR for emissions reasons. The 16:1 AFR will see an increase in NOx emissions, comparatively speaking.
 
Last edited:
Commonly accepted most "efficient" AFR is the 14.7:1, so that's what the stock ECM works for . .. . Rick, where did you read about this 16:1 school of thought?

edit--actually, the 14.7:1 ratio is just the ratio at which all major pollutants tend to run at their lowest--it's the trade-off AFR for emissions reasons. The 16:1 AFR will see an increase in NOx emissions, comparatively speaking.

I'll see if I can find it again. There is a whole site devoted to lean running engines. As you say the trade off is higher NOX but these guys have gone as far as 25:1 and stayed within guide lines I believe. And that is their premise, do no harm to the engine and stay within emission standards. I've had enough tests done that a properly running Toyota usually blow zeros on the emission tests so there is room to raise the output some and still meet the guide lines.

Here is an online manual for tuning an engine, manual.

It seems to go into the basics on how things are setup and how driving style effects AFR choices.

I'm not saying it's a bible to AFR but just looking at it as a guide line.
 
Last edited:
Yes, you can usually push the engine leaner in idle or part throttle scenarios but the whole WOT is not as forgiving as you guys have stated before.

On another note, tailpipe test Pass/Fail criteria is actually _supposed_ to be more forgiving than the parameters required to turn on the MIL on an OBDII vehicle. You're right, it's not hard to get a maintained, properly running vehicle to pass a tailpipe test.

I'm curious to see where they say the switch between lean and richer needs to take place in the throttle/load/etc. to protect the engine. If you can tweak the ECM to deal with that, that'd be a freaking coup.
 
I always thought that as you vary the fuel to air ratio, the EGT first increases, then reaches a peak, then decreases again. So unless you use the extra fuel in a too-rich configuration for cooling purpsoses, if the engine is able to run smoothly on the lean-of peak side, the only problem is NOX. Is there any other problem with running too lean (WOT or not) that I am missing?
 
the whole WOT is not as forgiving as you guys have stated before.

That was my thinking. I believe I can globally influence the AFR and with WOT already too rich, moving it a little leaner across the board might yield some nice results.

There is a web site out there with guys putting resistors on the IAT sensors on their Saturns and getting 50MPG. That's like a 40% increase I think.

One of the things that brought me here is that when I replaced my front O2 sensor I lost 3 MPG. If you look back at various posts I was always above 16MPG fully modified before the part replacement. It had to be running leaner and no harm came to my truck because of it.
 
That was my thinking. I believe I can globally influence the AFR and with WOT already too rich, moving it a little leaner across the board might yield some nice results.

There is a web site out there with guys putting resistors on the IAT sensors on their Saturns and getting 50MPG. That's like a 40% increase I think.

One of the things that brought me here is that when I replaced my front O2 sensor I lost 3 MPG. If you look back at various posts I was always above 16MPG fully modified before the part replacement. It had to be running leaner and no harm came to my truck because of it.

Running leaner with a worn-out front O2 sensor seems counter intuitive, though. I thought that situation usually resulted in a rich condition because of a false lean reading out of the O2 sensor. I remember seeing your posts about higher MPG.

How would the resistors affect the IAT readings? Make them appear hotter to cause the engine to cut back on fuel?
 
Running leaner with a worn-out front O2 sensor seems counter intuitive, though. I thought that situation usually resulted in a rich condition because of a false lean reading out of the O2 sensor. I remember seeing your posts about higher MPG.

I'm not sure what was going on with my sensor, I only know how it hit the wallet.


How would the resistors affect the IAT readings? Make them appear hotter to cause the engine to cut back on fuel?

Yes they mount the resistors in parallel to the IAT sensor to give a false reading of warmer air which the ECM then pulls fuel out of it. I don't understand why the system doesn't react to it and automatically richen the mixture back up but that is what they are all reporting.
 
Yes they mount the resistors in parallel to the IAT sensor to give a false reading of warmer air which the ECM then pulls fuel out of it. I don't understand why the system doesn't react to it and automatically richen the mixture back up but that is what they are all reporting.

You would think the false reading from the IAT and resultant AFR would be in conflict with the O2 sensor feedback. Maybe IAT has a higher priority in influencing AFR because it's pre-combustion, meaning the ECM has to start somewhere to determine the mix.
 
You would think the false reading from the IAT and resultant AFR would be in conflict with the O2 sensor feedback. Maybe IAT has a higher priority in influencing AFR because it's pre-combustion, meaning the ECM has to start somewhere to determine the mix.


Who knows, one thing I can tell you is that even within the same manufacturer these ECMs can differ in how they do things and react to changes. They all might be labeled OBDII but that doesn't mean they all work the same.
 
I'm not sure what was going on with my sensor, I only know how it hit the wallet.




Yes they mount the resistors in parallel to the IAT sensor to give a false reading of warmer air which the ECM then pulls fuel out of it. I don't understand why the system doesn't react to it and automatically richen the mixture back up but that is what they are all reporting.

Cattledog introduced this thought to me. How about a variable/adjustable resistor monitored with the wideband?
 
Cattledog introduced this thought to me. How about a variable/adjustable resistor monitored with the wideband?

on our system monkeying around with the IAT sensor will only yield short lived results. I opened up the spare ECM I have and it's made by the same company as the controllers on the old copiers that I used to work on. The layout is very similar and I'm familiar with those.

Basically all the signals come into the ECM and then pass through a resistor before moving on to the processor. So manipulating that resistor value will cause a shift in the signal the processor sees.

So in the case of the O2 sensor, if we swap in a lower resistor, the processor will see a higher voltage meaning it's running rich and then drop the FT% until it sees what it wants. So basically instead of idling at 14.7 maybe it's now 15.2.

The ECM is quite nicely marked out with all the lines labeled to what signal is passing through them. I've only done a basic survey of the PCB but it is very similar to ones that I used to work on in Canon Copiers. Only in the copiers they had VRs in place of these surface mount resistors.
 
So when is lean too lean, and how do you tell? Where do you draw the line.

Knock sensor feedback the line? I view the knock sensor as feedback on incorrect cylinder combustion. Two thing off the top of my head that cause knocking are high cylinder temps and timing that is too advanced for the combustion mixture. If you run lean by modifing the sensor data. I would drop the timing a bit from the stock position.

My thought on the variable pot on the high voltage line to the fuel pump would only kick in during WOT. How fast is the response time for the wideband sensors? Narrowbands suck for feedback that is why open loop is around 2800 to 3200 rpm. I think that is why most narrow band OBDII run rick a WOT high RPM. I only ask about responsetime because WOT usually means high rpm.
 
So when is lean too lean, and how do you tell?

From what I can tell 14.7 is ideal for emissions and 16.0 is ideal for fuel economy


If you run lean by modifying the sensor data. I would drop the timing a bit from the stock position.

I think your putting the kart before the horse here Dave.

The big hurtle is how accurate are the results of modifying the data on an engine that is 11 years old. Look at the recent HG thread by Riad. Those piston tops looked like crap. If one was to manipulate the sensor data on that truck and had a detonation issue where would you point the finger?

I'm thinking this will be a fun winter project and don't mean to put down anyone's suggestions. I like the back and fourth so I might get a game plan in place for testing.
 
From what I can tell 14.7 is ideal for emissions and 16.0 is ideal for fuel economy




I think your putting the kart before the horse here Dave.

The big hurtle is how accurate are the results of modifying the data on an engine that is 11 years old. Look at the recent HG thread by Riad. Those piston tops looked like crap. If one was to manipulate the sensor data on that truck and had a detonation issue where would you point the finger?

I'm thinking this will be a fun winter project and don't mean to put down anyone's suggestions. I like the back and fourth so I might get a game plan in place for testing.

I agree with the carbon buildup issues, so you would need to inspect the piston tops and check injector flow? But most people will have a good amount of carbon build up in this engine due to the oil squirters under the pistons. High octane fuel would only make the carbon buildup worst.

We could check your truck with a 3 foot bore-a-scope, I have a lighted one at work.
 
Back
Top Bottom